Making Sweet Memories

I had a very specific cake in mind for my girlfriend's birthday – a tiramisu cake. Luckily, when I approached the bakery owner about making it, she didn't hesitate and said she'd be happy to. The cake turned out beautifully, just like we'd envisioned. It was a huge hit with my girlfriend, and the taste was spot-on – pure tiramisu perfection!

Make sure to get out and support a local business. The sweets a phenomenal! You see here buckeye balls, a lemon bar, s'mores bars, a chocolate cherry brownie filled and Oreo cupcakes. They are all delicious. Our family is so glad a new owner opened shop here.

I wanted to order cookies for my sons monster truck themed birthday party and I am so happy I decided to go with this bakery. They were absolutely wonderfullll. They were so delicious and fresh, & the design was exactly what I was looking for! I had everyone asking where I ordered from which I gladly shared. Thank you Cookie Jar Bakery for providing amazing cookies for our family and friends, you guys really did an outstanding job!(: I cannot wait to order cookies again for our next event !!! P.S. to anyone who has yet to visit..when you walk into this place, it smells soooo yummy, very tempting to try one (or more) of everything !

In the words of my toddler, "Mmmm, that's a good cookie!" This place is amazing. I wish we would have stopped in sooner. Everything we got was excellent. We will be back.

First, workers are very kind-pleasant on the phone (I called a few times because I was indecisive). I asked if they made cakes & they don’t BUT they make chocolate chip cookie cakes. I thought we’d try it out. It was HUGE, so fresh, & every single person commented on how good it was!
I had to pick it up with my toddler and newborn. The lady offered to carry the cookie cake out for me and help which was super appreciated.
My toddler got a frosted sugar cookie too and I snuck a bite. It was the best cookie I ever ate in my life.
I think about these cookies all the time lol!!!
Thanks for being kind and making delicious fresh cookies.

I made a last-minute order for cookie monster themed cookies for my sons first birthday. One dozen for the dessert table and one dozen to be individually packed for party favors. they turned out perfect everyone loved them they look so cute and we’re absolutely delicious I can’t wait to have an excuse to order from here again I highly recommend them!

I ordered 4 dozen cookies for my husband's birthday. The cookies were so fantastic, and everyone loved them. I was so sad there weren't any left over. The price is great, and the cookies are so delicious. I highly recommend!

Since our favorite bakery closed we've been hunting for another great local sugar cookie. I found this place through Google. I was so happy to find an amazing frosted sugar cookie here! The staff is very friendly & they have adorable childrens books & cookie jars for sale!!

My boyfriend and I frequent here. We love this cute little cookie shop and of course everything is always delicious! They really go the extra mile for their customers as well. Just today I called to see if they had my boyfriend's favorite snickerdoodle sandwich cookie because I was going to surprise him after a tough day. They didn't have them out today, but offered to put one together and set it off to the side for me! He is a happy camper needless to say. Thank you so much!

Local bakery with sweet treats including their main cookies (chocolate chip, peanut butter, snicker doodles and oatmeal raisin) plus lots of other goodies. Not quite as spectacular as the original owners recipes but still highly recommended.

Love love love this bakery. So friendly and awesome cookies. My daughter loves to stop in and see her favorite bakers!

Love this cute little bakery. My daughter and I have our weekly trip to the library that wouldn't be complete without a cookie from Cookie Jar Bakery and a visit with Rachel.

This place is legit. Best chocolate chip cookie I have had in years. If I only could eat one thing for the rest of my life I would chose this places chocolate chip cookies.

Super cute place, absolutely wonderful cookies and other baked goods.

One of our clients just brought us treats from your shop and they are delicious!

Good stuff at a decent price. You are getting what you pay for and that is delicious bakery items.

Best chocolate chip cookies I've ever had.

Great cookies and very nice people!

The chocolate chip cookie is delicious!

Always friendly and great selection of childhood favorites