Balistreri Brothers

It would be a challenge to find a better pizza in all of Milwaukee! We love a thin crust and always order our pizza that way. Our choice on toppings is many, cheese, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, pepperoni, and black olives ! All toppings are fresh, and add the perfect flavors to our pizza ! I've also enjoyed a cup of soup many times and found it to be tasty and homemade. The waitstaff is very friendly. Some even remember our order. We're treated with respect and a caring attitude. We travel from New Berlin to Wauwatosa and will continue to as this is our favorite pizza in the area!

I read some of the reviews, seems they had a rocky road at the beginning, gave them a try a few weeks ago and have ordered several times since then...

I love the banter with the owner or manager, not sure, he is good people trying to make a living just as we all are.

I have ordered pizza all over around here, Rosati's, Rockies, The Local, Pizza Ranch...

Balistreri Bros I think is a rising star, the pizza rocks...

Gonna give the Friday fish fry a go soon.

Delicious pizza in simple, clean carryout location. We tried both the thin crust and hand tossed crust. Both were very good but the hand tossed was our favorite. Looking forward to getting more pizza from here in the future.

Still cooking that Southside Milwaukee pizza after all these years. Locations have changed, but taste is the same. Thin crust w/ sausage, onions and green peppers is perfect. If you don't know what a Milwaukee pizza is, go here and order it.

The pizza and mozzarella sticks were delicious the fries too, fast and friendly staff. Will definitely order again from them.

Amazing pizza. We get ours par-baked then finish them up at home. Always delicious. Nice thin crispy crust all the way through. Generous toppings and delicious sausage which is so hard to find anymore.

Awesome pizza! The dude walked out when I pulled up and said he'd bring it out when it was ready. I'll be eating here again when I'm up here.

The pizza is amazing & I’m a bit of a pizza aficionado 😅 Definitely my favorite in New Berlin. Also, they caught a credit card error before I noticed and called me to make it right which is the first time any business has done that for me.

The thin crust pizza is legit; awesome tavern style crust, perfectly crispy and light. Excited to try out hand-tossed crust when this location has their full menu available. Well worth your time checking out. This is gonna be our go-to pizza joint going forward.

BB’s on Moorland in New Berlin is genuinely some of the best pizza I’ve had in a while. The sauce is sweet, it isn’t oversaturated, and there’s never too much of it! It’s always the perfect amount of sauce. The cheese is so good, it doesn’t seem to want to ever come off when you pull a slice out for yourself. The toppings always taste fresh no matter when I order it, and I work next door! I thoroughly enjoy this pizza, the sides, hospitality, especially from a small businesses like this. The Balestreri Brothers knocked it out of the park with their passion for ensuring quality food, and above average customer service. The owner here is one of the most calm, and friendliest people I have ever met. This is, and I’m not exaggerating, one of my favorite pizza spots in the area for pizza.

Very good pizza and garlic bread. We loved the perfectly crisp thin crust, sauce was excellent, garlic bread was buttery and soft, it was great! We were asked when we could be there, I asked when it could be done, we were told 10 mins, and sure enough 10 mins was all it took for 2 pizzas and garlic bread. Absolutely perfect for kitchen demo day!

Pizza to-go is hot and tasty! A really great option for New Berlin instead of the regular go-to's. Glad Balistreri Brothers moved in next door... although my waist isn't. ;)

We LOVE this place! Balistreri's pizza is SO good! We live in Mukwonago and have tried practically every pizza within a 10 mile radius. Balistreri's is the best by far. Not only is their pizza the best but the cost is reasonable and their staff is efficient and fun-loving too.

Italian beef sandwich was amazing. Pizza was delicious. This is my new favorite pizza place in NB/Muskego area.

I love this pizza, my family’s addicted. We’ve literally gotten it two days in a row multiple times. 10/10 recommend.

Good yummy pizza! Ordered pizza, BBQ wings, and breaded mushrooms. They were all amazing!!

Picked up garlic bread and a thin crust Margherita and thin crust Classic. Everything was great, crust was nice and crispy! Will definitely be ordering again

We walked in on opening time with a warm greeting of a nice guy. He said hello and told us we could start ordering whenever we wanted. We ordered our pizza and wings, sat down, and waited a reasonable time before our food was brought to us. The pizza was delicious and the wings with ranch were one of the best i’ve had in a while. This guy was checking in on us a little while we ate to make sure everything was alright. We even had a little talk about sports with him. This place is great and I recommend it to everyone, and if he’s reading this, I was with my dad when we were here, and we were talking about the Milwaukee bucks with you. Thanks for the great service bro, greatly appreciate it.

It was first time ordering from here. The pizza was fantastic. We ordered a thin crust and it was done to perfection. Nice and crispy, and thin! The pizza had a lot flavor, which was fantastic! And we ordered baked mostaccioli, breaded mushrooms and mozzarella sticks, which my family loved everything. We found our new pizza place!!!

We moved away from the area and still find ourselves coming back for the pizza and wings. The pizza sauce is savory, not sweet, like other places. The thin crust is all we order but it’s perfect every time. Crispy outside with still having a slight chew.
Don’t skip out on the wings, the garlic Parmesan is the best example of it I’ve ever had, hands down. The staff has always gone above and beyond without asking for it. I’m surprised by the negative reviews here, because we have been here countless times and it’s always been solid. We have a bunch of options when we moved to Milwaukee, but can’t find something we like better. Give it a shot