The Godfather Brick Oven Pizzeria & Seafood Bar & Grill

Excellent meal and experience! The staff is attentive, friendly and personable. The food was delicious too! My milk allergy was accommodated so deliciously from the bread and olive board, appetizers, main and even dessert. The bar swiftly made an off menu cocktail so perfectly, I was able to also enjoy a glass of white wine with dinner and still enjoy amaretto on fresh berries with almond slivers without feeling like I over did it on the alcohol (no worries folks, I did not drive). Will definitely return.

The food was fantastic. Pizza, eggplant, seafood, and chicken dishes were all amazing. Every dish came out hot!
Our server, she was a little inattentive, and the restaurant was not all that busy when we were there, so that was inexcusable, but otherwise, we had a great experience. We will definitely be back!

Absolutely amazing! Phenomenal food. Raviolis, sauce-yum! Salads & brick over person piazzas Excellent service. Management went above and beyond! There were 8 of us and we all loved it !

Can’t wait to be back.

So many specialty pizzas by the slice and ample seating. The bar area has everything you need for a short lunch date or hang out in the evening for a few hours. Had the Buffalo Chicken Ceasar Salad (SaladZa- can we make that a real thing?) easily one of the best pizzas I have had with style and taste. Great location with shopping near by and right of rt10. Need good, really good pizza for the family or just you and don’t want to pay an arm and leg? Godfathers is the easy choice. We are with a part of 6: 6 slices of pizza &6 drinks for just over $40! Really can’t beat that. Can’t wait to come back.

Been here a few times. Has not disappointes yet. Lunch specials are well priced and quick. Had oysters here twice and both times thought they were fresh and delicious.

Ordered shrimp francaise for delivery and it was delicious. Jumbo shrimp and the sauce was perfect! We ordered garlic knots to complement the dish and it was a big hit. Definitely a good choice!

The people with great. And made up for every shortfall and had. I would definitely go back here. The nicest people in the world

Pizza is good, macaroni is good, service is pretty quick, atmosphere is pleasant, nice lounge/bar area with what appears to be a saltwater tropical fish tank upon entry. Not quite sure why some people do give this place poor reviews, although I do see possible reasons. A few issues here.
First, as we all know, it's not necessary to charge that ridiculous 3% additional fee for credit or debit card use. You know it annoys your customers and they always question you about it.
It's not necessary. Some of us customers spend alot of money here. Come on.
The next issue, and it's another legitimate issue, there are "Major Differences" in your prices between the online menus and what you actually charge at the counter. Why is that? According to your online menu and what you told me at the counter, the difference came to over 30 dollars that's a big difference.

Last year, the man at the counter said they still need to update the online menus but that's what you said several years ago?
He also said many customers still ask the same question.
Well, several years later, it's still mass confusion when ordering..
Still going to give the 5 stars for the fact that we simply like the place and the food.
As Honest as a review as it gets, right here..

We had our Annual Holiday Party on December 8,2023 Gioana and the whole staff where fabulous . WE ENJOYED EVERY MINUTE ! Food drinks dessert all were top notch! We used Chris @ Lavated for Photobooth & DJ dance floor was full up to the ending of our party! Florham Park Pediatrics highly recommends having your next event @ The Godfather !

Outstanding!!! And... They become like family... Gennaro and Chris are the greatest; they have helped me with menus for so many catering needs for many family celebrations and party events ... NEVER DISAPPOINTED!!

Place is very nice
Food is even better, baked clam are off the hook.
Service was very good !!!!
Won't be disappointed

So good . Keep ordering their food every week. Love all of them ,love the sea food ,so fresh . 😍💋😘

Really enjoy GF. Its a very local place. All the help is good and they do their best never to say No.

Fabulous all the time. Love their happy hour which, if memory serves correct, now starts at 3pm. Great bar food and discounted drinks.
Julie the bartender is awesome but all staff great.
Bar pie, clams oreganata, stuffed shrimp are my favorites.
A must go!

This pizza is good BIG FAR PRICES I wanted a slice of pizza, I got me a meat lover What's excellent BIG slice I'll be back

Our Stromboli s' were fantastic. They are the best we have had in NJ and NYC!

Busy and an atmosphere that makes you know you're in a great part of Jersey. Friendly and food awesome. Oysters shooters fantastic. We had a group of 10 and they are all just AWESOME.

One of my very favorite places!! Amazing friendly service. Great ambiance. Food is fast, hot and most importantly always delicious. When I walk in the door I am always treated like their best customer (but I see that they treat everyone that way). The owners and staff really care about their customers and want to make them happy. I find myself stopping here multiple times a week. Thanks to Jason, Chris, Jared, Jeremy, Vinny and all the staff for making customers always feel welcome. LOVE this place!!!

I usually don't post reviews but I had to tonight. I read a lot of bad reviews on the service and have to say the service was EXCELLENT. We were seated promptly, our drink and food orders were taken right away, and the food was excellent. I took someone's advice and had the lobster bisque. It was delicious with clumps of lobster. I also might add that it was a Saturday night and the restaurant was packed .

Friendly staff and very talented.... they can tell time without a clock 😉