Lylah's

Literally the best. Sandwiches were packed with flavor. Not pictured where the delicious cookies we devoured! Staff was very attentive, and very friendly.

Note: pictured sandwiches are half a sandwich as they were kind enough to give us separate servings when we split sandwiches

Love the decor, service and food! Clean everywhere. In the summer months we've sat outside which is relaxing. Everyone who works there are so friendly. Have I mentioned the sandwiches? Large and so tasty. I have to say I'm partial to the Tuna Schauby. You won't leave hungry.

We went to Lylah's (Suttons Bay) for breakfast. Oh my goodness our sandwiches (Eggscelenta and Morning Hambition) were DELICIOUS! The coffee was good, and the staff was lovely!

I have dined at Lylah's several times and always enjoyed my meal and the service. I just had them cater a party and I could not have been happier with the delicious and quality food, great presentation and excellent service. I highly recommend Lylah's and will hire them again!

Great tasting food. Staff very pleasant. Blueberry pancakes wonderful.

Incredible warm and inviting atmosphere. Creative and tasty menu. Breakfast sandwiches are awesome

Please stop coming here.

The more people who know about Lylah's, the less likely I am to get a table.

The food is incredible. The people running it are the best of the best. AND it's very reasonably priced. It's my favorite sandwich place in the whole area.

Also, do not buy the carrot cake cupcakes. Those are for me.

We got the Not Tuna Schauby and Not From Philly. Honestly, some of the most phenomenal sandwiches I’ve ever eaten in my life. We also tried the lemon cookie and the snickerdoodle with are baked in the café. So soft and so delicious. We will definitely be back. Highly recommend!

So great to have Lylah's now open in Suttons Bay! The food is top marks (check out the menu below), I have trouble selecting every time because everything is amazing! Megan at the counter is super friendly and welcoming, this place is perfect for grab-and-go or fast-casual eat-in dining!

Today's 5-star awesome food eaten and rrcommended: jalapeno mouth, twisted chicken, & chill chick!

Had the BLT and loved it.
Staff is very nice.

We stopped in today for the first time and got the horsin’ around and pulled pickled and pressed so that we could share with each other and try two. Both were so delicious and fresh. We will definitely be back.

This place blew my mind. I couldn't decide what I wanted it all looked so good....that's rare for me. The staff & service is beyond awesome....SO friendly...and man they are FAST. The rewards program, traffic flow, atmosphere, computer system....they are spot on. The prices are incredibly fair...the portions are generous!!! The the food..DELICIOUS!!! I can't think of a single thing I would complain about. Worth every bit of time and money.

Absolutely delicious. So cute inside and extremely friendly! We ate here three times on vacation. Highly recommend!

We were traveling through and came in at 1:55 not realizing they closed at 2pm. The staff was very welcoming and OMG our food was amazing!!! Will definitely make this our stop when traveling up this way!!

Best lunch sandwiches in SB. Great to pick up ahead for a picnic or to dine in. The people there are SO nice, must try for sure!

Stopped by for a quick bite. My twisted chicken sandwich was terrific and the pancakes for my kids were perfect. Friendly staff!

I had easily the best pulled pork sandwich from Lylah’s. The “Pork with a Punch” … if you’re in the area for lunch Lylah’s is an absolute MUST!

Loved this! We were nearby and needed lunch. I ordered online and everything was ready to go when I got there, no mistakes or missing items in our order. We had a lunch picnic and everyone was very pleased with their food!

Lylah's is owned and operated by my niece. That being said, it's a wonderful place for breakfast or lunch. They offer online ordering, curb service, take out, or dine in. Oh, and most importantly, the food is absolutely delicious. Most of the meats are cooked on site and the sauces are made from scratch as well.

Don't get me started on the baked goods. 🤤 One of my sister's does most of the baking: cookies, cheesecake and more.

Amazing pork sandwich, super nice people, comfortable clean environment, 5 stars!