HMC

Your Bagel Cafe

Bagel shop in Fire Island National Seashore

Updated: March 13, 2024 08:19 PM

Your Bagel Cafe is located in Fire Island National Seashore (Nature preserve in Suffolk County, New York), United States. It's address is 451 Glen Dr, Shirley, NY 11967.

451 Glen Dr, Shirley, NY 11967

R4P7+MQ Shirley, New York

(631) 448-8899

places.singleplatform.com

your-bagel-cafe.business.site

Check Time Table for Your Bagel Cafe


Monday5 AM to 3 PM
Tuesday5 AM to 3 PM
Wednesday5 AM to 3 PM
Thursday5 AM to 3 PM
Friday5 AM to 3 PM
Saturday5 AM to 3 PM
Sunday5 AM to 3 PM

Questions & Answers


Where is Your Bagel Cafe?

Your Bagel Cafe is located at: 451 Glen Dr, Shirley, NY 11967.

What is the phone number of Your Bagel Cafe?

You can try to calling this number: (631) 448-8899

What are the coordinates of Your Bagel Cafe?

Coordinates: 40.8366978, -72.8856086

Your Bagel Cafe Reviews

Laura Lambert
2024-03-02 17:48:12 GMT

Us New Yorkers know good bagels ! This establishment is ON POINT ! The bagels are so fresh and soft . Try the chicken salad on everything bagel ! It’s Like my grandma made it back in the day . Friendly staff …. Let’s put it this way . I live in Manorville 4.7 miles away from said establishment. . I have a bagel store literally 3/4 mile down the road and I’ll travel the 4.7 to get QUALITY AND CONSISTENCY. I wish them loooooong term s success and are around FOR VERY LONG TIME! It’s definitely not easy to find establishments that you know what you’re going to receive each time. In my picture you’ll notice some chopped tomatoes that’s because I add them.

N R
2022-11-01 18:25:19 GMT

One of the best bagels in the area! The staff are friendly despite being so busy. They were really busy yet they let me edit my order couple of times and my order was big so really happy with their service and their bagels are so good and freshly made. I ordered the bacon egg and cheese and asked for extra bacon with everything bagel ofcorse and they made it perfect! Definitely will return!

Rocco
2024-01-30 12:52:40 GMT

Great addition to the area. Staff are very friendly & attentive. Bagels are awesome & give generous about of food.

Samantha Wright
2023-09-16 01:42:32 GMT

I teach in the area so I normally call right before the light on William Floyd to turn into the bagel place & it’s always ready and perfect when I pull in! The bagels are good, egg & cheese is good so are the cream cheeses.

Robert Grant
2023-07-12 02:03:01 GMT

Consistently delivering exceptional sandwiches, this place has never disappointed. Their coffee is top-notch and complements the delightful flavors of their sandwiches perfectly. Without a doubt, it's the premier bagel deli in all of Suffolk County, guaranteeing a memorable and satisfying dining experience.

greg wolkoff
2023-08-18 14:56:48 GMT

Amazing service, food is incredible! Owners friendly they do my catering. Just can’t beat it! I highly recommend catering all parties. Even to go in for a quick sandwich!!!

El Gibson
2023-11-14 21:40:40 GMT

Everything Bagel with veggie cream cheese ....😍 how a cinnamon raisin toasted with cream cheese and crispy bacon ......yummy bacon (Homer's voice)

Daniel Zelaya
2023-10-04 13:28:03 GMT

I love how the make the pancakes 👌🏼👌🏼10/10

KingRex MMA
2023-01-07 18:57:37 GMT

Best deli/bagel store , amazing and friendly staff. Always a smile and happy to help. Food is always fresh and well prepared. Love this deli. I travel from the town over cause this one is way better than the bagel store/deli by me.

AB Negative
2022-02-25 01:25:06 GMT

I work in the area and I take my bagel/deli spots seriously. After trying a lot of different locations in the area this location by far has been the best in cleanliness, consistency, variety and price. Service is fast, Yes there is a coffee station, food is fresh and flavorful. The negative reviews made me laugh at how people like this survive outside of their reality.

Silas Owens
2023-12-12 11:10:28 GMT

Food is good, a little Skimpy on the bacon for a BLT.

Daniel
2021-10-03 00:11:07 GMT

This is my new favorite bagel place. Excellent food (not just bagels), friendly service, reasonable prices. Very bright and clean for a great early morning pick-me-up! Lots of staff ensures a fast/efficient stop on your way to work and the coffee is spot-on! Highly recommend!

Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
2022-06-07 01:27:38 GMT

This place is better than you thought. It's a local store that popped up a couple years ago. Right near the expressway. They have great service and always with a smile. Their bagels are crispy and light with a good bite to them. Prices are reasonable. Nice storefront inside as well. Go see them. They have a great BECSPK!

Went back again, love their bagel breakfast sandwiches. Always service with a smile too!

claudia
2022-10-08 10:51:02 GMT

BEST BAGEL AROUND!
and I'm not the only one who thinks so! It felt like the entire town was there getting bagels or breakfast at 7am the place was packed! The staff behind the counter was great and managing the crowd!!!

Rachel Tomasky
2022-05-27 14:07:52 GMT

We love this bagel store. They weren't open when we first bought our home right down the road. We had to go down William Floyd. So happy they are here now. Great bagels and egg sandwiches.

Jonathan B
2019-07-08 17:10:17 GMT

Just had a bagel here. Super soft. Super fresh. Smiles with all the staff. I will be back to enjoy another great experience. It’s nice to have a good bagel spot so close to home. Keep up the great work. And please get us some low fat cream cheeses please. So happy to have a bagel shop here.

Robert Lukes
2022-09-18 00:21:27 GMT

Great bagels! Really busy place buy they move really fast. Line ask to the door and I was out in less than 10 mins. Got a lox bagel which was great, no capers though.

Catherine DiGristina
2022-03-10 20:27:44 GMT

The best bagel i ever had! The everything bagel is so flavorful! The place is spotlessly clean. Great service and staff! Would definitely recommend this place. This is by far my new favorite bagel place! :)

Victor Cruz
2022-11-16 19:50:46 GMT

Long Island at its best. Good people and good food.
We went there every morning before sunrise, they open at 5. Talking with real long Island ers, locals, hard working people.
Coffee, bagels and bialys, along with fresh oj.
Great way to start the day!

Michael Martin
2023-07-22 21:18:42 GMT

Good selection, quick service even being busy. And bagels were good.

Write a review of Your Bagel Cafe


Your Bagel Cafe Directions
About Fire Island National Seashore
Nature preserve in Suffolk County, New York

Fire Island National Seashore is a United States National Seashore that protects a 26-mile section of Fire Island, an approximately 30-mile long and 0.5-mile wide barrier island separated from Long Island by the Great South Bay. source

Top Rated Addresses in Fire Island National Seashore