Fiesta Mexicana

This place makes the best combination dinners for anyone that likes several dishes and can’t choose just one thing. They make the best margaritas around and the service is great.

The BEST guac ever! I am never disappointed here. Ambiance is great. Service excellent. Food fantastic every time.

First visit there for myself and my son's girlfriend. My friend, who was with us, suggested we try Fiesta Mexicana. There is the flavor of Mexico in the decorative atmosphere. Our waiter was helpful and explained the dishes we inquired about. I had crutches and there was no problem finding seating to accommodate keeping my foot raised in a chair. The prices are average for the area and we did not feel rushed. My son's girlfriend, who is Latino, enjoyed her meal very much, saying it tasted authentic. The strawberry margarita was perfect! Highly recommend.

Always great, but the chef's special was amazing

The guac is amazing. The staff are all very kind and responsive. Dont have too many margaritas especially if you plan on driving!

I go to the gym & then regularly get the spicy guacamole (jalopeno juice & chopped jalopenos) to go!. Sooo goood!

Haven't had a bad meal here yet for lunch or for dinner. Good drinks, good prices.

They are the sister of las mañanitas, so if the wait at mañanitas is too long, good to come here instead.

Sometimes I go to the bar here and then head to las mañanitas. Either way, you're in for an amazing time! 🔥

I absolutely love this Mexican restaurant. This is the best Mexican food around. Their specials are always great, and the main stay items on the menu are fabulous. Make sure you rider the fresh made guacamole. It's the best anywhere.

We stopped here randomly during a 12 hour drive amd and had a great experience!! The service was excellent, the food was delicious, the bathrooms were so clean. I am sad because I live far away and can't go back all the time. If you are considering going to this restaurant, this is your sign.... you definitely should!

Great food. Great Drinks.
Friendly service.
Great steady Bartender.
Never lets me down. They don’t close on Mondays.

Analise and Kevin are amazing there! They really work hard. The food is CHEFS KISS. Incredible! The prices may intimidate you but they give you A LOT of food so it kind of pans out! Definitely give this place a try if you’re curious! You won’t be disappointed :)

Best Mexican you'll ever have and for a great price. This place is an institution in brewster and there's a reason the owner has been so successful. Great food, great drinks, great atmosphere.

Nothing poor to say about Fiesta's always a great meal and experience.

Fantastic Mexican food, it’s so comforting and delicious. I had the pollo con mole...chicken was juicy and flavorful and the mole sauce was perfection! My husband got the chicken fajitas which sounds basic but he says it’s the best fajitas he’s ever had! Our serve William was great with his suggestions and very attentive without being over bearing. This will be our new go-to place for Mexican food.

My daughter and I ate at Fiesta Mexicana this afternoon. The food was excellent. Margaritas were so good, and relaxing!! And the service was efficient and pleasant. Highly recommend this place...you will not be disappointed.

The beef fajitas were sizzlin hot and nicely tasty. Huge portion, was barely able to finish.The lime margarita was superb to. All at reasonable prices 😁

The restaurant is small but not too small, it was busy when we first walked in but we were seated immediately. We actually decided to sit at the bar because it was actually slightly quieter. Our server/the only bartender was awesome he made our drinks they were delicious. Then he must have gotten 30 drink orders and made everyone of them without getting frustrated or complaining any time he had a second not making drinks he made sure his customers at the bar were happy and checked if we needed anything. The food was great I cleared my plate, my fiance has leftovers I'll probably end up eating today haha. We had a great night out there and we will definitely be back. Thanks Fiesta Mexicana for a good time.

We live in Brewster, not far away from Fiesta Mexicana. We have gone there a few times, including last night for dinner. The food is always excellent. Service is wonderful. We never have had any reason to complain about anything. I highly recommend this restaurant.

This is the best Mexican food around, and the restaurant is amazing to boot! Family-run and family-friendly, I have so many fantastic memories from years and years of visiting this restaurant. I’m really baffled by some the negative reviews, they’re just flat out not true. The food is amazing, the environment is amazing, the music is amazing. You can’t do any better than this, and if I still lived in the area, I would be there every week!

We've always had terrific food here but this was the first time we did take out. We were thrilled that their take out operation is as good as their dining in option. BTW their take home margarita was excellent & plentiful!

Great Mexican restaurant. Excellent food with a friendly staff. The atmosphere is pleasant with an authentic Mexican feel and decor. There is a separate bar section with plenty of seats and big screen tv. At certain times there is a mariachi band that play table to table, they too are very friendly and fun. My girlfriend and I visit this establishment a couple times a month and we highly recommend it.