Nancy's Pizza

This is authentic Chicago Deep Dish Pizza. Tastes exactly as it would if you ordered it in Chicago. Highly recommend. I grew up in the Chicago area and lived there for 40+ years, I'm qualified to say what I've said.

Always a pleasure.

Been coming here for years ever since A Better Pizza sadly departed from our fine city. Nancy’s really came through and filled that deep dish void.

The crust, sauce, and most importantly, the cheese, all work together in perfect harmony. Exactly how you would expect from a high quality Chicago style pizza pie.

Nancy's Pizza offers an absolutely delicious Chicago-style pizza experience that is sure to leave your taste buds singing with joy. The "A Lot A Meat" pizza is a carnivore's dream, with generous portions of savory meats piled high on a perfectly baked crust. The taste is unparalleled, with each bite bursting with flavor and satisfaction.

Beyond the incredible food, the ambience of Nancy's Pizza is simply beautiful, creating the perfect backdrop for a memorable dining experience. The warm and welcoming atmosphere exudes a family feel, making you feel right at home from the moment you step through the door.

Adding to the charm of this establishment is the friendly staff who go above and beyond to ensure that every customer feels valued and well taken care of. Their hospitality truly enhances the dining experience, leaving you eager to return for more of their mouthwatering pizzas.

Overall, Nancy's Pizza is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers craving a taste of perfection in every slice. With its great taste, beautiful ambience, and friendly staff, it's no wonder why this establishment has earned a reputation as a beloved local favorite.

Excellent stuffed deep dish, their sauce is addictive and the crust is always crispy even after a 15 min drive to pick it up. We ordered meatball as the topping since there's so much flavor other toppings can be hard to taste. When we crave deep dish, this is our go-to.

Very good Chicago style deep dish pizza. It took about 40 minutes to get but I called ahead. Hot fresh Alot of Meat Pizza was ready 5 mins before the person on the phone told me. Tomatoe sauce was well seasoned. We got extra cheese 🧀 😋. The price was a little high but it was a deep dish. It was a nice change from the normal pizza we eat. Will definitely come back when in O'FALLON. The customer service was great. I was in and out in 4 mins.

First timers!!👏🏼 👏🏼 👏🏼
10/10 recommend ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
We ordered a L- deep dish half pepperoni/ sausage, beef, bacon and Canadian bacon pizza 🍕
The kiddos ordered a L- cheese pizza 🍕
(The kiddos 😂 said the thin pizza crust was so amazing when you bite into it, tasted like a fresh baked cracker)
🤤 winner in my momma books!!!
Dessert we ordered the 3-canolis 🍒

Wow. This is excellent pizza and it’s worth the price, and that’s hard to find. The deep dish is fantastic great flavor and meat proportions. This time I also added a thin crust. It doesn’t disappoint either! My biggest complaint is it’s not closer to Wentzville!

Jason did a great job on our pizzas last night! Perfectly assembled and nice ratio of cheese, toppings and sauce. Both pizzas were delicious, we eat here a few times a month and what we had yesterday was the best order by far.

It was excellent. Chicago style is my favorite style, and this is as good as anything you can get around here. It is pricy, and it would be cool if you could sit down inside but overall I recommend it.

Hands down the best experience I've had in a long time.. was perfect from the time i called in to order to when i was dine eating it.. employee was incredibly helpful with explaining their different options and had great communication skills.. my food arrived via their own delivery driver (thankfully because I don't do those delivery service things) and tasted nothing short of perfection... thank you to everyone at your buisness it was definitely a great experience.. you're the only place I'll order from whenever I'm in the area in the future...

This is good Chicago deep dish, here, 5 hours from Chicago!
This is a good pizza, not a typical St Louis style either.
FYI, no dining here, just pick up.

Excellent deep dish Chicago pizza. The sauce and cheese is so good! Every bite reminds me of pizza in Chicago. Highly recommend this place. You won’t be disappointed.

The pizza was much better this time around...will definitely be going more often. Not a real fan of Chi style pizza, but the super thin saved the day!

We saw the owner as a patient at Americas Best and he brought us some pizza to try and it was DELICIOUS! Highly recommend! Will make this is a stop whenever I am in this area!

Good Chicago thin crust pizza. Brings back memories of my childhood.

We had a huge order for a birthday party. Everything was delivered just as ordered and was very delicious! Awesome owners! We will be back!

I have eaten from Nancy several times and have enjoyed the salads,Pasta and Pizza's the customer service is also great.Keep up the good work

My hubby grew up in Chicago, and he requested Nancy’s Chicago-style pizza for his birthday a few days ago. I am southern and do NOT enjoy Chicago-style pizza, so we ordered one Chicago and one thin. Hubby and son reported that they really enjoyed the bowl of pizza, as I call it, and I really enjoyed my pizza, which was loaded with cheese and pepperoni, it was delicious!

If you don’t like the Chicago-style pizza, try the thin rather than leaving a negative review. There’s a big difference between reviewing something you like that’s prepared poorly, and something you don’t like that’s prepared well. I think Chicago-style pizza is GROSS, but Nancy’s makes it well according to the Chicago pizza lovers in my home. Personally, I’ll stick to the thinner, less saucy pizzas. We will be back for more!

Awesome pizza! We got their signature stuffed pizza and it was amazing. Loaded with cheese and toppings. This place is real easy to miss, it’s kind of tucked back in the same plaza as potbelly sandwiches and right next to a phone store. Make it a point to seek them out. You’ll be glad you did. Note- the place is really small. Not meant for dinning in. You’ll need to carry it out... with 2 hands.

Great deep dish pizza, mozzarella cheese stretches forever. This is to-go only but great Chicago style.