Panatieri's Piscataway

I have ordered a few items on their menu from a few visits and every time I’ve been completely satisfied. The lady that takes the orders is very sweet and friendly. I think I found my new fave piscataway pizza spot.

A very clean, neat place. The staff are very friendly, always smiling, bringing joy to customers. Its not an ordinary pizza store, they bring ypur order to your table. What I ate is great. Didnt tasted the pizzas because I wanted something different and was eating pizzas during the week so took another italian entree, and it was worth it. They know what theyre doing and its satisfying peoples taste buds and exceeding to customers' expectations. I would go there again.

Amazing never eating any other pizza everything we ordered was great but that square too die for and excellent and friendly service highly recommend give them a shot

Very good, delicious and very nice staff member!!! We like it!

This is the best f****** pizza I've ever had in my life. It's crunchy and fluffy at the same time. The sauce isn't heavy, and you can actually taste every ingredient used in their pizza. Not to mention, it's all hand-made with fresh ingredients. Their wings are crunchy as well, and they have different flavors. They also have sweet treats like tres leaches, and flan. It's better than authentic New York Italian pizza.

Very tasty pizza with an amazing staff!

Love the Blackened Salmon / Cajun Shrimp Salad 😋 my first time there & I'll definitely return. The customer service was amazing as well 😁 I'm so glad I tried it. Oh great hot wings with blue cheese also I almost forgot to mention that😂

This has become our favorite Pizza place. The pizza has very fresh ingredients and is excellent each time we place an order. Best calamari we've found in the area and the Buffalo wings are great. Salads are enough to feed at least 3 people. Their homemade soups are not to be missed. Chicken dishes, pasta dishes, and subs, are equally great.
Honestly the best part of the Piscataway location is the staff. Brenda always answers the phone with a very positive and friendly attitude. Paul is a gem that is being hidden as the delivery man. Responsible, & he takes pride in a job well done. He's always upbeat and positive. Hope he gets to utilize his talents in a management position. It surely would be a win/win situation for all.

Oct 27 2018
Lunch order of eggplant florentino: included fresh bread and salad $10.67( with taxes). Everything was freshly prepared , staff was courteous. Main course took 25 minutes to arrive. The freshly baked bread was amazing. I got the thinner pasta, which was more enjoyable than the regular one. The portion size was huge, I didn’t need to eat dinner.

Always great delicious food. Staff is friendly. Pizzas of ALL kinds, hot subs and "smackers"...(chicken wings with sweet & heat)...just some of our faves.
We visit at least twice a week.

Best pizza and service in the neighborhood. People working are super friendly and the chef customizes the dishes as you prefer.

They are always so nice. The pizza is fresh, always tastes yummy. Never have to wait long. Strongly recommend

Everytime I come here the service is great and the workers are extremely friendly and welcoming and the food taste amazing. This is for sure my new favorite pizza place.

Consistently good food, friendly and efficient staff. Great value... Can't beat the Monday night half price special! LOVE the Chicken Maddalena.

Have been there twice in past week. Once a sandwich...second slice of pizza. Very good sauce. Going back soon.

My boyfriend and I had some slices, they were great! Crust was crunchy and not floppy or soggy!

Weekly specials, freshly prepared entrees, fresh ingredients, large portions, reasonable prices & friendly service... don't let the "Strip Mall" fool you. Try it, you'll luv it!

great food, great company messed up my order and gave me a free pizza for a layer date and honored it...... they have my pizza business for life.

Great selection of great looking foods! Pizza was amazing!! Perfect in every way! Taste! Flavor and just good!!

Best chicken parm dinner I’ve had in nj 👍🏼👍🏼 great service, great food, y’all should go asap! you’re welcome.