That's Amore

Oh my goodness! Had a delicious dinner here after a small wedding. We had 3 dinner options to choose from and the Seafood Amore was outstanding!! Soooo yummy. The wait staff was friendly and accommodating. In particular, Tiffany was very helpful. We appreciated her service! The complimentary appetizers for all the guests and then the complimentary desserts for the bride and groom were a great touch. The cocktails we ordered were also delicious.

This place is fantastic. Currently my favorite Italian restaurant in the Milwaukee area.
The entire restaurant, including the name, is rat pack themed. Pictures of Frank Sinatra o, Dean Martin , Sammy Davis Jr,, Peter Lawford, and Joey Bishop adorn the walls. There's also several pictures of family members form the old country framed near the waiting area. A lovely touch.
The Caesar salad is a bit heavy on the sauce and light on the Parmesan. I wish they would throw some croutons on there as well. Come aaaaaawwwwwn 5.0/10
The breadsticks 8.4/10
Red sauce 9.0/10
Mixed veg. What am I? On a hospital diet? Throw a little salt on the steamed veggies 3.4/10
Italian sausage sandwich 8.9/10
Very good with the peppers. It went well with some extra red sauce. I would make a trip back just to have this sandwich again.
Baked zitti 8.7/10 Anthony Jr would be excited.

Havent been there in a few years. Food was terrific, the atmosphere was wonderful, the waitress was top notch. Great Italian food!

Best Italian food in Milwaukee, served in a beautiful space. The restaurant is always hopping, and with good reason! Fresh and delicious menu items, friendly and attentive staff (Tiffany was wonderful!) and an atmosphere of fun and relaxation keep us coming back!

Top quality authentic italion food.superb service amd unique old brat pack Italian atmosphere..

Super great Italian food, I had the pappardelle with bolognese sauce. Salad and bread sticks came with and I topped off with tiramisu. Excellent service and on a Thursday at lunch was hopping!

We were our Friday night fish fry group. They bring a large salad bowl as opposed to Cole slaw. I could make a meal of the salad, the dressing is outstanding. That's not to say the fish wasn't good, it was.

First time here and the food was quite good. Very inviting atmosphere. Service was good and food came quite quickly. I ordered the mushroom ravioli and I would order it again.

Wonderful local Italian restaurant! Inviting atmosphere with a great selection of cocktails, wines and Italian eats! The service is very friendly and quick, not rushed at all but very attentive. The food itself is delicious and came out hot. Highly recommend the artichoke dip and fried eggplant appetizer. Large portions where meals could be shared. Classic Italian desserts. They also have an amazing salad and Italian dressing that is worth visiting for alone! Highly recommend!

Food was delicious server was friendly GREAT atmosphere! Will be back!

Went for lunch and want to go back. Many Italian options, served with Italian salad and warm bread sticks. Had lunch portions on the menu, still left with a doggie bag. Exceptional value and quality.

A group of my friends and I come here often and nobody's ever had a bad meal. The service is always great, too. Today we dined on their beautiful patio for the first time and it was lovely. Their lasagna is some of the best I've ever had.

Posted this review a year ago but I had to come back, just to say that you guys are just awesome. Every time I eat here I leave 100% satisfied. The pescatore pasta is great. The prime rib is flat out amazing.
If you can help it, don’t sit on the top floor. It is extremely loud when it’s busy..which it usually is. However you do get a great view of everyone’s plate if you can’t decide 😉

The employees are so nice and helpful!! they had a beautiful set up for my birthday lunch and treated us great! The food is delicious. The only reason it didn’t get a five star for food is because their breadsticks are very basic

Started with bloody marys, which come with a pickle and string cheese stick. Tastes like they use shrimp sauce in their mix. Unusual but tasty. Large italian salad and warm breadsticks were a good start. Dinners were al dente fettuccine with shrimp and garlic butter sauce, chicken pietro with a mushroom sauce, and homemade Italian sausage with rigatoni in a marinara sauce with mushrooms baked with mozzarella. Awesome decor with phoyos and italian artwork, Dean Martin themed. Everything was very good and fairly priced. Can't wait to go back and try more selections from the extensive menu!

They actually take reservations on a Friday night! Excellent fish fry -- served with unlimited green salad and buttery bread sticks 😋 . Herb baked cod was excellent 👌. Waitress was knowledgeable and table was bussed regularly. Restaurant is very large but packed at 6pm. Reservations recommended.

My family and I made reservations for 8 on Oct 8, 2022 before we headed to Boehner Botanical Gardens. Our wait staff was Tricia F. She was fabulous, I highly recommend requesting her. She was so patient with our large party. She also was very helpful, putting tables together for us, extra napkins, drinks, patient with the kids in our group, etc. The food was good, always hot. Steaks & Prime Rib was perfect. Appetizer plates were huge. Atmosphere was cozy, and made you relax. Drinks from the bar were spot on - Appetini, Blue Hawaiian, Watermelontini, etc. No complaints from us. We will be back!!!

02/14/23 @ 4:30p
Came to this restaurant for Valentine's Day. We had to make a reservation, since it was going to be busy. We were seated right away upstairs. The waiter was very attentive! Everything tasted amazing.
•Mozzarella Marinara
•Salad & Breadsticks
•Tortellini
•Chicken Parmesian

After being seated, we were given ample time to look over the menu and place our drink order. After the drinks arrived, we placed our dinner selections along with the appetizer. Food was served hot and delicious! Baked Ziti and tortellini with garlic and herb sauce

Friendly and welcoming. We came from a funeral, and the kitchen was clising in 10 min. They invited us to sit and order dinner. Everything was great, from the fresh crisp salad, bread rolls, and ample portions of entrees. The cook came out so we could thank him and his staff. He said he has kept the kitchen open for other funeral goers before. We were treating like family. Thank you.