St. Paul Fish Company Mequon

If you love seafood, this is the place for you! As you walk in, there's an area with a variety of fresh seafood such as fish, shrimp, scallops, lobster, etc. Everything we tried was delicious. My first time having Oyster Rockefeller was here, and it did not disappoint. The calamari and the peel and eat shrimp were also some of the other appetizers we sampled. For dinner, I selected the bouillalbaisse, and my cousins opted for the lobster mac and cheese. They both were divine. Do yourself a favor and pay them a visit.

We loved this place. It was far for us to come but it was a birthday adventure for me. Our meals were outstanding, The service was great. We sat in a cozy table in the corner. We were first seated at a table in the middle of the room. We asked our waiter if we could move to the corner booth. He was very accommodating. They have a fish market also. So we had a terrific time / meal and also bought some things for home. Kyle was a very good waiter. Destiny ~ " I gotchu" has an incredible personality - made us feel sooo welcome, prepared the items we took home (removed skin etc) , let us taste the salmon jerky and we bought a big selection for home. It was an all around wonderful experience. We will be back. It was delightful. The Sea Bass ~>🤤🤤🤤 Sooo good.

This dinner was AMAZING! Oyster shooters, Cajun BBQ shrimp, crab cake and schlitz-battered cod frys. Food, service and setting was great. May just be my new favorite restaurant.

Fantastic food! Will definitely be going back. Super fresh seafood. Very busy place so definitely recommend reservations. But a fun delicious place if you love seafood!
Highly recommend 👌

This is my new favorite place! We live in the area but just had not made it here yet. We were seated quickly(we had reservations.) Our server Kyle greeted us right away and took our drink and appetizer orders. We ordered a crabcake appetizer and the barbecued shrimp. The crabcake was lightly breaded and seasoned, and served with a remoulade sauce, and a little bit of greens on the side. The barbecue shrimp had six shrimp, and the sauce was really good. It came with two pieces of toasted bread to my mop up the sauce. We ordered a bottle of Grgich Hills Sauvignon Blanc. It went great with all of our food. Not too fruity like some of the New Zealand Sauvignon Blancs. This was dry and crisp. For entrées, my husband had the pan seared scallops. They were nicely caramelized, with a beurre blanc sauce that was delicately delicious, and also some vegetables and rice. They were big scallops. Cooked perfectly. I had the perch fish fry, and had an unbelievable six pieces of perch, lightly breaded, could’ve used one more wedge of lemon. It came with a good tartar sauce, some coleslaw which my husband ate, and really great fries. For dessert, we shared a piece of Key lime pie. It was plenty for two. Fresh, tart, and round not like a pie piece. Lots of light whipped cream that was not overly sweet. The whole meal, with the two appetizers, two entrées, dessert, and a bottle of wine, was $120 not including the tip. We felt like that was a great value. Also, our server Kyle was just the right amount of attentiveness, and was also helped by other people. We had a woman who served us wine, and another guy who brought us our entrées. I would have no hesitation recommending this place for a great tasty dinner. It is a little loud, so, if you are looking for a quiet, romantic restaurant, this would not be the place. It is more family style, and lively.

I am from the UK, and I have to say, as a nation that does fish and chips regularly, this place blew UK fish and chips away.

I had to eat the fish with my hands it was that tender, and it just melted in your mouth.

Possibly the best fish and chips I have ever had.

This place was great!!! If you want seafood you’ll get seafood. It's hard to find this quality of seafood at a causal place in South east Wisconsin.

Love this place! We had the shark bites (baby shark, maybe?) And Pan Seared Scallops and Mahi Mahi. Absolutely delicious! Top notch serve by Val, very attentive. All around a great experince.

My husband and I visited your retail store in Mequon this morning and loaded up with seafood for homemade gumbo. Freshest seafood at great prices, this will be our new go to! Everything from grouper to squid was sparkling fresh and delicious! Great service, too. Can't wait to return and dine in the restaurant, your menu is thoughtfully curated and fairly priced, and so much from which to choose!🍤🐟🐙🦀🦐🦑

St. Paul Fish Company in Mequon; WI is an Excellent Seafood Restaurant with Appetizers; a large assortment of Fresh Oysters; Sandwiches ; Lunch and Dinner Entree's with nice Portions- GREAT Bloody Mary's! Try the Smoked Salmon Seafood Crack ( a Sweet and moist Salmon bits); I will be coming back for Happy Hour Thursday called Oyster Shuck for a $1.00- usually Blue Point Oysters. Happy Hours 3:00-6:00. A "Must Try " Restaurant !

Great food, great service. The seafood is fresh and we've liked everything we've tried so far. For 2 meals, 1 child meal, 1 cranberry juice and 1 specialty drink we spent about $80.

I dined here alone, and it was a really lovely experience. The food was just as good as the service. You can order oysters from a little paper menu (just like you can order sushi rolls at some restaurants), which was super fun. The bouillabaisse was also incredible.

Great meal! The restaurant gets Busy so a reservation is a must. Our server was delightful and attentive. Our meals were served hot and timely, and both were delicious. We’ve dined here about 10 times and have never been disappointed. I love their vegetable medley served as a side on the dinner entrees - always fresh and perfectly cooked.

Let’s just start with the crab cake which was out of this world delicious! I had a lobster roll and couldn’t rave enough about and my bf had the shrimp po’ boy which he loved. I ordered a Paloma which was also great. Waitress was wonderful and attentive. Can’t wait to go back!

Had lunch today with the wife at St. Paul Fish Co. The first thing you see is all the fresh fish laid out behind the counter, and a live lobster tank near the Hostess stand. We were seated immediately and the wait staff was very kind and attentive. I’ll note here that the restaurant is very clean and we enjoyed the decor. We ordered a lobster dinner, Tuna Melt, and New England Clam Chowder. First off, the Clam Chowder was excellent, very creamy with large pieces of clams, served with oyster crackers. The lobster which was very tasty came with baby red potatoes and a cob of corn. The Tuna Melt was probably made with some of the best tasting Tuna I’ve ever had, very fresh. With the prices being very reasonable, and the seafood outstanding, I would highly recommend the St. Paul Fish Co.

Loved getting a quick and tasteful lunch with my friend here. We got the lobster roll and crab roll and a shark appetizer. So delicious and fresh....cannot wait to go back and try more things on the menu.

They even have a area to pick up fresh seafood and take it home to cook in recipes. Of course fresh means more expensive but so worth the taste buds.

Fresh seafood in the midwest. Speed in for some oysters and a cold beer on my birthday. If I didn't have dinner plans elsewhere I would have stayed all evening. I did take home some fresh tuna, salmon spread, and salmon jerky. Grouper looked good too, maybe next time. Or scallops. Or oysters.

First time visitor checking in :)

AMAZING food from St Pauls, someone that’s super VIP told me about the lobster rolls, I’ve been thinking about trying them ever since! I wanted more!!!

Now the rest of my meal, omgosh I told the server EMILY, “I want Crab Legs, but it’s too much work. I’ll have lobster instead.” She said, “there’s some work with the lobster too, but I’ll help you.”

St. Paul Fish Company 10/10 & the server was even more AMAZING. Can’t wait to visit again. Lobster was so dang good. I left wanting more.

Best dinner I have had in a really long time!!!

Exceptional food, drinks and service. Huge selection of fresh seafood, chef prepared perfectly. Oysters are delicious, tried a variety of oysters and all were good! I had the walleye and partner had lobster boil- cooked perfectly and absolutely delicious. Highly recommend!!