ST. JAMES PIZZA & PASTA

We're from Ohio and ended up in the area for a car. The dealership asked us if we'd ever had New York style pizza - nope! So they eagerly gave us a couple slices of cheese pizza they ordered for lunch and it was so good I asked where it came from, they said St. James Pizza. After we got done with the car deal this was the first place we stopped and got 2 larges to eat on the way home. That was on St. Paddy's Day weekend and here I am STILL thinkin about how good the pizza was. Excellent!!

Darren and Co are amazing owners. My wife and I order from St. James Pizza often. I will say as a pizza maker for 15 years, it’s appreciated when the pizza is A. cooked, B. crisp, C. Not sloppy. These guys cook a great pizza for delivery and in house. Highly recommend!

Jenny and Darren are really good people. Always welcoming and friendly. How's the pizza you ask? By far the best around. This place is worth traveling to. Regular Slice, Brooklyn Slice, Chicken Parm Hero are my go-to favorites.

Their pizza is hands down the best I’ve ever had. I would travel from anywhere for it but thankfully I don’t have to travel far so this is a weekly dinner in our house!

What nice people! Picked up pies donated for a fundraiser and everyone was extremely nice! Location is very clean and appealing! Pizza was absolutely delicious! Looking forward to going back to try some other fun dishes.

Just wanted to share a nice experience I had there. Moved to the area recently and this has been our go to pizza place. Food is always excellent. I went to pick up my order and my two toddlers both wanted to take a ride with dad. So with my hands full, I picked up my order and quickly realized getting two kids and the food in the car was going to be harder than I thought (rookie move). Before I could even start formulating a plan, I heard someone say, “I got it” and an employee carried our order to the car without hesitation.

Great pizza, they had a really good crust and I loved the sauce flavor. Perfect amount of cheese. Just wanted a slice and they had very speedy service. Would definitely recommend.

My first having their pizza 🍕 was very good actually some best tasting I’ve had in awhile .highly recommend

We had a great pepperoni pizza from St. James Pizza last night.
Crust was crispy and thin with the right amount of cheese, sauce, and pepperoni. Not sure why we waited so long to try it. This is our new go to place for pizza! Definitely give it a try if you haven't already :)

I love this pizzeria. They make the best Sicilian slices.
Ah, the Sicilian slices! Thick, pillowy, and generously topped, they transport you straight to the streets of Palermo. The crust is golden and crispy on the outside, yet soft and doughy within. The tomato sauce is robust, and the cheese—oh, the cheese—is a melty masterpiece. Whether you choose classic pepperoni or veggie-loaded, each bite is a celebration. Visit this place. You won't be disappointed.

I have been there many times. The owner is very friendly and they serve the best pizza in town.

Recently found this hidden gem. Food and pizza are awesome!!. Service is welcoming. YOU MUST TRY!!! Catering for Christmas was loved by all!

Love, love, love this place. Food is always good. Great meatball heros and Sicilian slices.

Amazing! Since new ownership, you feel like you're going into your hometown pizzeria, friendly and delicious!!

I love this place. Come here a lot on my lunch break from work. Sometimes pick up for dinner after work. This place takes home the winning prize compared to any italian place in the smithtown/ st. James area

Smaller place so "atmosphere" is a challenge. Food and folks there more than make up for it.

I've lived in the area for over 25 years and it's still has the best pizza in town.

Always fantastic!
Food is delicious and the staff is wonderful.

We go here all the time for their amazing pizza! The panko covered crust and Brooklyn slice are the best! Great food and nice people. Def one of our favorite pizza places.

Just tried this place for the first time since it took new ownership. I tried a fresh slice of Sicilian and it was delicious. I then went for a regular slice that was fresh as can be. The sauce was on point cheese was perfect and slice was crispy. The Slice even came with the special crust which tasted great
Soon as we entered we were greeted by a very friendly man behind the counter, this man turned out to be the new owner. You can tell he is very passionate about his food.
I'm excited to welcome this place to the neighborhood and wish all good luck to them and this will be in regular rotation.