Effingham's Coal Fired Pizza and Taphouse

This afternoon at lunchtime I was given a friendly greeting by Liz at the Hotel Weyanoke front desk who directed me to the entrance into Effingham's to the right. From there LaShanna immediately offered a friendly greeting. I asked to sit at the bar and ordered a Classic Chicken Caesar salad with no croutons and iced tea with lemon. The vibrant salad greens came out beautifully, and the grilled chicken on top was so fresh it still had steam coming off of it! The Dijon Vinaigrette dressing option sounded delicious, so I requested it. It definitely tasted fresh and had just the right tang! Do you enjoy eating high quality fresh food cooked to order? I would definitely recommend trying Effingham's!

What a lovely new restaurant in Farmville! The renovations to this restaurant area and the rest of the Hotel Weyanoke are very nice. The food here is great, and it's always nice to have more non-chain restaurants to choose from. I tried three of the pizzas, and look forward to coming back and trying more. I also had the dessert calzone, which I would highly recommend!

Everything I’ve had here has been top notch and tonight the shrimp and grits stole the show. Great dining experience through and through.

We came for breakfast and had the eggs Benedict, breakfast sandwich, and omelette. The hollandaise sauce was delicious and everything came out nice and warm

Great food and service. Bbq chips were stellar. Came here because Charley’s service was terrible. You won’t be disappointed.

We came into town to visit family. Traveling through Virginia with a dairy allergy is not easy, but finding this place certainly helped! They have vegan options on the menu, and they were very accommodating. The food was great, and even my kids managed to find something they enjoyed. The staff was very welcoming, too. It made a tough trip a little bit easier, and I really appreciate that.

Always enjoy eating here. Nice wine and cocktail list. Food is elevated classics, nice but not fancy. Easy to get a few dishes to split. The pizza has a wonderful crispy crust.

I have a large family of 10 (7 children, my mother-in-law, my wife and myself) so I was hesitant to put that kind of stress on the staff. However, the staff did an extremely awesome job, suggesting that we use the high top center dining area and managed to keep up with my son that tries his best to drink all the lemonade in the place. Bringing my family to stay at Weyanoke and enjoying Farmville for a quick overnight was such a great idea. I’m in Farmville often and always enjoy the stays here at the Weyanoke and eating at Effingham’s, but it’s always on business and I don’t think I’ve ever got to truly appreciate all of what this place has to offer. Thank for having us!!!

Have a wing night great flavors. Try fries with aioli delicious, and cauliflower appetizer also delicious. Great choices of pizza and all are fresh ingredients and wonderful. Try bingo night might win a free pizza.

Oh the food and the service was great. Much better than 202. The last time I went there the food was good but the service was horrible it was only two tables and the waitress was busy chatting up two young men at the bar and totally forgot about the other 8 customers in the dinning room .sad

Sangria is delicious on a nice day where you can sit on the rooftop or outside right on high street. Both lovely views and the dinning area is simplistic but well put together.

Waitresses were great! Friendly and attentive. Food was amazing! We really enjoyed our stay at the hotel as well as the restaurant! Everything was good!

They're the best there is at what they do!

I had the Surryano Ham pizza and it was beyond delicious. The service was excellent. Overall a great experience. We will be back again very soon.

I came to meet a friend. They had friendly staff and the food was amazing. Definitely check out the Truffle Fries if you go there 😅😋

Great food and friendly staff. Smoked salmon crostini is amazing, the whole menu is great. Very nice atmosphere.

The Sunday brunch was excellent! Molly was helpful with the menu options and very attentive.

Food was fresh and delicious. Fairly priced. Staff was pleasant & attentive.

PIZZA and Pesto Wings.. highly recommended.. always fresh..and the French Fries..with Melted Mozzarella .. best ever..and the $$$... Anyone can afford it..

Really enjoyed the pizza, good beer selection, nice staff.