Michael's Pizzeria

I really enjoyed this pizza place. It is super small but the pizza itself is really good. This place is extremely traditional to Ohio style pizza. The restaurant was pretty clean and the staff was pretty nice. One negative side would be they do not have fountain sodas, so it is only canned sodas or bottles.

Best local pizza. Never gotten my order wrong. Salads are huge and topped perfectly.

The food is always good and I love the service. This is my favorite pizza place

I think they have the best pizza in licking county I drive from the north end of Newark to Jackson Town just for a pizza

Michael’s pizza in Jacksontown is great. Never disappoints. We have been eating here since the 80’s when it opened and haven’t found a better pizza anywhere else.

Best pizza I had since Hank Newman's in Gahanna back in the sixties and seventies I ate a whole large to myself and let me tell you like I said the best pizza I ate I'm going back sometime this week I get more and more on the weekend cuz I spend time with my brother at Fairfield Beach I'm getting more pizza that's for sure I'm going to check out the rest of the menu I'm telling you guys if you over by Buckeye Lake stop by there you will not regret it it was the best 40 bucks I spent myself love the pizza

Some of the best pizza I have had in ages! Best garlic bread I've had in my entire life! 100% worth the stop. The service was fantastic, and a wonderful experiance.

Went here to visit with my dad, he recommended to us their Italian Subs with Sausage, it's a whole game changer!!! I ordered it with Italian and mayo 😋 I most definitely will be back! Such nice people working!!! And the subs were awesome!!

We have been ordering Michael's pizza since my Godson worked there in 1989. The quality of the food and delivery service has not changed since then. Just ordered a white garlic pizza and garlic parmesean wings tonight and they were outstanding in flavor and delivery time. Just goes to prove when you have a solid family business and a great team of employees you can count on good quality food and services even through Covid and a crazy economy. Thank you.

Food is amazing. However must be a few new employees. Was disappointed in the huge bubbles in both pizzas. Very little cheese. I know I'm a cheese lover but even for my husband who likes it lighter then me was disappointed. But overall every other time we have come it has been great.

Best pizza I have ever had. Been ordering since 2011. Won't go anywhere else. Only minor downside is whe you ask for well done, rarely is it well done.

Great server,delicious pizza. Will definitely be back.

Delicious pizza, clean environment, great service! This was our first trip here and we were pleasantly surprised - the Jacksontown location on State route 40 looks small from the outside, but it's spacious with nice sit-down booth & table dining. We'll definitely be back!

I drive from the east side of Newark to pick up pizza from Michael's!! In my opinion, the best pizza in Licking County!! I was so happy when they opened one in Newark, but sadly they changed everything, including the name, so now I'm back to driving to Jacksontown when I want pizza. I recommend it to anyone who asks!!

The best pizza ever!!

Love ordering here. Food is always correct and we always get our sauces, 2-liter etc.. it’s those little things that set them apart. There’s also a regular driver who is super nice. Always a pleasure.

Always great food

Excellent! Stayed at lakewood Inn BW 5 mins down the road and stopped by based off of the other great reviews! Very good pizza! Got a XL Hawaiian pizza and a 2 liter plus free garlic bread for about 20 bucks can't beat that for great quality pizza!very satisfied and would deff return

They have the best sibs! A very good heavy Italian sub bun and a lot of meat and toppings, very good. I get the Italian sub with a sausage patty, my husband gets the pepperoni sub and really likes It.

Best $40 I've spent in a long time! Keep up the fantastic pizza!