BlueJay Insurance Agency, Inc.

Had an excellent experience with Michael Bendix. This was my first time using an insurance broker and Michael was professional, knowledgeable, and considerate. He was able to get me higher levels of coverage and a lower deductible, all at half the price of my previous policy! Everything was explained thoroughly and I felt comfortable throughout the process. I highly recommend Michael and BlueJay Insurance Agency!

Jay was extremely helpful and walked me through the entire process painlessly. He saved me nearly $1,400 annually by updating my policy and finding the best carrier. I highly recommend if you are looking for a fair independent broker.

Highly recommend! Communication has been great and reliable! My wife and I now use BlueJay for our home, two cars, and a couple add-ins. Insurance packages are very good -- and they compare different companies so you get a competitive rate for the coverage you need. Also helpful in providing recommendations for work to be done. Awesome job.

BlueJay has a very easy in depth online data capture of your information which really made me feel like the agency was trying to truly figure out what insurance would be best for me. I heard from agent Michael Bendix immediately the following morning by email and scheduled a phone call to discuss things further to find me the best insurance. Michael called to determine what insurance was best for my car and town home and emailed me the insurance quote he found to be the best for me. We talked by email and phone over the next several days answering all of my questions to ensure I understood everything and made the right changes to be perfect for me. Michael was SO AMAZING with his great customer service skills in explaining everything, timely correspondence, and focus on ensuring that you as the customer found the very best insurance! I would HIGHLY recommend Michael Bendix because he is just GREAT!!!!

Michael from BlueJay Insurance was a breath of fresh air! He was responsive, proactive, and dedicated to getting me the best rates on my homeowners insurance and auto insurance! I would recommend Michael to anyone looking for a great customer experience! (Thanks, Michael!!)

The service here is incredible. Michael Bendix is a fantastic guy to work with. He was able to find and compare quotes for me as well as explain the details. I learned a lot. Highly recommend.

Jay was very helpful getting my new homeowners & auto insurance policies arranged. He was very thorough, and I was pleasantly surprised at the money I was able to save. He made the process quick & easy. Customer service after has also been great. Very quick to respond to any questions. Would highly recommend!

Can not possibly say more about the fantastic service I received from Jay Schleicher and BlueJay Insurance. We needed something on very short notice, and Jay did a fantastic job getting everything we needed done, efficiently and economically. We'll definitely be checking back with Jay for our future insurance needs.

I’m a new customer with BlueJay and have no complaints! Michael has promptly answered all of my questions and working with him has been a pleasure.

I recently had my first car accident and had to actually use my car insurance. I had a lot going on when I signed up for my policy, so Jay just picked out the best options for me and handled everything. Now, I am SO GLAD I let him choose everything because he thought of it all. I have all the coverages I probably wouldn’t have gotten myself, because Jay knew what was best and took care of it for me. It has made this stressful event so much smoother and I’ll let Jay pick out my insurance forever.
He also called to check on me and make sure I was okay. So kind, so thoughtful, so professional. Can’t recommend him enough.

We depend on Jay to help us choose the right insurance for our condominium and individual owners, and he has never let us down! We appreciate his prompt responses and his thorough answers to our questions. We depend on Jay and the BlueJay Insurance Agency and we're convinced they're the very best!

We just purchased our first home and it was my first time purchasing property insurance. Jay Schleicher came recommended to me, so I called BlueJay out of the blue and they had me ready to go with a policy in an hour. During that time, Jay described all of the different options, why prices were higher or lower across insurers, and how all of the coverage work. Way faster than I would have expected. Very response and helpful - would definitely recommend.

Jay was excellent to work with in helping us transition to a different insurance company that had better rates and with more coverage for both our auto and home policies! He took time to walk through all of the details of our coverages also. Look forward to working with BlueJay for years to come!

I've worked with BlueJay on 6-7 properties and every time it's been a great experience. I always receive quotes from multiple providers yet Jay and team consistently provide the best protection & value. Jay has also helped a dozen clients and they always provide positive feedback. The word that comes to mind with their team is trust and expert advice. I always feel like I'm receiving objective expertise with no "sales" pressure. Highly recommend!

Jay is extremely thorough and works hard to find you the best coverage at the best value on an individualized basis. He always takes the time to call and walk you through the details of your coverage and explain the details in plain English so you know exactly what you are getting and fully understand your plan. My fiance and I have really appreciated Jay's responsiveness and reliable follow-through. I highly recommend BlueJay Insurance to anyone looking to improve their service experience.

Jay at BlueJay Insurance assisted us with setting up Vehicle and Renters Insurance. He was informative, timely, and patient with all of our questions. We've been able to interact with him a few times since the initial meeting and would highly recommend him and the company to anyone in the market for a new insurance provider.

Over my lifetime I've worked with different insurance agencies and now moving around often due to being in the military I found BlueJay Insurance Agency. The location is close to home, and the staff are friendly and helpful. Tanner from BlueJay has been extremely helpful and patient whenever I have questions and responds promptly when I need a new quote or new information. Needless to say they have my loyalty and respect as a client. I'm always thankful to know they got my back.

Best Insurance Company I have ever dealt with. So far I have only worked with Austin but he is amazing and fast at responding and helping with whatever you may need. Will for sure be using them for the for seeable future for any insurance needs I have. Thank you to the friends at BlueJay Insurance for all the help and GREAT customer service. HIGHLY recommend.

Excellent customer service! I worked with Austin and he helped us get better coverage for cheaper than we were paying before. Can't ask for much better service than that. Austin did an excellent job of explaining each of our coverage options and policies. Would recommend him and BlueJay to anyone. 10/10!

Jay and the BlueJay team were very helpful, invested the time to listen to our insurance needs, and tailored an insurance package for our home, auto, and business. Very competitive rates with a much improved customer service level than my previous insurance provider.