Isabella's Pizza

I kept going for pizza alone and most recently started trying the various pasta dishes. There are so many other places in the surrounding area that are well known with a lot more space for indoor dining. I would hands down choose Isabella's for the amount of food you receive and the taste (small space to dine in, but we do take out). My son is a bit of an Italian food addict and we were trying different places to keep it interesting. I just can't believe how good the food is and the price at Isabella's. Why go out of my way to try other places when I have found our favorite? To be continued with more pics as I make my way through the menu....today we got 2 regular, 1 buffalo, chicken Florentine with spinach and kids chicken parm with spaghetti. The bread that comes with the pasta dishes is amazing! There is no need for garlic knots I'd you get this bread.

Not only the best pizza but their soups and burgers are delicious! 🤤
Food always fresh too.

This Pizza place is great! Prices are fantastic and the food is delicious. I come here often for lunch and am always satisfied. The environment is cute and quaint for a bite. Highly recommend to anyone!

I have had Isabella’s pizza and hero’s before but never a pasta dinner. Now I know why. I did not enjoy it at all. I ordered lasagne with chicken parmagian and meatballs. The lasagne was mostly chicken, hardly any lasagne. The meat balls were good. I was’nt to crazy about the sauce. I will still get pizza from there but not a dinner.

We have lived in Oakdale for 6+ years and have always complained that the only thing we didn't like was the lack of good pizza/italian takeout! We finally expanded our search a little bit and luckily found this place. I am really picky about the pizza - if you're going to splurge, it better be worth it! And this pizza is so worth it. Every topping you could want & all the basics were perfect.

Everything was phenomenal, fresh, delivered really fast, priced great, and service was amazing (called to check on custom request via online app to make sure they understood 100% correctly - we all know this is not always the case!). Cannot recommend highly enough. Give them a try - you will be so happy.

My kids are obsessed with their chicken caesar salad pizza. Its very delicious. Their chicken parm rolls are really good too!

Grandma slice was amazing. The sauce is pretty much perfect. Lil sweet, lil tangy . The crust is super delic! Check em out if you're in the area.

First time trying them. Everything was amazing. One of the best buffalo chicken rolls I've had. Wife got a insalata caprese salad which she loved. meatball Parm hero fantastic. Also got a personal specialty pie which was great. No complaints. (that was bbq chicken). Will get again.

One of the best pizza on Long Island. I’m lactose but their cheese pizza does not make my stomach upset.

Isabella's Pizza is a must in the Islip area. Great spot next to a pub. Love every slice, garlic knots and fried oreos. Excellent customer service.

Great pizza. Best I've had in the area.

I got the Buffalo chicken slice and my wife got the taco salad slice. Both were very good.

Some of the best Pizza in the area! Ownership truly cares about each customer and takes the time to make sure everyone is happy! We do catering a lot from them...Shrimp Oreganta is some of the best if not the best I've ever had.

For a small pizza place, the food is AMAZING!!! Whether it is pizza or dinners, everything is freshly made and tastes delicious! Portions of dinners are huge! Isabella’s never disappoints. You must try it!!!

We tried two grandma slices - portions are generous and the pizza was fantastic. They have a huge selection of specialty slices with sesame seeds in the crust. I'm definitely trying one of the specialty slices next time

Been a customer for 5+ yrs. Great pizza, one of the few pizzerias around with sesame seeded crust 👌🏾 Recently renovated and pleasant staff

Best pizza on long island hands down, get grandma or grandma vodka. Owner is nicest guy give them a shot next meal you wont be disappointed.

Both food price quality and quantity is very good it's one of those places that's hold that standard for quite a while the fires are great it's the first place I want a pizza place they actually made a Greek salad and they put the grape leaves in it and it beat most prices by $3 or better boss works it and takes pride in his food the delivery is bouncing in and out of there like crazy it look like the orders are very timely though I have not have it delivered. I live too far away but I definitely go out of my way to get the food it's well worth a drive it sets the standard worth the trip and the seafood calamari pie is off the hook he used to have it on Fridays but prices got to be expensive to make it but if you made it you definitely get what you pay for I miss those Friday nights when he made it it comes back in the summer I'll be knocking on the door often

Great pizza been coming here for years

Some of the best specialty slices I've had. I like the sesame crust too. Good food at a reasonable price. molto bene