Nonnie's Italian Bakery

I really love this little bakery. I was in a bind and needed a cake within two days and every other place that I contacted said they could not do what I needed. For reference it was a white cake, with a picture of Ronald McDonald on it with a raked texture and matching frame. So in my opinion it was a cake that was not complex, but for some reason the large grocery stores refused me. When I went in to Nonnie’s , everyone was so warm and kind. They were personable and became really invested in my silly McDonald's Birthday Cake Debacle. The cake was loved by all that ate it. Very light, but fulfilling. I would recommend anyone who needs baking done, to take a visit to Nonnie’s. They treat you like family , their prices are VERY fair and I will definitely return again.👍 also there Italian cookies next level good! I plan to grab some more in a couple days.🤫

I just had Nella make me a cake and cupcakes for my son’s 1st communion, although I wasn’t able to try either dessert they looked amazing and everyone that ate either cake or dessert said it was very good. I have also ended up becoming a regular and since the staff knows what I order every week they have it waiting for me for when I arrive. Everyone is super nice and always greet you with a smile.

I wish I could give them more stars!!! The staff here is amazing! When we were having a cake emergency due to another bakeries error, the staff at Nonnie’s came through. They made a beautiful and delicious cake for my son’s birthday! They will be my choice from now on!!! Thank you to everyone there who made his birthday so special!!!

I just have to say, you want a true Italian bakery this is the place to go!!! They have a wide variety of food and baked goods! As well as their special bread dipping oil! It is out of this world! So so good! Thank you Nella!!!

My husband and I got grinders today. He got chicken cutlet and I got turkey, cheese and some other toppings. The grinders are amazing. My husband said it was the best chicken cutlet sandwich he has ever had. We have also tried their cookies, Italian bread and dipping oil in the past and everything was amazing. I'm telling you go here for your grinders or if you need any other italian pastries or pies/cakes. If you live in town, it's the best! If you don't live in town but are driving thru stop here, you won't be disappointed!!!

Some of the best Italian pastries I've ever had. And if you're looking for a wonderful selection of gluten free pastas and cupcakes/cakes, this is the place to go. I've had many premiere gluten free cakes, but Nonnie's has figured it out in ways some gluten-free exclusive bakeries have not.

But I'm able to eat gluten, and this bakery is a hidden gem. I recently had the cannoli; I'm serious when I say it's better than what I've had in Boston's North End (for those not from Boston, this is high praise).

I will absolutely be coming back. I'm very happy to have discovered Nonnie's.

First time visit—Stopped in to grab a few treats, since I’ve heard great things about the Lil bakery. I ended up ordering a few mini pies and some Italian cookies. I was lucky enough to sample the chocolate peanut butter pie snd the banana cream pie. They were both delicious! The Italian cookies were also incredibly good, and I’m not one who typically orders these. They just looked too good to pass up!
There was quite a variety of pies, cookies and pastries. They will package orders in bags, individually too.
The staff was extremely pleasant. I plan to return in the near future. 😊

Great neighborhood bakery. Excellent selection of Italian bread, cookies, and pastries. They are even doing grinders and deli meats now. If you love Italian baked goods, you need to visit.

Best gluten free cakes I have ever had! The texture and flavor is absolutely perfect to the point that they are making my wedding cake.

NONNIES recently made a cake for me and I couldn't be happier with the result. I showed her what I wanted and she executed it perfectly. I would 1000% recommend Nonnies if you want a great cake, communication and price.

12/16/23 1st time there. We got greated by very nice people. We got 2 limoncello cake. 1 chocolate fudge. 1 chocolate. And 1 neopolitan cake. Delicious. We will be back monthly if not weekly.
Thank you. 😁

This year has been a very exciting time for my family. Not only did I celebrate a milestone birthday, but I proposed to my girlfriend of 4 years. Nella at Nonnie’s made statement cakes for both celebrations and did not disappoint. The cakes were decorated beautifully and tasted even better. Nella’s signature double chocolate recipe is to die for. We can’t wait to continue to have Nella’s beautiful creations at our future parties and highly recommend her to anyone in the tri-state area!!!

Ordered a cake for a 40th birthday and it was beautiful and delicious. Thank you so much for making this wonderful cake for our family member.

We passed Nonnie’s stand at a local fair and tried the most delicious cream pie we have EVER tried! We are now going to have Nonnie’s bake dessert for our wedding & can’t wait! The owner was so sweet too!

Update: Our wedding cake was absolutely delicious! We had a 2 tier cake with champagne cake with strawberry filling & vanilla cake with Oreo filling. Thank you again, Nonnies! We have found our go-to bakery 😍

Celebrated a special family member’s birthday yesterday with an incredible chocolate mousse cake from Nonnie’s. My sincere thanks to Tiffany for adding your personal touch to the design and decoration. The cake looked wonderful and tasted ever more wonderful! 🎂

Went in a few weeks ago for a little treat(s) and I'm STILL thinking about that delicious crustless cheesecake And their amazing semolina bread! I brought cinnamon rolls and some arancini home as well, we demolished those as soon as we got in the door. Between the amazing treats, delicious bread, warm faces that were so enthusiastic to help when I didn't know exactly what I wanted just that I wanted a treat. This is easily a place worth making a trip to visit, I highly recommend EVERYTHING, I will definitely be going back to try anything else they're baking!

Ordered a Cannoli Cake for my daughters birthday and let me tell you!!!
It was PERFECT! Tasted just like a cannoli, the puff pastry was the best choice...
Will definitely be ordering from Nonnie's for all my bakery needs!!

Great pastries at the bridal shower today! Great owners!

Nonnies bakery is the best! I stop in for my morning espresso and they are so so sweet and welcoming, they really treat you like family! They make the best cannolis EVER and the best Ricotta cookies I’ve ever had!

Excellent. We bought a cake with 4 different layers/flavors for my daughter’s birthday party. Each one of them were delicious and everyone at the party was commenting about it. This is our new favorite bakery. I am so pleased with their work, that this is the first review I ever made. Highly recommended.