Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

This is probably the best Italian restaurant in Long Island for the price. Not just pizza but other dishes too. The pizza is just the best nice white cheese house sauce with a thicker dough for stability and crispiness. Perfect in every way. I’ve been coming here since I was a kid always getting pizza whether it be veggie, mushroom, cheese, margarita, Brooklyn or Sicilian but now as an adult I come here almost every week for the pasta. Both the tomato and marinara is simply to die for, always hot served with bread and a generous portion that can be shared between two people. Place has been renovated 3 times as far as I know and it always looks better. Regular seating and fancy too is available and the staff is friendly as is the owner. Nice people, nice interior, perfect Italian cuisine.

Incredible pizzeria/restaurant. Very tasty food. Service was super friendly. What a great family business. I can’t wait to come back.

It's the sauce!! Loads of fresh food all day every day. Typically same staff faces every single time you walk through the door. Never a disappointment...EVER! Whether taking out, grabbing quick slices, or sitting in the cozy dining room served by the friendliest waitress in the neighborhood you can not go wrong. 10 stars!!

Friendly atmosphere, service was fine, I had pizza that was delicious. I had a white slice & a pepperoni. Both fresh crispy easy to chew crust, great tasting sauce.
I will eat there again when in the area.

Always love Alitalia, but I never complimented the chef last night so I'm writing it here. The special board had a salmon and cannellini beans with greens in a scampi sauce. I can't describe how good it was, well done Chef! Thank you!

A great Pizzeria/Restaurant! A wide variety of Pizza, Sausage and Chicken Rolls and other varieties for a guick bite to eat. The Restaurant has a wide and excellent choices for a sit down dinner. Give it a try when you're in West Babylon!

So many different kinds of pizza slices to choose from. Salad pizza with the eggplant on the bottom is so delicious.

Pizza tasted amazing, staff was happy and upbeat even during the rush we arrived in. Have been here multiple times now and happy each time.

The food is delicious 😋 every time. Customer service is great. The whole staff is awesome.

Amazing pizza place. The only issue i have is that they do not deliver directly. They only deliver through a service. Food amazing though the Chipotle chicken pizza is so good.

This was my first time there and it was outstanding! The service, the food and the atmosphere made for a nice evening. When I'm in the area again I will be dropping in for a bite!

August 6, 2023 review… ok so we ordered the marinara pie (also known as tomato pie in Philly) with pepperoni. It is a deep dish round pie with the texture of a Sicilian pie and the only cheese on it is grated Parmesan I believe but may be Romano. Also added pepperoni as u can see, When I tell you guys it was absolutely amazing, the crust is crispy on the bottom and airy and pillowey on the inside, the sauce is so well balanced, it’s tangy, well seasoned and salted and a tiny bit of spice. No mozzarella needed on this work of perfection!!!!! This is now going to be my go to pizza!!! Can’t wait to try the entrees next time

I wasn't a fan when I first tried the regular pie about a year or two ago and the prices are pretty high for some specialty pies. But as long as they keep the Hot Honey Pie on the menu, I will keep coming back.

This is a Great Pizza Place. Good for Families. And Very Good Tasting Food. 5 Stars by me. Service was on point....Enjoy and Be Safe

So many different choices of pizza types.,,,,,, among other items. Love the crust. Delicious food. Super friendly staff. Great parking. It's in Great South Bay Shopping Center

Not many restaurants use traditional ingredients anymore, so if you find one, better stick with them. Here's a winner 🏆 🥇...

Ordered food was ready when promised and as always it is very good. I pass at least 10 other pizza joints to get to Alitalia because it is that good!

great staff and clean restaurant. bianca was so kind and helpful. delicious pizza and pasta. i really enjoy this place!

They make a great chicken parm with vodka sauce. Also the pepperoni Ala Vodka with hot honey slice is amazing.

We went here Tues 8/22 a party of 4 as a Farwell dinner to an ill friend. I would like to Thank the staff for the wonderful service and food. The server was so accommodating of his food restrictions. So kind so courteous. I am sure we were a bit on the loud side do to all the talk over and laughter and apologize for it. But we were made so welcome. I will recommend this place to everyone. can't say enough great things about this small family restaurant. Again thank you all.