Uncle Joe's Pizza

Been coming here since the late 80s. We have had food catered here and always the food is top notch.
Hard to find a pizzeria that executes great pizza and Italian entrees and appetizers.

On my recent family visit to the island, I always try to make here for at least a few slices.

I'm a Sicilian pizza purist, just the basics for me and their Sicilian is in my top 10 on the island and I've eaten at more pizzerias than I should divulge . The crust is cooked perfectly, crispy but not overdone. More than ample amount of creamy cheese and my favorite part is the sauce.
The sauce is in a league of its own, perfect balance of acidity and sweetness, it has a distinctive taste that is hard to duplicate. If they sold fried sauceballs, I'd fly up from Tampa, just for that.

If all these accolades weren't enough, the people here are nothing short of amazing. Warm, friendly and inviting, people you look forward to seeing. Place has a community vibe like it's Bay Ridge not middle country rd in Lake Grove.

Looking forward to my next trip back to the island and next time, stopping in lunch and trying one of thier delicious daily specials.

New spot to come to. Excellent sauce, undercarriage is perfect. Fidel will make you feel welcome customer service is amazing. I go all over L.I for best pizza and this is quickly climbing the ranks! Thanks Fidel and team!

-Marco

We came for dinner, party of 7, everything was delicious and reasonably priced. Family owned and operated. Wonderful atmosphere & holiday decorated. We sat in the large back room of the restaurant, could easily host an intimate bridal/baby shower. Garlic knots, calamari, mozzarella sticks, eggplant parm, chicken franchise, cannolis, everything is very good, portion sizes are huge, service is great. Highly recommend!

They gave me a knife and fork, which I did not use. The crust held up despite the heavy toppings. Crispy and tasty from Uncle Joe's in Lake Grove, NY

Always consistent!

Excellent food, crew is great, and they have a great menu, and great variety of slices to choose from.. come check them out! Jim w/ Cheez Boss

This is a wonderful family owned Italian restaurant. Mom, Dad, Son and Daughter are always smiling when you walk in...
Probably the most genuinely nice people you can meet...
The food is excellent, plentiful and fresh...
The inventive pizzas are incredible...
If you're in the area try it...
Love this place...

THE BEST vegetable panini I’ve ever had in my life. Coming from someone who is allergic to dairy & can’t eat meat, I really appreciate their consideration and attention to detail, because I never get sick when I eat here. 10 out of 10 recommend. My boyfriend eats all of the non-vegan foods and loves everything he tries as well!

My favorite place to eat and feel like home. The staff is wonderful and the food it always great. I highly recommend coming here for a quick slice or a nice hot meal.

We live in Centereach and whenever we are craving pizza we always go to Uncle Joe's. Their pasta and specialty slices are great and we love the meatballs and broccoli rolls. I would definitely recommend

Food is always excellent! The tiramisu is the best I’ve ever had. Food aside the staff is excellent, they always go above and beyond, they bring my food out to my car because I have small children, they are always so friendly, so kind, they treat you like family. I highly recommend uncle joes!

Food was wonderful. Pasta night is the best deal for italian pasta. Bread was amazing. Coffee was also great which came with my meal and also dessert amazing. Staff was super polite very attentive. Water was filled 3 times which is awsome and i felt like i dined 5 star. Plenty of room 16 full tables. Super classy and great prices that cant be matched .

Family run pizzeria forever. The family is so nice and helpful. The food is some of the best I’ve ever tasted. They catered my daughters sweet 16 years ago and it was perfect. Stop by for a slice or sit down and be treated like royalty. Beautiful people and tasty food, what more could you ask for.

Customer bought us some pizza while on a job. Awesome pizza ! Very very good. Perfect and tasted even better because I was starving. Thank you.

Love this hidden gem.. always stop in when nearby and never disappointed!! Very nice owner and staff, and a great menu for a reasonably priced delicious meal!!

We absolutely love Uncle Joes! 💕 My kids beg to come here and have renamed certain foods that they adore. Worth every bite!!

I’ve recently been ordering pizza from here for my weekly meetings at work and it’s always fresh and on point. So Tuesday night, my family and I went there to try dinner. They were extremely accommodating, the food fresh and delicious, and the waitress was unbelievably pleasant. We haven’t received service like that in quite some time. While we were there I ordered catering for last night (Thursday 8/3/23). I was having 40 people at the beach because it was one year since my father passed away and I wanted to celebrate him. I was already anxious and just wanted the food to be checked off my list. Fidel was awesome! He was genuinely very helpful and the food was outstanding. All of my family was so impressed and I was grateful for Fidel and everyone at uncle Joes for helping me with this special occasion. Go there for dinner and I promise you too will find your new spot!!

We had my son's first birthday party here. The food was great, the staff were friendly and accomodating and let me use my own decorations. I would definitely use them again

Had a family gathering there recently. Bertha was a dream to work with. Everyone was going on and on about the food. The gnocci! The mussels! The parmigiana! You just can't get a bad meal. Be aware it's a great pizza parlor in the front but don't miss out on the wonderful Italian restaurant in the back as well! 10/10 will return.

Uncle Joe's is really good. They make a good pizza and the service is great very quick very friendly

Uncle Joe's has the best food and pizza around ,,,you live in lake grove ,stony brook or Centereach you gotta switch to uncle Joe I promise you it won't disappoint...