Sal's Pizza Company

Loyal customers love this pizza consistently made with love. Family loves the garbage pizza. I switch black olives for green olives and added bacon. This pizza is so good highly suggest. The crust is always perfect. The ingredients are fresh and evenly distributed. Cream cheese jalapeño poppers were good.
Inferno wings are so good beware, very hot.
2024 updates further amazing food we have tried:
Shrimp 🍤 🦐 love these and cocktail sauce so good.
Best 👌🏾 👍 😍 jelepeno poppers cheddar cheese had delivered and still hot and crispy.
BOS- crispy bacon can never go wrong. Great crust and sausage, homemade taste always fresh always good.
Mediterranean pizza - crust crispy buttery garlic taste topping good only feedback would rather thin sliced tomato slices.
Everything we try is good ...next time, we need to try Sals brbq ribs.

Sals always passes the vibe check. The pizza is great! The staff is always friendly and the delivery service is exceptional. We've never had an issue and we've been ordering for years. The taste is always consistent. You truly couldn't ask for better quality. Thanks always guys!!

The way I found out about this place was honestly the Dave Portnoy review… lol. I saw the video and it looked so good that the next day I put in an order for pickup. I ordered a large thin crust with half cheese and half sausage, green peppers, and onion. The pizza was amazing, the cheese was amazing and a classic and the sausage pepper and onion pizza was as well. The cheese is very good and the sauce has a very good flavor to it. Crust is amazing as well. They also do a very good job of loading the toppings on there. Honestly probably best pizza I’ve had. The guys working there were all very nice and it was a very good “customer” experience. When you leave a tip the worker goes “guys we got a tip” and all the guys in the back go “thank you!” So that is cool to see as well. It is delivery or pick up only but they have a dine in location in Huntley I look forward to trying soon. Great place and will definitely be a return customer!

Wanted a local pizzeria instead of a chain and can say I definitely found one. The pizza is delicious! I've ordered thin and thick crust and they were cooked beautifully. The employees are always so polite as well.

We’ve ordered from here multiple times & it never disappoints. The pizzas are always amazing & filled with flavor. They don’t skip out on the ingredients either, love it! I would definitely recommend to give it a go.

Both the thin crust and pan pizza are excellent. I can't pick only one so I get both when I order. Try it, you won't be disappointed.

My go to spot for Pizza. Don't be afraid to be creative with their ingredients. I have them make a Mediterranean w/beef dipped in Au jus Gravy 😏.

Best Pizza around, they never disappoint! I wish they could open one in Crystal Lake. We live about 20 minutes from the Algonquin one, but the Pizza closer to us doesn’t compare to Sals.

One of the best pizzas I ever had. I've tried their dinners as well, spaghetti, pizza bread, ect. Nothing has disappointed me and their apps are fantastic as well. When we went ,our waitress was kind and attentive. The atmosphere is of an old pizza parlor with a small bar inside. I'll definitely be back!

Best Pizza Ever!!! So much flavor! Everything comes out perfect every time! Very friendly and hard working staff!

I can’t get over how good this pizza was! I ordered the Hawaiian and added bacon and jalapeños. DROOL.
The gentleman who took my delivery order was really helpful and friendly. He suggested the pizza sauce base and gave some appetizer recommendations for next time! He said delivery would be 45-60 minutes and the driver got here in 45!
I highly recommend this pizzeria, and I can’t wait to order again!

Best pizza in McHenry county in my opinion

Best pizza I'm town, I go there at least once a week

Dave Portnoy gave it a 7.6 pizza rating. Nice to see Sal’s get some good reviews from the Barstool owner. I grew up on this pizza. Order the meatball pizza it’s amazing.

A hidden gem if your not local... definitely reccomend. Delicious pizza and excellent service! My last visit was in May and now November 10th 2023 this is the first time I'm having pizza without my Wife Jenny. She had passed June 30th from colon cancer and today is pizza in her honor. She would've absolutely come in and tell you how much she enjoys the pizza. Thank you for being such an awesome business cooking up the best pizza around.

I found this place from Barstool. It's awesome. Easily my favorite in the area. The staff is super nice and the pizza is A+.

Take out only, but, OMG, FANTASTIC 🍕🍕. The thickess thin crust pizza ever! Not that the crust is thick but the toppings are HUGE! Great flavor, thickness, WOWZA!! Thanks so much, will be back for the unmtieth time!!! 🤤🤤🤤

The absolute banger. Algonquin’s very own legends. Best pie hands down. Generous, always hot, and the dough crunch is top tier. 10/10

My second time ordering from them and I will forever be a customer! Not only was their customer service accommodating to a special request but their pizza is FANTASTIC!! We have been loyal to nicks pizza and georgios and no more! Sal’s pizza is probably the best stuffed pizza I’ve ever had! And the price point is perfect!! We are so glad we found you guys! If you haven’t tried this pizza place before I HIGHLY recommend you do!!

PS my son is NOT a crust eater. And with your pizza he devours it crust and all!

I went in for a pick up order from Crystal Lake and discovered my order was made incorrectly. Patrick, offered to remake the pie and personally deliver to me. Was at my house within 30 minutes! Not only is Sals the best pizza around but the customer service is top notch! Thank you Patrick!