Pizza Cottage

Excellent experience, the food portions were above and beyond to include value. Very good sandwiches as well as we loved the sauce in our meatball ravioli dish. Our server Mikaela was top notch, super friendly and helpful in her suggestions of menu items. We will certainly return - thank you

Met friends there a couple weeks ago. Great service very friendly, food was really really good. We thought comfortable enough to sit there for an hour or two and chit chat. I have only one suggestion, how about some pesto sauce? My husband and I love pesto, in fact that's his favorite way for pizza.
But overall everything was wonderful!

Our pizza was excellent for sure. Our waitress was very friendly and sweet. She went out of her way to take care of us. Her name was Michale. Top notch and we will travel two hours again to eat there

Pizza Cottage is a Central Ohio institution. They serve top quality and delicious pizza every single time. The atmosphere is always low key, relaxed, and the service is always quick and friendly. They don’t skimp on toppings, and we never have to worry about leaving there any other way but stuffed to the gills! Our only “complaint” is that delivery would be a welcomed option. However, nothing beats fresh-out-of-the-oven pizza right when it’s made. Love this place!

We reserved the party room for 18 guests and everyone had a great time. Staff was on point from accommodations to service. Food was great as always.

Big 13th birthday party went off without a hitch due to super amazing helpful staff can't say enough about that really food was excellent fast service always helpful for any ask we had. Couldn't believe we got everyone in there and still had elbow room. Huge thank you to all involved

Always a good experience here! I love their steak sub and their salads - always delicious!

I love this pizza joint! The crust is thin and crispy and the cheese is extra stringy! The restaurant itself is clean and open. They have an area set aside for the bar. The prices are good. The bread sticks are a little think for me, but the marinara sauce was awesome!

Great pizza, fresh salads. They help people with employment. Patronage this local all goodness!!!!!

The pizza was amazing, had the BLT, loaded baked potato, and whole hog pizza. I was pleasantly surprised with the loaded baked potato pizza, not something you'd expect but was great. Overall, they all were great, the service was great, and they overloaded one waitress, so one of my requests got put on the back burner. Nothing against the waitress she was great.

Love this place, always stop on our way to perry state forest to ride, or on the way back. Love the Thai pizza. I don't even like pizza and I always look forward to this one with the Thai chili sauce.
My friends that eat other pizza always say theirs are awesome! Love the thin crust. They also have cauliflower crust options. Their fried foods are always cooked exactly how they should be. We just got the mozzarella triangles and jalapeno poppers and they did not disappoint. Their dipping marinara is good too!

Great food Great staff Keely was our server she was great Newark Ohio location

Always delicious pizza & friendly staff, great family spot

Delicious as always and the beer on tap ice cold!

Great place to eat! We always get pizza because it is so good we never have gotten to the rest of the menu to try anything else.

Ordered two BLT pizzas One with cauliflower crust and one regular. They were both perfect!! Staff was friendly and they got the food done early.

Good food. Poor service. Hot, air wasn't working, daughter had to go to front desk and order our food our waitress never came. The manager got us our pop.a different waitress brought us our food,

We picked up pizza here to take it to a family get together and the pizza was scarfed down. It was great pizza!

We had the best server here the other night! Decent food and decent atmosphere. We will revisit for sure.

Had a BLT it was perfect I’ve never had a bad one there