Tony & Maria's Pizzeria

Fantastic pizza! Called on SuperBowl Sunday, they were happy to add to their already crazy busy night. Pizza was amazing, as always, and the delivery driver was so nice!!!! Love this place.

First time ordering from these guys and OMG so delicious. Got the all meat or meat lovers whatever they call it, it was fantastic, i mean, the crust was even fantastic without the toppings!!!!
Eat here!!! I swear you'll totally love it!!

Update:
Yup, this pizza is still legit and yes, I still drive from Madison to pick it up. I had to invest in a pizza warming bag but it's worth it. 😋 I really wish Tony & Maria's would come to Madison.

Allow me to put it this way.... We live in Verona, WI and have no problem ordering a pizza from Tony & Maria's, then driving 41 miles one way just to go pick it up. They are that delicious! You do not know real Italian pizza unless you've been to Tony & Maria's. I absolutely love their sauce. Their ingredients always taste fresh! I highly recommend you give them a try.

When you want some of the best pizza Janesville has to offer, look no further than Tony & Maria's. So good, even as leftovers.

Just ordered and it got here right in an hour. The pizza is AMAZING. Im from Chicago originally and this is the best pizza in Wisconsin. 10/10!!!

This pizza is the best in town. Our number one place to go is downtown Rockford but this place makes up for the distance. They're always nice to us and don't sound ghetto like other pizza places in town. We might have to get more next week!

I have not lived in Janesville for some time but always have to get a pizza from this legendary Wisconsin establishment. They have the cheesiest pizza this side of the Mississippi. You should order it well done and uncut for the perfect results, cause even when they cut it the cheese reforms and it’s your best guess where a slice may start or end. This is a thin crust lovers dream as the toppings far out weigh the crust. If you love pizza this is a place you will not regret.

This is the best pizza in a 50 mile radius. Yes, they’re only open 5 days per week and only for dinner. No, they do not typically answer the phone on the first couple of tries (no call waiting, and usually very busy). And yes, it’s not “cheap”, at roughly $20-25 for a large size pizza. But it’s all entirely worth it. This pizza is fire. Perfect crust. Wonderful sauce. Excellent, fresh toppings. And the cheese and grease are heavenly.

Amazing pizza, I'd even say my favorite. All pizzas have a delicious mountain of cheese on them. The pizzas aren't as cheap as chain stores, but the portion size you get still makes for a good value. They also have some of the best tasting pepperoni; give it a try.

I have lived in a few different cities In the past year. I have not been able to find a really good pizza for a long time, especially one that matched my hometown favorite. This is amazing. Came hot, which is important to me and the taste is awesome. Great ingredients and a crispy delicious crust! I so needed a good pizza and I’m glad I live in Janesville!!

I'm surprised that anyone would give this place only a 1-star review. Hands down, our favorite pizza joint in Janesville! They put so much cheese on their pizza that you need a second person in the car to hold it upright during your drive home! Seriously! A bit on the pricey side, so we get it mainly only on birthdays.

They are one of the greatest and long time favorite places to get pizza ! Their cheese is amazingly flavorful and delicious. And they are very generous with the cheese. I wish them all the best during this very tough time ( the pandemic ) and hope that they can get through this. You've made my family and I very happy and fulfilled over the years. Thank you ! Stay safe, wear masks and wash those hands often. Take care.

My daughter & son-in-law constantly talk about how AWESOME the pizza is at Tony & Maria's. We finally had the pizza for the first time. OMG....The pizza was to die for!! The sauce is AMAZING and their pizza is nice & cheesy. Definitely going to get order one every time were in Janesville!

Anyone who complains about the price should stick to Domino's. I order an X-Large sausage, mushroom, onion, every time I order, it's $45 and worth every penny. You're a damn fool if you think someone in the area has better pizza. This is the best, PERIOD!!

Ever since I discovered this place I've been a return customer. The price is a bit higher but for what you get it's worth every penny. I've seen complaints about customer service, price, and delivery times. Here's the skinny on those topics. This place gets very busy and hectic so if the phone rings and rings it's because they are swamped. Customer service? They do their best and treat people with kindness. The price. If you are complaining about a $25 pizza with the works then stick to Domino's or pizza hut. This is a real pizzeria. If the cheese slid off it's your fault as they do tell you to keep it level. They use real ingredients from the 100% cheese, unlike Macs and Domino's, to the toppings and dough. Sam's large size is actually smaller than a 12"and they've raised their prices mind you. Tony and Maria's has the right amount of cheese, sauce, and toppings. The taste is insanely great. The crust is bit soggy due to the real ingredients that cause grease to soak into the crust. To me that's not a deal breaker. These local guides with unfound reviews on this place really need to understand what a pizzeria is. Hint it's not the major chains. This pizza will have you saying mamma mia with the amount of fresh ingredients and flavor you get. And again if $25 is too much for you then go elsewhere. This is real people, real pizza, and real taste.

The best pizza served by two of the nicest people you would ever want to know. Many of the drivers have been working there for a long time and are likewise very nice. I have tried get anyone I know when they come to Janesville to try one and tell me they do not like it. Everything about the pizza is good. I love cheese and no one comes close to the amount and tastiness of Tony & Maria's Pizza. I love you guys and the pizza too. I love hearing Tony talk about the times in Italy. He has some great stories to tell. Maria is so nice to me and really genuinely caring.

Best pizza ever!!!!!! Took me 22 years and a new friend to discover this joint. Haven't had good pizza since I left Milwaukee 22 years ago.

I grew up eating this pizza 30+ years!) and it's hands down my favorite pizza. Whenever I go back to Janesville I try and order one and relive my childhood. Not your standard pizza chain pizza, this is true made with love and passion pizza.

I've been coming here off and on for over 30 years. They are more expensive than others, but well worth it . We go up a size or two and freeze the leftovers to enjoy again another time. I do wish they had fresh mushrooms instead of canned ones.

No need to order extra cheese. It comes standard that way! This is amazing pizza...And the dude (Tom A) that said he paid $50 for one of their basic pizzas and it made him sick, is nuts!! I think he got sick from the crack he must be smoking!