The Elias Inn Supper Club

Wonderful evening last night at The Elias Inn Supper Club in Watertown, courtesy of our cheerful, delightfully kind and attentive server Whitney H. The Elias Inn is the undisputed king of the relish tray - brought to the table on its own lazy Susan. Good thing we had an empty seat at our table. 😂 I had the Queen cut prime rib and the ladies had the ribeye steak sandwich special - both entrees superb, seasoned and cooked to perfection. I also can’t remember a time I wanted to rave about mashed potatoes (well… not true - it was the last time my mom made them for me) but still, they were positively delicious and I would actually recommend them. Brandy Old Fashioned Sweets were also top notch. We capped off the night with a Brandy Alexander for us and a Grasshopper for our guest of honor. If you’re anywhere near Watertown, treat yourself to a fantastic meal. And ask for Whitney. She’ll carry it over the goal line for you.

We had a lovely time. I must say we are very picky with food....foodies you could Sat. The fare at Elias is amazing, full of flavor, unique, and presented well. Presentation to the eyes is the first "taste", and Elias and Sobies does this perfectly. The wine was outstanding as well.

Stopped on a Friday, while in Watertown, limited Friday lunch menu was smaller but had some decent non fish fry options (I was gonna have one with my wife later). I had the Chopped Steak Sandwich. It was chopped prime rib with horseradish cream, sauteed mushrooms, onions and peppers on a toasted French bread served au jus and topped with a pile of fried onion strings. It was an awesome sandwich. Very cool smaller supper club.

Elias Inn Supper Club certainly delivers a great meal and experience on all levels. We were warmly greeted and confirmed our reservation with the hostess as we entered the bar area. As we waited for the rest of our party, we enjoyed a drink in the bar area. After enjoying Old Fashioneds and wine, we took our seats in the quaint dining area. The relish lazy Susan relish tray and bread basket were an excellent starter. The baked French onion soup was also amazing. We enjoyed prime rib, crab stuffed shrimp, and seafood de jonghe. All were delicious! We ended the meal with a pink Cadillac and a grasshopper. The staff couldn't have been more pleasant and attentive. It was a wonderful experience!

Best. Breakfast. Ever. Came here for Sunday Brunch and had The Family Style Breakfast which came with fruit, pastries, bacon, pancakes, hashbrowns, and eggs. The hashbrowns and bacon were some of the best I've ever had.

We really enjoyed our time here. The broasted chicken and the alfredo with chicken came out fresh and hot. Both were 10/10. The seasoned French fries are a must try. What we really liked were the entrees came with soup, salad, and a lazy Susan relish tray. The lazy Susan is the first item brought out, and it's just fun to try all that is offered on it like cheese, beet salad, Artichoke dip, etc. Also, the staff were wonderful. The Elias Inn is a great place and they truly offer fine dining

Wow absolutely worth it. Also order the relish tray for an old school flavor experience! I’m thinking the chef is related to the chef at Ishnala, yes that good.

The Elias Inn servers the BEST fish fry!!! They don't take reservations on Friday nights. The wait is usually an hour or more. I promise, it is worth the wait!!

Cozy, quaint place with traditional supper club food. The whole night was an experience, from drinks at the bar, to the relish tray, to soup/salad, to the entree (with sides), to finally dessert. The staff know how to make your dinner perfect, the food is a gastronomic delight, and the ambiance makes you all warm and fuzzy. 10 stars!!!

Wow! A great tasting meal in a quaint supper club! The five of us enjoyed our reasonably priced dinners which included a choice of soup or salad AND a delicious lazy Susan (salads, cheeses, pickles, veggies, dinner rolls and bread sticks!). Many fine dining places charge additional for your salads or soups. When in Door County we paid $12 for a super club lazy susan that wasn’t near as lovely as the Elias Inn one. Service was excellent too!

Elias Inn Watertown, WI - this was a fun first visit. Ron Faiola's "Wisconsin Supper Clubs" brought us in. We started at the bar, enjoying a couple Wisconsin classics - Brandy Old Fashioneds while learning a little history of the place from the bartender. The evenings host prepared our table and escorted us into the eclectic dining room where our server, was great - she signed our book and informed us she'd been serving at Elias Inn over 20 years and loved it - and it showed, she took great care of us. "She" had the scallops and I had the Rib - our entrees and sides were all delicious - this was a really fun visit. We're looking forward to visiting Elias Inn again when we get that direction. Stop in and have cocktail, stay for dinner - I know you'll be glad you took time to experience Elias Inn in Watertown, WI

The relish tray you get with some meals is the bomb. Food was great. Make sure to make reservations though! Place has a nice German feel to it. Definitely a must stop.

The best pork schnitzel you'll find anywhere in Wisconsin and beyond. The cajun cod soup is amazing - chicked full of flavorful fish. Get yourself there for great classical American or Western European food.

Tremendous place! This was my first time eating at a Wisconsin supper club. It looks like a family run business, everybody was nice.

We enjoyed a delicious fish fry. Had great service with our waitress Monica. We had our SC cone with us and owner came to table to visit. Highly recommend.

A group of 14 people had reservations last night at the Elias Inn. We were promptly seated. Our hostess and waitress were very attentive. Several of our drinks “missed the mark”. They seemed to be missing the alcohol!! Our food was overly salted. Hard to eat….the steak, veggies, spatzle, and schnitzel. Our only mistake was not saying something at the time. But since we were a large group we couldn’t communicate with each other at the time!!!

Searched a long time for a good fish fry.
this place has it.

Brought my grandpa and his wife here for dinner with my fiance and I, the food is always amazing! The seating is so cute, feels very homey! Love the renovations they did!

This place is charming and has the best all you can eat fish fry. Trust me, I have tried many places over the years and this is the best.
I have not had it yet, but I hear the Prime Rib is amazing too! I am so grateful it’s a mile down the road. You will want to come early to avoid the crowd but that is expected at any place that has excellent food. Love this Supper Club!

This is easily one of the best supper clubs we have been to in the state. The tray with salads, and dips was great and then followed up with a good soup and salad. The prime rib and shrimp was very good. The tap beer selection was also good. Server and hostess were excellent. Just a great place to eat.