Mr Sammy's NY Style Pizza Bistro & Italian Cuisine

The food was great, but the staff is phenomenal!! They let my little guy help make a pizza and made memories that will last a lifetime!!

Great NY style pizza. A fun, laid-back atmosphere of friendly staff and locals. Night we stopped for dinner the place was packed at 4:30 pm and remained that way. Great service and reasonable prices all done right.

Pizza was great, but service was amazing. We dined at Mr. Sammy's on 9/11. We are moving to Lake Placid soon and have been trying all of the pizza places. When we entered the restaurant, a sign at the entrance stated 50% off for first responders. What a patriotic and heartwarming gesture. My husband is a police officer, so we were given the discount. We in turn applied our discount as our tip for the server. Thank you for your kindness, hospitality, and delicious pizza! You have made a regular out of us when we move to Lake Placid.

This establishment can not be matched in quality or style of food. Sammy's has perfected the New York style pizzeria with excellent quality food. The atmosphere is very welcoming, whether you want to relax after a long, hard day at work with a refreshing beer or want to have a family dinner with great service. I would highly recommend enjoying some of Sammy's wings because they are incredibly delicious.

Always feel welcome when I call or walk in and pizza is awesome. I'm born and raised in Manhattan, NY had the best pizza there and Queens and the Bronx, Sammy's is right up there with the best.

Had Sammy's classic pizza, and it was excellent! Lots of toppings and the sauce was perfect. Crust... outstanding New York style. Service was also the best! Friendly and attentive.

This is an amazing place! A friend took us there when we visited from out of town. The owner was a friend from hello! The staff was incredible and fun! Loved the decor…Spot on! It was like visiting family the entire dining experience, you have a special place here! Will visit every time I’m in town!

Delicious experience. Because of a food allergy, I requested to make my eggplant rollatini alfredo, and it was so good, rich and cheesy, they should put it on the menu permanently. Picture attached. Garlic knots are perfect, and mini canolis just the right size for a sweet bite as a finishing touch.

What a special day they made for my Daughter on her 8th birthday. Wonderful bunch of nice guys who really care about you having a great experience, even if it's "not on the menu" = they gave us Italian icy for the birthday gift too! (We didn't even ask!)

Amazing place, had a nice 80s NY vibe, staff were conversational and friendly, and the two of us that went agreed it was one of the best NY style pizzas we've had. Overall, amazing experience!

Best Stromboli I have ever had! And I have had a lot from many pizzerias/Italian restaurants. Also they are HUGE!

Update: Returned today for the 5 year anniversary under new management, same great food!

We very much, enjoyed our pizza. Looking forward to trying the pasta dishes.

Best pizza in Florida. Good prices and great people.

Loved it.

Wine & Beer Great
Calzone & pizza Great
Soup Great
Local Flavor and friendly service

If you ask me, this is the best pizza in Florida. as close to New York as it gets. Thank you Sammy for all your hard work.🙏🏼 God bless

Absolutely love this place. The food and staff are wonderful. Try the stuffed shells, the cheesesteak stromboli, the meatballs, I hope you visit when they have the loaded baked potato soup. It’s all delicious! Do not leave without dessert, the cheesecake is a must! My Kids LOVE Mr. Sammy & the beautiful Taryn!

Friendly place. Delicious Italian food and FAST seevice. I had the cauliflower white pizza. All was yey good!

AWESOME pizza some of the best I have ever had. Staff is friendly

Great Italian dishes and even better pizza, this place never disappoints! I was here the other night and Sammy allowed a little girl to go behind the counter and make her own pizza, a memory that will last a lifetime for her, that’s what it’s all about. I noticed some comments saying that the employees speak very loud, welcome to an Italian family dinner.

Lake Placid's best pizza! Sammy is amazing! He he even taught my girls how to make their own pizza. Sammy really treats everyone like family.