Gseppe’s Pizzeria

I walked in thinking about what pizza to order. And the owner created me a wonderful pizza. Support the local business. I will be back soon. Thank you Mark for turning a rough to a happy yummy dinner . I cant wait to try the calzones next time

We've gone twice and both times have been fantastic. If you like a hand stretched style crust get any of the 12, 14, or 16 inch and you'll love it and if you like a thicker pan style crust the Sicilian will give you what you're looking for. Not only is it good fresh but it reheats perfectly and just reminds you of home made pizza. Fresh ingredients and its not a super greasy pizza like chain pizza places. Gonna keep going here and enjoying this place

This place is the best I’ve ever had! It’s Simply Amazing!!!! The Pizza crust is thin and crispy .Its perfect! Best pizza around by far! We get it once a week! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Easily the best pizza place in Vandalia. Amazing hand crafted pizzas, great customer service and fairly priced. If you want authentic Italian pizza, this is your place. The only thing I hate is how long I waited to try this place out! Definitely a hidden gem.

Picked up 2 pizzas and some cheese sticks for the family tonight on the way home from work. It's a little pricey I thought but well worth it. Both pizzas were amazing. Oh and my kids absolutely loved the cheese sticks. We will definitely go back. I highly recommend this place even if I'm not sure how to pronounce the name hahaha

My daughter and I get pizza from here every other weekend as it is the best in town. BUT THERE'S MORE!

Gseppe's also goes above and beyond for customers. We ordered pizza one Friday night but then got caught in a massive traffic jam on I70 because of jackknifed semi truck. We called to tell them we wouldn't be able to make it as the traffic was not moving.

NOT ONLY did they hold the pizza for us for 3 hours, they gave it to us on the house and promised to stay open till we got there. After such a terrible night, they made it a good one for my 8 year old and I.

We are Gseppe's Pizzeria fans for life now. Oh and the the pizza is amazing.

I was driving for work and stopped by as I was craving pizza. Simple small store but clearly visible plenty love behind the work. Ended up overeating as my tastebuds refused to stop. It was well worth it. I definitely will go back!

We were passing through this little town from Providence RI to Oklahoma City. The day was very long for us, 12 hours I think and we arrived at our hotel around 8.

Everything else was closed except Gseppe's. We placed an order and were told it would be about an hour. That was going to be past closing time.

I arrived at about 8:45 to this very small pizzeria in downtown Vandalia. When I arrived I was just beat to nothing but I believe it was the owner who greeted me with a smile. I asked if they had any breadsticks because the wife (also brain dead at this point forgot).

They didn't have any but had this great cheese, ham and tomato appetizer ready. I said great I'll take it.

I handed over my card be the owner said sorry we can only take cash or credit today.

I only had $25 on me, but the owner said don't sweat it. He asked me about my travels while another staff member got everything ready.

The owner was incredibly great to deal with after a long difficult day. I asked for a couple forks for the salads but they didn't have any on hand so they gave me to metal forks and said keep them.

I was so very grateful to the Gseppe's Pizzeria I had to share a simple but great encounter after a brutally long day.

Thank you Gseppe's!!!!!

Awesome Sicilian Carnivore pizza and some Gseppes’ stix. What a great hidden gem. Don’t expect your order in 15 minutes just call it in ahead. Well worth it.

I Would Drive 400 mile's for a Gseppe's Pizza we are traveling through I didn't feel like cooking so I said hey Google what's the best pizza place around and Gseppe's Pizzeria came up first I read every review well the pizza was FANTASTIC and the we got a regular size salad with their HOMEMADE DRESSING it's enough for 2 people.
I do have a suggestion Gseppe you need to get a sign outside especially for people who are traveling.
It's a white building on the corner so if you want a great ITALIAN PIZZA right here is the place to go! 🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕

American-Sicilian pizza at its best! Gseppe sources top quality ingredients for the pizzas, as well as everything else that is made there. The best food of its type within a hundred mile radius.

Excellent food- if you want some real Italian pizza and cuisine that is different from the rest of your day to day pizza you have to try them out.
There number is incorrect on google though. The right number is 283-7070

Love the geseppis sticks and the pizza is soooooo good! Definitely recommend from my house hold!

Wish for a more detailed schedule of when it will and wont be open. But some of the best pizza and experience ive had.

Just moved from the south side of Chicago. Family told me to try Gseppe's. Great whole made dough and delicious toppings.

Great pizza great service great price my personal favorite best in town

Great service and the best pizza, bread sticks in Vandalia at a very reasonable price!!!

Fantastic pizza and the redneck sticks are great! Glad to see this place back open!

Great pizza at a great price! The ham and cheese sticks are to die for!

The pizza is great and my kids ask for it all the time.