Hart Bakery & Gifts

I got a birthday cake made for my hubby last minute and Cherice was very responsive and nice. The cake looks exactly like the picture I sent her and it tastes divine. I will definitely be back 😊

We ordered a custom tiered cake for our sons 5th birthday. The staff were so kind and they did a wonderful job. 5⭐ Thank you Hart Bakery.

My mom used to get every birthday cake from Hart Bakery 30 years ago. Now that I have children of my own, I've carried on the tradition of getting every birthday cake from Hart Bakery for my kids' birthdays as well. That's how wonderful their cakes are! Hart Bakery is amazing!

Every time I've got donuts from here they have always been extremely good. Today I stopped in and the door was still unlocked after closing. Since they had already close the cash register the nice lady just gave me the donuts free of charge.
Kindness is still out here 🥰

Forget Dunkin Donuts or Krispy Kreme. GARBAGE!!! This place does things the old school way! The woman that works there treats everyone like she's your grandma, so friendly and knowledgeable. They'll take very good care of you. Beautiful and delicious cakes, cookies and pastries. And you could spend hours browsing the very reasonably priced gifts and tchotchkes.

The bakery is run by the sweetest lady who has been there since the 1940s. In the back kitchen I could see her happy family making cookies by hand.

I asked for the best assortment of their baked goods to bring to my staff and she could not stop herself from adding addition cookies and donuts (for free) because she just really wanted me to try them. It was very obvious she loves her job and takes pride in her product.

A large box full of baked goods ended up costing only $9. I tried to tip and she refused and said she just wanted me to come back. Trust me... I WILL BE COMING BACK!! The cookies and donuts were so soft and perfectly baked. Everyone loved them. They have won me over as a customer for life!

I recently had them do a custom wedding cake. We were planning on 10-12 and they suggested an 8" cake when others recommended 6". They sat with me and discussed what the vision was by looking through photos I had on my phone. They did an all white 3 tier cake with buttercream icing and rosettes on the top for the same cost if not less than other bakeries' 6" cakes. The process was easy, the cake looked stunning, the size was perfect and it tasted delicious. I would definitely recommend them!

This place is a hidden gem of my wife and I. We absolutely love it. I'm a truck 🚚 driver who has traveled the entire U.S. and originally coming from N.Y. I know a good bakery when I see one!!!..not to toot my own horn(but toot toot!!!)

- Amazing baked goods in a loving and Godly atmosphere! The (glazed) croissant 🍩 is one of my favorites. 😊
- The ladies are super caring ❤ and always welcome you with loving, warm, open arms...always smiling from the time you open the door till your leaving, which helps me start my day right!
- They carry beautiful unique gifts which are priced to sell and be enjoyed. My wife loves getting a gift each time we visit. The gifts...best described are like precious moments statues type of deal, but of much more variety. We have gotten earrings, a silver goblet, lockets, audio books, and a Bulova clock decoration which holds pictures. Really must visit my words do Hart Bakery no justice.
- They open early morning which is great for me: Mon-Fri : 5:30am Sat : 6:00am
And Sunday they're closed with a sign posted stating they are closed Sunday so you and your family can go to Church...which I think is a beautiful thing that more businesses should do..

Again I love ❤ this place and it's a great little bakery that everyone should visit if in the Indianapolis area!

Love this place, very family friendly environment. They do an awesome job at making cakes and cupcakes and of course everything else. My daughter loves going here. Don't pass this place up!

I love harts bakery . So good & my girls cakes were very pretty .
The owner is so nice & so is the staff . We added the cake toppers but the cake looked glittery & so pretty in person

Amazing experience MY first time ordering from them was last summer for my fiancé's surprise birthday dinner cake turned out AMAZING!

Most definitely recommended the food is so mouth watering yummy most definitely will be back

They never disappoint I been here 3 years in Indiana found out a year ago about Harts love this bakery I might add I been here everyday this week I gotta stop

What a great place and person just made my custom cake in like an hour never ever had such experiences before and cake is also fabulous. Really impressed!

I visited Hart Bakery for the first time and was so impressed!! The owner came out from the back to greet me. She was so proud to share a few of her favorite product recommendations. Before I left, she made sure I took a “Hart” magnet for my refrigerator. I am so glad I discovered this local gem. The baked goods are delicious, and the local heart of the business really shines through. I will definitely be back.

Great bakery, the alligators are the best. Like a 1.5-2 ft long coffee cake. Best to pre-order as they don't usually have many otherwise.

Excellent little bakery with a hidden stache of incredible miniatures and more!
Sandy and her staff were exceptionslly friendly and colorful! The sticky bun I had was out of this world delicious and I got a bunch of miniatures for my dollhouse that are very difficult to find at great prices! I hope to visit again in the near future!!! Highly recommend!!!

Went in on a Friday - tried their cherry donut - only made on Fridays (or so I was told). It was absolutely delicious. I asked for a variety as I had never been before, and the ladies working that day did not disappoint. I'll have to come back and try their cookies and other baked goods. Very reasonable price point and friendly staff.

The prices are competitive, the cakes are the best around and the donuts are always fresh and delicious! Sandy has been the owner for several years and continues to be friendly and courteous. Sandy is simply the best. She is also very knowledgeable about cakes, frosting and recipes. I can't wait to get my daughters wedding cake.

We are in here at least twice a week. This is where we get all of our birthday cakes. It's the only birthday cakes my daughter and husband will eat. Their donuts are the best!! Make sure on Fridays or Saturdays you go early. They are also the nicest people up there. Never met a rude one. They always treat you like family.