Three Brothers New York Pizza

First time visiting this pizza place. We tried a few others locally but still did not quite hit the mark. Enter Three Brothers New York Pizza, they live up to the name. AMAZING pizza and various other menu items as well. It's a true, small pizza shop; they are very busy with pickups and deliveries with small amount of indoor seating. We were still able to get a table without issue. Very fair pricing, great portion sizes, and it was delicious. We'll be returning, happy customers. :)

One word for this place: amazing! Today was $9.99 for a large pie, amazing deal. The pizza is amazing and you can tell everything is freshly made. We got a large cheese pizza with bacon and mozzarella sticks. Everything was hot and fresh out of the oven. The cashier was super sweet and made sure we were okay throughout the visit. Definitely a hole in the wall place, but I’m not sure why people were complaining about cleanliness. All the tables were clean and there wasn’t even any trash on the floor. Definitely a little small on the inside but you can always bring your pizza home to eat! I will definitely be coming back as I’m super excited to try other types of pizzas and other foods from the menu. Highly recommend!! Also, the tool they had for the pizza is absolutely genius and helped with actually getting a slice instead of just kinda flopping the pizza all over and getting sauce everywhere lol.

Quality food! Fantastic pizza and wings!! But what prompted me to leave this review is the quality service. I ordered a pizza last night and selected the wrong kind of onions (pickled instead of carmelized). Within minutes of receiving the order they called me to confirm that’s really what I wanted, which I’m so thankful for bc it was NOT what I wanted!! They went the extra mile to make sure I got what I actually wanted, and you don’t get that from many places these days. So thank you for the excellent service and food!!

One of the best NY-style pizza places I've ever had. If you have a group of people to feed, try the 28 inch pizza. It's awesome!

A very excellent pizza! The name does it justice, well done guys.

As I continue to search for real quality pizza in Tampa, Three Brothers is definitely one of the top I have found. I called in the order and when I arrived, while very busy, my order was ready for pick up. The pizza is very good with a nice crust, sauce is good and the right amount of cheese. I would highly recommend Three Brothers Pizza.

Awesome from start to finish. Cashier confirmed my entire order and made sure it was correct (which just doesn't happen anymore) and they delivered on everything! Service, atmosphere, taste, quality....you name it. We will be back and if you haven't been, you are missing out. Thank you to George and the very friendly and efficient team you have here. 🙂

This is the best, most authentic Italian food in this area, hands down! The eggplant rollatini is superb! Reasonable prices, very nice people. One entree was enough for 2 servings for me. The pizza is excellent as well! Highly recommend!!

Best New York Pizza around!!!
The owners are truly from NY and know what thin crispy means. Their Siclian is delicious, light, and perfect.You must visit one of their locations!! Thank you, Sean and staff, for your hospitality!!

I had it delivered from grubhub which was good. The pizza is some of the best pizza I have ever had, outside of NYC. Perfectly thin and chewy with the proper amount of grease, that so many other pizzerias struggle to get correctly. A bit pricy but worth it, in my opinion.

Ordered a Philly cheese steak, I worked for Amoroso's for more than a decade,and know how the roll makes the sandwich,not to mention I'm originally from philly,Let me tell you i got an awesome CheeseSteak sandwich from Three brothers, even on a soft roll,great tasting meat,i would tell everyone to try their food !!!!

Unbelievably consistent. I always get delivery and it’s terrific. Eggplant Balsamic Pizza is fabulous just add grilled chicken to make it the best pizza youve ever had.

Need catering for a small party of 20?
They came through CLUTCH and everything was DELICIOUS!!!!

Very friendly staff and some of the best NY style pizza you can find in the area. If you like authentic, fresh NY style pizza you have to give this place a shot

Great people, service, variety, suggestion’s, and prices. There is clearly a passion for quality and tasty food. I’m about to eat my pizza, wings, fries, and home made brownies… I’m sure it’s as good as the service I just experienced. Can’t wait to wash it all down with a bottle of cream soda.

The olives had no pits,
The greens were crisp and bright.
the feta and the dressing
Were a wonderful delight
Try the brothers next time
You get the hunger call
And try this great Greek salad
Happy eating y’all!
(Try the reduced balsamic on the Greek salad)

Although there are closer pizza places I will always drive the xtra miles for their pizza ! And aside from their pizza being the best their customer service and management is 100% and that is rare today !
Kim Mitchell

Updated...pizza still great, but pretty much over consistently paying for blue cheese that is never provided. Then, you provide instruction to refrain from ringing bell in a no-contact delivery because of dogs, and they knock.🤦🏼‍♀ Simple things sometimes get frustrating and push you to seek out new places.

Real NY style pizza is about that perfect balance of a crispy yet chewy crust...they nailed it. Bianca with spinach was decadent!

Pizza was great. We are from NJ and have high pizza standards. We rarely get pizza when traveling because we are usually disappointed. Three Brothers knocked it out of the park. True NY style pizza with tangy sauce and rich creamy cheese. We also tried the fire and smoke pizza which was excellent. Great job Three Brothers we will be back next time we are in Florida!

Bruno is the absolute BEST!
The pizza is amazing, meatballs are delicious, service is unmatched.
You can tell they use quality ingredients and take pride in what they do.
I will definitely be frequenting this restaurant.

Oh! They have an extremely generous rewards program for loyal customers!

I’ve been a loyal local customer of Three Brothers pizza and the pizzas , and anything else I’ve had from the chicken strips to the calzones and homemade desserts it’s definitely a hidden gem in Palm Harbor in a little strip shopping center. There’s lots of cool places in there as well. The staff is always smiling and friendly and they have excellent deals during the week. They use the best ingredients and it’s my favorite local Pizza Place in Palm Harbor
Check them out I believe they opened up a new location as well.
Thanks for the great pizza
Support your locals
🤗Carrie Kyle