The Rustic Muffin

We LOVE Rustic Muffin! I am gluten free and love actually being able to eat yummy food with my family! So many gluten free choices between muffins, doughnuts, and bagels! Everything I’ve tried has been tasty. They use a separate toaster for gf items and seem to take the precautions they can to keep things allergy friendly. Super relaxing atmosphere and kind employees. We’ve been many times and will be back for more!

ACCESSIBILITY: Wheelchair friendly dining area but a note if using the bathrooms, the paper towels are out of reach.

The muffins are amazing! They have an incredible outer crunchy crust I love and the inside is super soft and just delicious! They are pricey but they are huge too… They have lots of fun drinks. Their bagels are soooo good… Hard to choose what to eat because there are lots of really good choices! Plus their decoration makes it really relaxed and cozy. Overall a great place.

Anniston and Kayla had such amazing customer service! Not only did they help our group of three find the exact items we wanted but they also made it a fun experience! Give them a raise!

Great place, with a great vibe!

We come a few times a week. Love the small town feel. Coffee is excellent, and bagels are from ny! They have the largest iced lattes I've ever seen.

Rustic muffin has become my favorite breakfast location on the weekend or if I need a quick pick me up on my way to work. Conveniently located and ever has a drive through! I would recommend their bagel breakfast sandwiches or my personal favorite the cappuccino chocolate chunk muffin!
This has become a staple with my toddler on a Saturday morning where she insists on getting her pink sprinkle donut and won’t stop talking about it on the quick journey back to cane bay! Keep up the good work at Rustic Muffin!

Such a cute coffee shop with great coffee and great food! It was decorated so tastefully for the holidays. Would recommend for a quick coffee or a nice place to sit and enjoy a sip.

Super cute coffee shop that offers a variety of drinks, not just coffee. Very quaint and you can only order to go but they have a covered sitting area in the back. We went twice in a matter of a few days because we loved it the first try. Everything we had was good. Hot chocolates, breakfast tea, cinnamon raisin bagel, Elf muffin amongst other things. Customer service was wonderful and they even have other little items for purchase like candles, plants, and dog treats! Although it's not close to me, I'll definitely stop back in when passing thru.

We’ve been going to Rustic Muffin for at least 3 years now. Every time we go, the staff is so friendly (even though they are busy!) and the bagels and coffees are amazing. Growing up in south Jersey I have missed bagels like this. I also love the monthly signature lattes, I can’t get enough of how creative and tasty they all are.

The person who was making the coffee/tea today (I think her name was Elli) made me the most delicious chai tea latte I’ve ever had. It was spectacular. Mm mm mm! My bagel was also amazing, very well made and tasty. 😋 Thanks for a great breakfast besties 😙

I hired the Rustic Muffin to cater my baked potato bar and it was amazing!!! Everyone raved about how perfectly the potatoes were cooked and how amazing the desserts were!! The Lemon Blueberry Cookies were biggest hit!!!!

I am so glad The Rustic Muffin came to MC. We really needed a place to get a good pastry and a coffee. I ordered breakfast for my entire group and everyone enjoyed their food. The food was ready on time, hot, and delicious. The pastry selection was wonderful. The only issue was the girl at the front counter could've been a bit more friendly. She was very short with me and a smile would have made my day. I will just assume she was having a bad morning, and this will not stop me from returning. My entire crew even talked about coming back tomorrow for breakfast. Thanks again for coming here, and I look forward to coming back with friends and family to enjoy more of your wonderful food.

Love it here!! Food is amazing, and Kayla our server was such a help!

Got a Blueberry Muffin from the truck and OMG! That muffin was what every muffin should be. Crispy edges, fluffy and not overly sweet. Wish I had found them sooner!

SOO good! i come here almost every day before going to my 9-5 & the service is always impeccable! faith, kayla, and arianna are always ready to serve with beaming smiles! definitely recommend the hungry man, caesar salad, and breakfast burrito!

Our family really loves it here!
Gotta try the jalapeno bagels and iced coffee .
My High school son just sent me this text message a few days ago. **** mom? bring me a da Bronx from rustic muffin and give me $10 at the game instead of $20 to cover my da Bronx ****
This happens at least 2x's a week. I can't blame him, because they are the BEST!

Just moved from the northeast where we have some great coffee. Was hoping to find some great coffee shops - stopped in here and it was one of the best iced coffees / cold brews I’ve ever had. Breakfast sandwiches were also amazing! So thrilled to have this place so close.

The Rustic Muffin is the newest gem located just a short distance from Cane Bay. The neighborhood Facebook page has been raving about how incredible the bagels and coffee are so I made this a must try. I came in around 10:45 and the parking lot was packed. Not a spot to be had. However, people were walking out as fast as they were walking in, so I managed to grab a spot and head in. The atmosphere has quite the charm and I could feel so much positive energy. There were three young ladies staffing the counter and constantly smiling and moving with a purpose. They provided excellent customer service and did so with efficiency.
I just finished my Jalapeno Bagel with Jalapeno cream cheese and I'll have to say it was probably the best bagel I've ever eaten. The bagel was lightly toasted and had a perfect amount of cream cheese applied. The Cane Bay Bold coffee is equally as amazing. I drink it black of course, and this is just the right amount of smooth and bold to be perfect for any time of day. I'm always hesitant when I hear so many great reviews because it puts it on a pedestal, but fortunately, The Rustic Muffin delivered. I'll be back this weekend to try a bacon, egg, and cheese bagel. Thank you and welcome to the Bay.

Walked in hearing folks complaining about the population increase in this 🌎. Not to mention, Cane Bay is starting to look like the BQE. Furgettaboutit!. NO KIDDEN! well known for bagels. This place took me back home. community and quality of life focused.

Great little shop! Went to the shopping center for another reason and decided to stop in since I had heard great things about it. I love blueberry muffins but none were available. This was around noon so maybe once an item sells out there isn't any more made. I tried a cinnamon roll ( I believe that was the name) with pecans and a muffin with carrots and raisins. Both were great. I will try to go earlier next time to see more variety of items.

The rustic muffin is amazing stop! The staff is wonderful and always makes thing perfect! My favorite breakfast place!