Umberto’s Pizzeria

Amazing staff . I stopped in when my sugar level happened to plummet I'm diabetic. Also I rank in the top 10% globally on google maps for pizza reviewers and I'd like to thank the staff for their hospitality. If you guys remember me. Thank you. The food is amazing . Top notch. Just crispy enough. Doesn't fall apart and slide off. 100% an all time favorite Umberto's all the way

Surprisingly...well surprised me anyway how good their pizza was. Went there for lunch, and if I say it was definitely 2 of the best slices I have had in a very long time. Kudos!!!.

Honestly best pizza in town. Perfect crispness, ideal sauce to cheese ratio, amazing flavor. 10/10, can't recommend this place enough.

They're also very patient with kids, which is a huge plus.

This place did not disappoint! A friend from the area recommended it to us on our way to the pumpkin blaze and it was so yummy. I had a buffalo chicken slice and chicken Francese over spaghetti. It tasted flawless and the portion was on the large enough to save for the next day (and tasted just as good the second time). My mother had spaghetti and meatballs and my husband had the baked ziti. The bread was great and the garlic knots were some of the best I ever had. I brought the rest of them to work and the guys demolished them and asked where I had gotten them because they were so good. And that was day old. That’s how good this place is.

I’m not a vegetarian but they have a really great menu for those who are.

Had dinner here tonight. Pizza, pasta and chicken parm. Was absolutely delicious. Definitely fresh and tasty food. Will go here again in the near future since it’s not that far from me. Thanks!

Visited Umberto's Pizzaria for dinner while in town for an event. Our server was extremely friendly and helpful with the menu options. He brought out a basket of bread which included garlic knots that were delicious! He even offered to make a sangia which was not on the menu so I naturally accepted. I ordered the red sangria and it came in a large glass with lots of fresh fruit. Very nice! We ordered the buffalo cauliflower arrabiata which was very lightly breaded and coated in buffalo sauce. I ordered slice of pepperoni pizza on regular crust and my friend ordered a slice of pepperoni on grandma's crust. We both enjoyed our pizza and appetizer very much. The sauce reminds me of pizza that I tasted in Italy. We orded canelloni for dessert which was amazing! My friend also took home an order of spaghetti and meatballs and said it was the BOMB!!

I am in town for work from Indiana and wanted New York pizza. By god did this place deliver on my wishes. Amazing pizza. Friendly staff. Perfection is an understatement.

I love this place! I went there last night for a quick meal on a Thursday night with family. Arman was our server and he was totally awesome! He was attentive and even recommended items on the menu. The Buffalo Chicken slice and vegetable Stromboli was delicious. I love the setting; I will be returning more frequently!

Service was good.

They have Buffalo Calamari (forgot to take pic). Why doesn't more restaurants offer this!!! Calamari is crispy and can hold the Buffalo sauce well. Perfect combo lol

Penne Puttanesca was delicious! Can be made vegan.

We went with my 2 teens on March 27, 2023, around 7 o'clock PM. I don't know the name of the waiter. He was a real cool guy. Fast service he was very nice and helpful. The food is amazing, go for the garlic knots, the sicillian, the calamari is the best. They have sangria, which was great, too. It's a good family oriented spot. After all of it, if you could squeeze in a Canoli, it was fresh and yummy. we love this place. ❤

Unbelievable spinach artichoke pizza. No more to say, just simply delicioso!!!

Excellent selection of freshly made pizzas. Staff was also friendly. Will visit again when I'm back in town.

One of the best Pizza places in Plainview. Get the Grandma or the Sicilian

Very tasty. Grandma slice , fresh mozzarella & arugula & Roma tomatoes. Boss !

The service here is always super fast and quick to please. They also have some of the best vegan pizza around. My only ask is that they have vegan slices out and ready to go on the counter instead of having to order a whole pie every time. Prices are decent. Definitely worth a try.

Ordered a half tray of Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana. Pricing was very competitive compared to the other pizza places around town. Had it delivered to my house to compliment other dishes we had for company. The Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana was SUPERB! My company as well as us couldn’t compliment the taste enough; it was delicious. Easy and well mannered people when we ordered and delivery was right on time, so the chicken was still nice and hot! Thank you UMBERTO’S Plainview..

Overall dining experience can be a bit better the atmosphere is a bit outdated but the food? Omg. Amazing pizza. Grandma and Sicilian are one of the best on LI. Order for a big party with them you can't go wrong.

Damn!! Gramma pie thin, crispy and chewy!! Pizza sauce amazing! Came to work from NJ. I will be back!!

An amazing pizza, the variety of slices made my mouth water. I love their plain cheese pie, the dough is chewy, salty and light. The cheese is piled on not just to cover the crust but to be a mouthful when you bite into it.

I wish I lived closer!

My family was in town visiting and we had a large party closer to close than we usually would. It was genuinely THE BEST dining experience. Our waiter went above and beyond to make us feel at home, the food was incredible, the timing was on the spot, and we couldn't have made a request they wouldn't have obliged. If I could give 100 stars I would!