Buttermilk Sky Pie Flower Mound

PROs: Great location. Friendly service. Yummy pies! Packaged well for 'to go'. Nutrition values posted on the website.
CONs: Gluten free options available but must be preordered. Sugar content is close to 2 soda cans for (1) 4" pie. I didn't see a sugar free pie listed, is there such?

I brought home: coconut cream, PB, chocolate and lemon. All were sinfully good.

Outstanding all around!! Had fresh samples available. I ordered the custard and it was just phenomenal. Staff was welcoming, friendly and informative. Will definitely make the trip back with my family, thanks!

The owner and her staff are always pleasant and kind. The pies and thumbprint (peppermint are my favorite) cookies are always fresh and tasty. They have the best key lime and strawberry pies!

Friendly staff, loved the key lime pie. There is no place to sit down and eat, so we brought a small one home and ate. As I lived in South FL for many years and had some really good key lime pies, this one is pretty close to the ones I had in S. Florida. I am definitely going back and will try other bestsellers they’ve mentioned.

Thank you for making my husband’s 40th birthday sweet! We purchased the Apple & a Key Lime & they were delicious. We polished the key lime off quick! Thank you to her kind baker Beth, for bringing some personal pies to my work and introducing us to their product! Thank you to Braden for his helpfulness over the phone! We’ll be back!

Definitely returning! Easy online order, easy pick up. Got the 4-pack 4” pies: key lime, chocolate, I-40, and cherry. Keep reading.....

Key lime - solid flavor, consistency, tartness well balanced with sweet, personal request for more whip cream coverage. Tastes like my recipe when I’m not busy making the rest of the menu.

Chocolate- straight up delicious! Dark chocolate filling, not runny at all. I was a little concerned at the price but this pie is def worth every bit ! I’ve never had a chocolate pie I’ve enjoyed this much.... Suggest a French roast espresso along side this beauty!

And haven’t tried the other 2 yet - as I need to make some ice cream to accompany.

I placed a large order with Wade for 54 pies and a ton of cookies and bite sized pies for a party we were throwing. Wade was very easy to work with, mostly over email which was convenient for me and he even delivered our order. Everything was delicious and we have received so many wonderful compliments from our clients on how good the pies were. We will definitely order from them again next year!

My uncle wanted a pecan pie for his 95th birthday so I preordered online, which was quick and easy. It was ready for pickup at the time we requested and my uncle thoroughly enjoyed it. I also ordered him red white and blue cookies because he's a veteran.

I ordered a bunch of different flavor pies for a graduation party, loved all the flavors, Key lime & I-40 are personal favs! Thank you Amy & staff!!!

Well worth the stop. The pies are excellent. We got the peanut butter pie. The small is good for a desert for two. You will want more but control yourself.

We used Buttermilk Sky Pies for our wedding this past November! Amy and Wade were nothing but helpful and all of our guests loved their pies! It was such a sweet touch to our wedding!

We’re in love with these pies, and the service and especially their to-go ice cream and pie desserts!!! Best pies on the planet!!

The best customer service! And talk about a warm welcoming with the coziness of the decor and recommendations from all the staff. I was greeted by a young man- asked what his favorite was and without hesitation said Key Lime! My husband and I don’t “cheat” on dessert much but when we do it will be from here moving forward. Also love that it’s owned by a local family!!!!!!

Not only are the pies utterly amazing, so are the people!! We love Buttermilk Sky Pie and we're pretty sure you will too!

I treated myself to some birthday pies. I was not disappointed they were very well prepared and the service was great.

My favorite dessert spot! Love the key lime pie and the apple pie. The crust is delicious and the filling is made to perfection. Amy, the owner, is kind and always helpful. She has a awesome crew working with her to always make my experience a great one.

Excellent pies. Got the 4 pies pack and all of them including my usual fav Key lime were amazing.

Such delicious pie and amazing customer service! The day before thanksgiving, i walked up and wanted a buttermilk pie, but they were out. So i ordered a pumpkin pie instead. I headed back home, i was a good 60 yards away when the baker came running out and stopped me and told me they just pulled out a fresh buttermilk. They even let me exchange it. I was so shocked! I don’t normally do reviews, but this was so out-of-the way nice, that I just had to. The pie is absolutely delicious too by the way!

Amazing pies, I have gone several times and have been happy every time. These pies put other pie shops to shame. The employees are always friendly and helpful. My favorite is the chocolate cream,but have also enjoyed I40,pumpkin,apple,cherry,strawberry, blueberry,and the lemon icebox. They were a very yummy.

Wow. My dad’s 82nd birthday was this weekend, and he loves pie. I didn’t want a big box grocery store pie, so I chose this place based upon the reviews. I am pleased. I don’t recall the name of the young lady that helped us, but hopefully she’ll read this…you’re incredible! She led us through our selections (9” key lime pie and 4 pack of 4” pies) and they were ALL delicious. If I didn’t live 6 hours away, I’d frequent this place!