Timothy Jay Sweets

We went to TImothy Jay Sweets recently with 2 of our granddaughters to pick out some cupcakes to celebrate the younger one's 3rd birthday. There were plenty of varieties to choose from, each one looking more delicious than the next!

Timothy made sure to recognize her special day and included a little something extra for her older sister "just because"

The cupcakes were delicious!

A wonderful small shop in an easy to get to location. Lots of yummy choices and reasonable size treats. The owner is very welcoming and thoughtful, after a warm greeting he wanted to know if there any allergies to consider!

This place is 🔥. Stopped in with my friend after lunch and was greeted, catered to and made to feel like long time friends. Such a cheerful and energetic vibe swirling around in there. I brought back a four pack of cupcakes which included a raspberry filled vanilla, Boston cream, cookies and cream and triple chocolate to my family in Connecticut and we devoured every morsel like a pack of wolves. So delicious!! I can’t wait to visit again!! My reason for traveling back to Millbury, MA!

I ordered a gluten free cake for my son's baptism and it was SO delicious! Everyone kept asking where it was from and were surprised to find out it was gluten free. Everyone at Timothy Jay Sweets are so friendly and were so great to work with. Will definitely be back for future cake/dessert orders!

Tim has made TWO gorgeous cakes for me now- One fun gender reveal cake for my daughter in 2022 and recently made a custom safari themed cake for her 1st birthday. Cakes always taste amazing too!! We always snag a cupcake or cookie every time we swing through too. Highly recommend the funfetti flavor for the cakes! Thank you!

I went there for the first time today. I got two of the salted caramel cupcakes. Let’s just say yummy, absolutely delicious. I was going to share with my husband but that’s definitely not happening now. I am actually glad he fell a sleep. I just ate one of them now and I am hiding my other one, for tomorrow. Excellent atmosphere, excellent customer service and excellent sweat tooth saver!

Thank you so much for the fantastic birthday cake for our daughter! It looked and tasted amazing. She loved it!

I'd like to say, can I just be friends with these partners!?? Very fun atmosphere, clean , warm and welcoming. Helped me out In a pinch 😉. With cupcakes! My son was so enthusiastic that they were willing to help with his ole school requests. Super fun way to start a new year with a new place to buy treats! I also want to go back because they sell paintings!!. 2 of my favorites in one place 🤩 thanks Timothy & Anthony!

Timothy is absolutely amazing!! Delectable treats very well thought out to satisfy all ages and tastes. Extremely impressive - thank you for adding a burst of fun to our Saturday!!!!

Amazing treats but even more amazing owner. It was so nice meeting with you and chatting about your tattoos and Halloween. My daughter and I will definitely stop the next time we are in the state. Ps. The Veterinary Hospital we were visiting loved the treats

The chocolate cake pop in my goodie bag for Over the Edge with CDK (Canines for disabled kids) charity event was phenomenal. The delicious cake pop was encased in some nice milk chocolate covered with sprinkles and that first bite revealed a decadent and moist inside. This cake pop was the best I've ever had and I definitely recommend you all try some.

The owner is so nice and the cupcakes, cookies and whoopie pies are absolutely delicious. We got our dogs the pupcakes and they LOVED them. We will definitely be back.

My first time there and it was an amazing experience. The shop it super cute and has so many treats to pick from! The owner was extremely nice and such a whole hearted individual. I would 100% go just to support him. But the peanut butter cookies were amazing and the chocolate bombs are fantastic. I honestly love this shop so much and this world needs more Tim’s. 🧁

Timothy made my day! I'd go back just for the healing vibes and positive conversation we had. It was hard to leave! The cupcake and cake pops were amazing and he even gave us candles for them since it was my birthday. My kids and I will definitely be going back for more whole hearted conversation and to experience new flavors! Following on Instagram for the joke of the day!

We made our daughter's first birthday party July 4th. Not realizing a lot of places were going to be closed July 3rd and 4th. My daughter loves unicorns and I had invisioned a unicorn cake for her. I stopped in to Timothy Jay Sweets hopefully he will be opened. He was amazing! He assured me I would get the unicorn cake for my little girl as well as a smash cake. He went over all the options and prices. Everyone loved it! Thank you so much time for helping this mom get the cake she wanted for her little girl

Waited on by one of the owners, who was very pleasant - cupcakes were delicious!

I wish that I could give more than 5 stars! I am beyond impressed with both the DELICIOUS cupcakes and incredible service! I will most definitely be returning 😊

Stopped in today & I am So glad I did!
I got The salted caramel, cannoli, & snicker doodle flavored cupcakes! They were delicious! The cannoli is my favorite. Also grabbed a tub of their chocolate chip cookie dough! It’s heat treated so it’s completely safe! The service was almost as delicious as the sweet treats! I’ll definitely be back soon!

At long last found the location. Beautiful shop, spotless!! The scent upon entering is DEVINE!!! They have a large variety of cookies, cupcakes, even devil dogs!! They will make custom cakes as well! Everything we had was so so YUMMY 😋. I can't wait to return. The owner was so nice and very personable, a total pleasure.

Cupcakes absolutely delicious you walk in there and it smells so fresh the owner was super nice and has a great attitude all the cupcakes were so good I had the confetti cookies and cream and cheesecake. Let me tell ya the salted caramel cheese cake absolutely to die for will be going back for that