Gaetano's Restaurant

We started out looking for a place we had never been before. We stoped at one restaurant and they had no walk ins and seen Gaetano’s. We decided to stop in and yes, we were able to get seated. I am so glad we ended up here. Our server was an older woman with short hair. She was great, very attentive and had a great sense of humor! For starters we had the Italian wedding soup, salad, bread and stuffed Italian peppers. For our meals we had chicken Parmigiana, and linguine and white clam sauce. Everything we ate was delicious, not to mention the prices are very reasonable!! I would definitely recommend!!

Quiet, simple, sit down and take out Italian restaurant. Good menu choices...has a good 3 cheese stuffed shell with big meatball and marinara on special for lunch with soup or salad. Stuffed shrimp is excellent. Tasty Italian wedding soup. Hot fresh bread for the table. Fast service, friendly. Decent wine selection. We look forward to our next visit!

Great food and service! We live nearby but had never been and were in the mood for Italian. The sauce was excellent. We will definitely come again. Great if you like a smaller family feel restaurant. Awesome place for local dinners out as an alternative to going downtown or to Little Italy.

A great little place to get homemade Italian food. Service staff is always very friendly and helpful. We love going there for dinner. We usually get the specials. Fresh baked Italian bread. We even get a loaf to take home. Great little spot. I would highly recommend

Excellent. We had our daughters college graduation party there and every thing was excellent. The waitresses were ready for us. The food came out very quickly. The food was excellent. The lasagna was delicious as well as the veal parmigiana. Alfredo per one family member was the best they ever had and the kids loved the pizza. The meatball sub was humongous. There were 14 of us plus the one year old.

The blush sauce was delicious! Happy they were knowledgeable and accommodating for gluten free needs :)

This place has excellent Italian food! They are well known for their bread. YUM! You can order bread to take home also, already baked! Service is wonderful. We were there 4/16/23, a party of 50, with 3 waitresses, and they all did an excellent job! Although you can walk in without a reservation, it's better to have one. I highly recommend this restaurant. If you love Italian food, you won't regret it.

Love it been here many times food is great and a great potion and the only thing better than the food is the service

We have been enjoying meals here for over 15 years. First, in Mayfield Hts. and now in Willoughby Hills. We have NEVER had a complaint about any of our meals. The servers, Lori and Janet are wonderful, caring and funny ladies who are great at what they do! I would definitely suggest trying Gaetano's
for a great meal and fun time!

Food were awesome. Italian tomato salad you don't find in much Italian restaurants. Pizza is great. I have shrimp diavlo and really good. Shrimp cooked perfectly to crunch and pasta is al dente. Great service and friendly staff. Will be back for more. Hidden gem.

We came in with a very large party reservation and the staff were prepared for us! Food and service were awesome! Reasonable prices, good wine, the lasagna looked amazing! I would definitely eat here again if I was a local.

The stuffed shells and side of meatballs were delicious. Their bread is fantastic!

The 1st time we came here it was amazing we came back a few weeks later and our server remembered what kind of wine I had. This is the best place in town and the service is always amazing and food is amazing and you get a large portion of food. Oh and the bread is amazing too.if you have not been here this is a place to try.

We were a little hesitant to try this place, but are so glad we did! From the moment we walked in, it felt like we were in an old friends house. The staff seemed to know several of the diners personally, and everyone was very friendly. Service was amazing, we never had an empty glass and our waitress was very attentive and nice.
The dining room is very clean and well maintained.
The food was very good. We had the stuffed shrimp, chicken francase and veal parmesan. Portions are hearty, and the pasta seemed to be homemade( it was absolutely delicious).
For desert we took home the chocolate moose and the tiramisu... and promptly inhaled them an hour later.
Thank you for the great experience!

Great food and the service was very good.

The food was delicious and the servers make you feel like family.

Great lasagna and tiramisu. The portion of lasagna was huge, and so flavorful. Price was a deal for the food we got.

Great food, highly recommend the meatballs, just be ready to take them home. They are big, but not dry in the center.

Chicken Marsala was great my wife send the best she has had in a long time.
I had the Pasta Primavera.that my go to when I come here to enjoy.
It's pasta in Chicken Broth packed with a lot love. I'm telling you don't be afraid to try. It is amazing.
I'm glad they opened the dinning room.
It's a little wait for the dining room. But worth the wait..
Enjoy and Mangia

My favorite place for Italian food, great service great food fantastic