HMC

JC Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant in Fire Island National Seashore

Updated: March 01, 2024 09:23 AM

JC Pizzeria is located in Fire Island National Seashore (Nature preserve in Suffolk County, New York), United States. It's address is 55 Surrey Cir, Shirley, NY 11967.

55 Surrey Cir, Shirley, NY 11967

Q4XM+3Q Shirley, New York

(631) 772-4394

slicelife.com

jcpizzeria.com

Check Time Table for JC Pizzeria


Monday11 AM to 10 PM
Tuesday11 AM to 10 PM
Wednesday11 AM to 10 PM
Thursday11 AM to 10 PM
Friday11 AM to 10 PM
Saturday11 AM to 10 PM
Sunday11 AM to 10 PM

Questions & Answers


Where is JC Pizzeria?

JC Pizzeria is located at: 55 Surrey Cir, Shirley, NY 11967.

What is the phone number of JC Pizzeria?

You can try to calling this number: (631) 772-4394

What are the coordinates of JC Pizzeria?

Coordinates: 40.7976305, -72.8655558

JC Pizzeria Reviews

Frank R
2021-09-23 23:26:21 GMT

Every time we order from here it’s amazing. The MOST consistently AMAZING pizza place around here. I usually get the chicken all’s vodka pizza and it’s incredible. Tonight I got chicken parm with vodka sauce and it was incredible.

Donna Mellow
2023-07-11 13:18:16 GMT

The food here is excellent! It's so hard to find a good pizza place that stays consistently good. JC's has been great every time we order, no matter what we order. I have never been disappointed. The people here are really nice too.

Suzi M
2021-10-29 20:16:01 GMT

Catered from here for our Halloween party! The food was all amazing! Food was delivered exactly at the time we requested. They gave us garlic knots and Italian bread for free. Everyone loved the food! We will definitely order from
Here again!

amanda eagleston
2021-09-05 13:00:44 GMT

Absolutely Delicious! Always Fresh and Made to order. We love there White Pizza and Wings! Never had a bad meal! There prices are great too!

Robert M
2023-08-16 13:53:17 GMT

JC is quality pizza place. Many good specials all week. Buy one pizza get one free Tuesdays. 👍🍕

Georgiana Defeo
2021-02-20 23:20:54 GMT

This quaint little gem provides restaurant quality service at pizza parlor prices. If you are wondering where to get genuine New York style pizza look no further. This restaurant provides everything you might wish to fill your gourmand loving hearts fill of Italian delights at a very reasonable price.

Mommy5dearest
2023-07-18 19:54:07 GMT

Pizza was good and delicious. Delivery was great and fast. Would definitely recommend.

joe k
2021-06-23 17:25:36 GMT

I think this is the best pizza I had in the Shirley/mastic/mastic beach area. The pizza taste so good not salty not doughy just a bit to much oil but still it was the best pizza.they have lunch special too just call them and ask them but thank you guys at Buona fortuna pizza.

C Garcia
2020-11-28 00:28:52 GMT

Chicken wings were great! Penna ala vodka was delicious 👉🏻we order catering for my husband birthday and everything was on point! 💕new place , new taste! Very professional staff.

Emmanuel Marte
2021-03-24 15:58:24 GMT

chicken parm slice is delicious. the sauce has a unique sweet/tangy flavor which I like and the bread is also well made-thin slice and crunchy crust. made my stomach happy

David Chivelly
2023-01-19 01:38:21 GMT

A very nice restaurant and service. The food is absolutely amazing. I surprised them all the time with my request for special orders. Very friendly.

Evan Purcell
2020-12-17 00:11:20 GMT

First Time there had 1 spinach slice and reg slice pizza was delicious , great crust , by far the best pizza in the Shirley , mastic , manorville area , the staff was friendly , would definitely recommend ,this will be my new go to pizza spot

Eric Rubinstein
2022-03-29 22:25:47 GMT

Mario and his staff are very professional and family oriented. Fresh food and above average amounts served every time. I recommend this place to all

Louis Esposito
2022-11-10 23:11:06 GMT

Recently started going here and really love there pizza and hero’s. Great prices and great food

Tina Scorse
2021-05-02 11:51:51 GMT

Delicious food and the service is great. We always love everything when we go here. Their meat stuffed pizza is the best!!!

Victoria windley
2021-10-26 21:51:03 GMT

BEST PIZZA I'VE EVER HAD. I HAVE BEEN EXPERIENCING THIS AMAZING SLICE OF HEAVEN SINCE THEY WERE LOCATED ON 101 IN EAST PATCHOGUE, BUT SINCE IVE MOVED.... I THANK THE LORD THAT THEY ARE LOCATED IN MY NEW HOMETOWN. ON PIZZA NIGHT MY FAMILY KNOWS DONT ASK ME WHAT I WANT BECAUSE THEY KNOW WHAT IM GOING TO SAY. MARIO IS AWESOME IN THE BACK AND I LOVE SEEING THAT FAMILY LOVE AND FRIENDLY WELCOMING WHEN WE COME IN. ALWAYS WELCOMING AND HAPPY TO KNOW THAT OTHER MEMBERS OF MY FAMILY COME IN FOR THE FOOD AS WELL. YOU GUYS ARE AWESOME. I WILL BE THERE SOON TO GET A MEATBALL AND SAUSAGE PIE ...... THAT I EAT KIND OF ALL BY MYSELF, ALWAYS LOVE. VICTORIA CARTER

Kevin rochford
2020-12-16 22:10:39 GMT

1st time trying this place and Pizza was really good, everybody in the family enjoyed it! We will Definitely order from Them again

Jake New York
2023-03-04 18:48:09 GMT

The Chicken parm pizza has really nice flavor and the bottom of the pizza has a perfect crisp to it .

Stephanie Brewer
2022-01-24 20:22:54 GMT

So refreshing to receive the food I ordered HOW I ordered it!! Nothing was missing or prepared incorrectly! Thank you, thank you!! Great customer service and the food is fresh 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

John Corbett
2022-02-27 20:11:57 GMT

This place is unbelievable, the service is fantastic, the portions are huge, and the food is great. The real shocker is that the prices are so low. This place is an absolute home run

Write a review of JC Pizzeria


JC Pizzeria Directions
About Fire Island National Seashore
Nature preserve in Suffolk County, New York

Fire Island National Seashore is a United States National Seashore that protects a 26-mile section of Fire Island, an approximately 30-mile long and 0.5-mile wide barrier island separated from Long Island by the Great South Bay. source

Top Rated Addresses in Fire Island National Seashore

Addresses Near Fire Island National Seashore