Piscataway Pizza

An accidental snack but this pizza was one of my best. I wasn’t expecting to have such a soft crust but this one was melt in the mouth! The guy was really great and in a cheerful mood. He took great interest in helping us with vegetarian options and even confirmed if we were vegan or vegetarian. Appreciate the detail! There were 3 veggie options and we ended up getting 3 slices of 2 of those. One with mushroom and another with mozarella. The tables are spacious and you would enjoy a slice or two on a lazy day sitting there. If you eat meat, they have a lot of other options too. Combos with buffalo wings are also available. We also got garlic knots which were equally melt in the mouth. All in all, a good place. I would definitely go again.

Ordered Garlic Knots, Margherita, Mushroom! Pizzas were good! Crunchy Crust with flavorful sauce, fresh Mozzarella and Basil. Mushroom was good too. Didn’t really like the garlic knots. Felt like it is made from garlic oil and not butter. Could taste oil more than garlic. But 5 stars for great service and extremely friendly staff. Good place for a pizza slice overall. I would surely recommend their Pizzas.

Not a fan of the pizza since im so use to nyc pizza but the GARLIC KNOTS are AMAZING!
I think the garlic knots are better than any NYC pizzeria. I just order the knots.

Just had couple slice of pizza and couple knots. Food was very good but customer service was EXCELLENT! very nice and humble welcome by Matt, he kinda forgot to get the knot out of oven on time which wasn’t bad at all if anything I would say it was perfect for me but just because he realized the perfection wasn’t according to how they serve it he didn’t charge me for it. These days where ppl don’t care about what they provide for what they charge, this was an absolute example of honest customer service out here Piscataway. Happy and proud to business with Piscataway Pizza!

Best Food in the area! Everything was delicious! Not only does this place make the best pizza, but their dinners, salads, subs are all fantastic!! Piscataway Pizza is a staple to the community and always delivers quality food! The owner Jaime is one of the kindest people by far & the regular chefs put real craft into everything they make! Worth every penny and more!!! If you haven’t tried them, give them a shot, you will be glad you did!!! Best food in the area by far!

Roberto was awesome! The food is amazing. Best pizzeria in town!

We came in late night, almost closing time. Food was so great and the customer service was greater. My family and I laughed so hard while we was there. It was like getting a double dose of goodness all under one roof. We ordered pizza, salad, and garlic knots. The price wasn't that bad. The comedy is what made it even better to enjoy the food. We will definitely be coming back again for the food and the comedy. Thank you Sir for making our night.

Awesome service. You don't expect to have amazing service at a pizzeria. This place goes above and beyond. We stopped here on the way home after my daughter's spring recital for a little celebratory pizza and we were blown away by the service. They server was funny and attentive and great with our little guy that was tired and asking for everything. On top of the great service, the food was delicious. We had a chicken salad and large pizza. Nothing extravagant but everything was flavorful and fresh which is everything you need from a pizzeria. I took the menu so we can order take out.

We order from this restaurant constantly, at least once every few weeks if not every week. The supreme pizza always comes fresh and loaded with delicious toppings. I can eat 2-3 slices of other pizzas easily, but unless I've skipped a meal, a single slice from Piscataway Pizza is more than enough. We've also had good experiences with their garlic knots and jalapeño poppers.

The delivery guys sometimes struggle with finding our apartment, but they seem to have gotten used to us over time. When I stopped in for a pickup order yesterday, the man waiting on me behind the counter was extremely friendly and helpful.

Pizza slices are HUGE, a slice came out pretty doughy but the others were good.

Owner is nice

WOW, Wow, WOW!! let me start off by saying if you haven't ordered from these guys you need to! First off I live across town and they are super nice and deliver to us and the food isn't cold or old! There food is tasty, fresh, and just great! Tonight we placed an order and realized an item was missing. My husband called and let them know, they said let me call the driver and see if they forgot it we'll call you back. I told my husband to just call back and forget it just ask for a credit, we do live across town and it wasn't really a big deal just an honest mistake. He did just that and they informed him they were already remaking it and sending it back out!!! They were so nice, we got a prompt delivery with a little extra for the mistake. I just wanted to share this experience with everyone because I am big on customer service. Today its hard to come across that, places and people simply just don't care and I've had many bad experiences. This is so refreshing and they will forever have my business if they can keep this style of running a business. Thank you Piscataway Pizza!!

I was very hungry and I got a pizza for breakfast. And the pizza was amazing. And a nice big slice. Love big slices of pizza.

The prices are good and the pizza is great. The garlic knots are straight fire 🔥🔥🔥. My guy Roberto provides excellent customer service and sometimes hooks us up with free toppings. Now they have a rewards system to consistently get free stuff. Best pizza place in the area by far.

Big slices and friendly staff; More menu items attached

I just moved to Piscataway and have been scouting out the area for good pizza. I highly recommend Piscataway Pizza to anyone who is local and/or wants to find good eats! We ordered buffalo wings, calamari, and a grandma pie. All was excellent. For blue cheese lovers, they have Kraft blue cheese (it did the job); for Calamari/Spicy food lovers, I recommend ordering extra Marinara with crushed red pepper for some extra heat! Our grandma pie dough was a little thicker than I'm used to, but it actually worked out great since we ordered extra cheese! Portions are great- we had left overs for days. We plan to order again soon. My favorite item was the Calamari- pleasantly surprised. Last note: the delivery itself was on schedule, food arrived hot, and the gentleman who delivered the food was very very friendly.

The pizza is great! Fresh veggies, meats, cheese blend and delicious in store made marinara and vodka sauce. If pizza is not In your mood, great sandwiches and pasta dishes as well. The owners are very kind people as are the employees. Never had a bad experience there.

A first-time visitor, and I was not disappointed. When I picked up my order, I told the guy behind the counter it was my first visit, and he said, "You'll be back. I guarantee it." He was right ... I will be.

Beware the Meat Lover's 18" pie. When you pick up the box, the weight alone will surprise you. This place is not shy with ingredients. The crust was perfect, the sauce was amazing without an acidic bite, and the presentation was impeccable. However, I'd recommend bringing a few friends and one hell of an appetite. This Meat Monster will weigh you down.

Congrats, Piscataway Pizza. You've earned another loyal customer.

Owner is nice funny and absolutely friendly as can be. We went in 20 minutes before they closed and he had no problem or attitude at all. He was actually happy that we came in and explained that kitchen was closing but he could still make us just about anything. Pizza was awesome, salad was great, and the garlic knots really hit the spot. Between the pleasant service and great tasting foos we plan on making this our official pizza place.

Big slices great daily specials great people. Did a special request for me also.

Very friendly and time efficient. Replaced fratellis for me