Old School Pizzeria

We love Old School Pizzeria! Delicious pizza, but my favorite is their cheese bread with garlic butter!

Best Pizza in the area, totally worth the drive. Everything is homemade daily, therefore really fresh and delicious. If I could give them more stars I would!

On vacation and we were looking for a place to eat, couldn't have found a better spot. My girlfriend and I had the Grandma Goldies sub which is a pizza on a roll! The sauce is homemade in house, cheese is cut in house and dough (not rolls) is made in house! The owner (Lisa) was great to chat with (we were the only ones there). The sauce reminded me of my grandmothers when she made pizza in a cast iron skillet.

Unfortunately Google only has 5 stars but this place is a 10 in our book! We look forward to a return trip back to the area, currently on vacation!

Grandma Goldie’s sub was amazing! It’s a pizza in a sub roll. Dizzy kept saying it was amazing, so good, I’m full but I want more. Definitely need to check this place out. Lisa, one of the owners is so sweet and personable. She made our lunch experience so much better. Please check them out; it’s worth it. PS: They don’t accept credit cards but they do have an ATM machine on site to pull cash.

Yall. For real the best breadstick I've ever had. Super small, quaint, what you want for an old school pizza place

We discovered the place all of a sudden..was driving around to enjoy the fall colors and saw the place...the pizza surpassed our expectations....very authentic taste..
the interior of the shop was awesome, different in look with a rustic tone..free pool table and pac-man game(which is rare) the owner was very friendly..he showed us around his place..would love to go there again 😊

Had their pizza for the first time last night and I can confidently say it's the best pizza I have ever eaten in my entire life!! Eating leftovers right now and it's just as good the next day! What makes their pizza unique is the sweet tasting pizza crust and ground pepperoni instead of slices. The staff were so accommodating and friendly! Rodney you now have a new customer for life!!

Fresh pizza with a perfect balance of slightly sweet crust and spicy peppers. In addition to the terrific pizza we enjoyed sitting on the patio and watching the classic cars drive by on a fabulous summer's day. While we dined they rolled and baked fresh pepperoni rolls for us to take home.

I recently had the pleasure of visiting School House Pizza in Reedsville Saturday evening. I don't usually endorse places, but will this one. I ordered my pizza and was really enjoying it. Loaded with toppings and tasted fantastic. After telling the owner how good it was, we started talking. He showed me the mixer machine where they make the dough fresh each day. He said that he only uses real cheese that they shred themselves daily. He said he only uses fresh vegetables that are cut fresh each morning. He said they only use the highest quality meats and is also cut daily. I was really impressed. The pizza dough was perfect and the crust just right. He said he didn't want to be just another pizza place, but the best pizza place. I think he has succeeded. You can taste the quality. They are a local small business and trying to grow. If you get the chance, check this place out. You will not be disappointed.

Lisa and Rodney are like family I only met them about 3-4 weeks ago and they treated me and my husband so well Lisa is such a hard worker and does everything in her power to make the pizzas great she pours her heart and soul into every bite the sauce in my opinion is so good. And I love the way they do the pepperoni it's something new I've never had before. And I like change I was tired of the same old bland original pizza of everyday life Lisa and Rodneys pizza has really great flavor and it has a meaning behind each and every bite also the pepperoni rolls with honey butter are to die for!!!!!!! Will definitely be buy more of those ☺ my whole family loves the pizzas!!!!

We stopped and got a pepperoni pizza after visiting Arthurdale Heritage, Inc. Very cool spot. Nice outside sitting area. Pizza was delicious. We will be back!

I picked 5 solely on how delish the pizza was. I think it's the best tasting pizza around. I ordered spicy Italian sausage, black olives and extra cheese on thin crust and pepperoni onions and extra cheese on thin crust on the other. It's hard to stop eating because their pizza is so good!

After wrapping up an exercise on Camp Dawson, my team and I wanted to treat ourselves to some of the local pizza. Old School Pizzeria did NOT disappoint! The whole team loved it. It's very apparent that the team at Old School pours a ton of love and tradition into their food that you'll just never experience at the franchised pizza joints. Not to mention, their customer service is top-notch. If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and go Old School!

Thank you Rodney and crew for an awesome experience. The pizza was out of this world! The only thing better was the customer service. I called unknowingly outside of business hours, and he never once said about being closed, and made the pizza anyway. Rodney treated me like I was his most important customer, and we had never met. He couldn't have been more polite or accomodating. I've never received treatment like this anywhere before at a restaurant. I'll be sure to tell everyone I know in the area to go here for their pizza!

Pizza was awesome, but the pepperoni rolls were hands down the absolute best I've ever had. I was actually mad when I came home and someone had eaten the last one that I thought I hid! Definitely worth the drive!!

Pizza was delicious. All homemade ingredients using an old family recipe. Atmosphere was excellent and very fun. Service was amazing.

Lost in Reedsville, I've never been here before, and stopped in their parking lot to get our bearings. Googled then called to place an order. After a little bit of comical confusion we went inside to order. As it's name states its in an old school, the familiar shiny wood floors gleaming just as they did in my old school when I was a kid. I didn't catch the girls name who was working but she was awesome! Friendly funny and a great pepperoni roll cooker! The inside decor was nostalgic, old pictures, Ms. Pacman machine, old auditorium seats along one wall and I think even a jukebox plus much more! Comfy seating with an oversized checkers game which I won a round against my friend lol. The pepperoni rolls were delicious even without their homemade honey butter the girl apologized for not having and Scruffy gave it a paws up too!! Reasonably priced, very clean, super friendly and speedy service.
We'll definitely return to try the pizza and honey butter! This place is a hidden gem!

When I heard old school was opening, I couldn’t wait. I remember when getting pizza from Rodney’s when he was out on rt 92 near Brownsmill. That pizza made a huge impression back then, and it still is just as tasty! I really liked the dining area and the atmosphere was great. Thanks again for making good pizza in Preston County!

Before I moved there was a place called Franco’s Pizzeria. It was my family’s favorite and just last year, 2020, Old School Pizzeria opened up so we tried it then. It was delicious and tasted just like Franco’s. Yes it’s a little expensive, but it’s worth it for good quality pizza. It takes a little while for the pizza but the owner only has two ovens. The owner was also very kind to us every time we went.

So good! This will be our pizza place every time we come down from Ohio. Absolutely amazing, the chick was super cool and nice. Love it. Definitely recommend.