Uncle Matty's Eatery

Had a really nice "between funeral viewings" dinner here. Staff was very accommodating for a sudden party of 10. Service was good, menu was varied. Everything got to the table hot and reasonably quickly. Their homemade chips were really good. My BBQ was very flavorful, nice and moist without dripping sauce. Crab dips were good and decent size.

A really nice small local eatery, try them out!!

Bridget is the best! Great customer service, always with a smile. :D The Blood Orange beer in the can is a lot like Blue Moon but better, try it! I love the homemade chips that come with the sandwiches and dogs. Lots of options on the menu to keep you coming back. The Matty Melt is one of our favorites, but we order double meat because it is often not enough.

Parmesan crusted scallops in a bacon-vodka cream sauce. Get here today- this special is not going to last - fantastic - love this place!

I love a good steak sub and this one was perfect in every way. They have their sub rolls shipped in twice weekly and the meat is thick shaved ribeye that was seasoned perfectly. The feta fries were delicious and the home made garlic salad dressing on my salad couldn't have been better. I can't believe I've driven by this place countless times and had no idea! I also wanted to note that the waitress Bridget was right out of a Lifetime movie set in a restaurant in small town America - pleasant, friendly, and welcoming.

Our lunch was delicious, and the portions were large. Our server was very friendly and did a great job. The dining room and bathrooms were clean. I'd definitely recommend this place!

My husband and I went there on Friday, October 13, 2023. We had a wonderful experience. The service was excellent and the people were very friendly. I had the crab soup, and it was devine. Then I had the 5oz cheeseburger. This burger should be against the law to have because it was so delicious. I talked about all night to my friends. The burger is an award winning burger, and I didn't know that until I had already eaten half. The homemade chip is a must try. My husband's Italian hot dog was superb. I will be forever chasing the taste of that burger.

Nice little bar and restaurant with great service and food. Boom boom shrimp yummy with just enough heat. The spinach salad was outstanding. And for a small place, they have an impressive beer list.

A very pleasing find in New Windsor - we drive out into the scenic countryside just to enjoy lunch at this homey family-friendly restaurant (they do serve wine & beer and have a bar area). Can't go wrong - never an inferior dish. The salads are fresh, sammies and entrees tasty. Love the wings, crab dip, gator bites, quesadilla, and incredible "boom boom shrimp" in spicy sauce - wow! My guests liked their loaded hot dogs. Prices are reasonable with very friendly service. We'll have to try more entrees - spinach ravioli was a good one. Bathroom is accessible. Free street parking right in front.

Update: Chef's fish Reuben sandwich on the menu was heaven!

Take Nicodemus Road driving west from 97 for gorgeous countryside.

Great food and quaint space. I ate in the patio. Kinda small and intimate but felt right for the small town. Well kept establishment. I got a turkey pesto panini which was really good but the homemade chips were outstanding. I finished my sandwich and asked for another beer and another order of chips. Looking forward to my next visit.

We stopped there this afternoon a party of 10 ,they guy waiting on us was very nice did and amazing job and the food was outstanding thumbs up to the staff ,my whole party said they will definitely come back many times again great job 😀

I have gone here off and on for pretty much the past 2 years. Obviously take in to account how busy this is during peak hours. But since I usually go later in the day I have always had a great experience with the wait staff. Especially the other week making my own concoction (I did the assembling myself, not going to do that to the cooks or servers). It's a nice and comfortable place if you are looking to wind down from the day with some good food. I personally recommend their 10oz Burger medium rare, Feta Fries, Boom Boom Shrimp, Crab Dip, Shrimp Salad Sandwich, Buffalo Chicken Panini, Cubano, and Bacon Crab Penne.

Delicious food and nice staff! Will come again.

There is no onsite parking but there is plenty of accessible street parking. They serve cans and bottles of beer and their selection ensured there was something for everyone. The lunch menu was diverse with good choices for vegetarians. I ordered the cheese steak melt and it was superb. Our server DJ really made the experience and we will be back for sure. The food was awesome, the ambience is good, and you should come here for food.

A GEM of a restaurant. First the staff was top notch (very polite and very helpful deciding what beer to get). There were food options for everyone's food pallet. I had the cheeseburger which was very good. The beef was seasons nicely and there were lots of topping you could put on the burger. The cream of crab soup was great starter for a cold night. I highly recommend this place!!!

Great little spot. Stopped for lunch on a recommendation, and couldn't have been better. Atomic dog is fantastic. Son got the turkey club sandwich and it was huge

Uncle Matty's is aways a good place for dinner. The food is good & they have an impressive and ever changing beer menu to keep me happy.

First time eating here tonight. Just need to shoutout Suzanne and the bartender (didn’t get her name). They were both wonderful and super accommodating. Good food as well! Will definitely be back.

Uncle Matty's is one of my favorite eateries. We visited on the occasion of a mercy meal after the demise of a mutual friend, and the food and service were exceptional.

I visited here with a group of others. This place is casual with a reasonable amount of seating, including both booths and tables with chairs. The menu was vast and had a great variety of options to eat, from sandwiches and subs to pasta to rib eyes and chicken or fish. They also had a kids menu and the kids for kid's drinks were sippy kids, which I thought was awesome. The service and food was as awesome as the variety of food they serve. It's an hour away from me, but if I'm ever on the area again I would love to visit again.

Their food is amazing! I love their cheese steak, feta fries, club sandwich, crab soup... I could continue on naming down the list but honestly everything here is yummy. On top of that, Matty & his staff are always super friendly and the service is always excellent/fast. I usually order take out and it’s always ready when they say it’ll be ready and it’s always hot. My only complaint... that I didn’t discover this Gem sooner.