Libby's Italian Pastry Shop

Wow! I haven’t been here in a few years. I am so happy they remodeled. It was falling apart before. The best Italian pastry in Connecticut finally has a nice atmosphere too.

They have a great selection of canolies, pastries, and cookies. We bought a bunch of different canolies and they were just as good the next day. The cheesecake and tarts were great as well.

Great authentic Italian pastries and friendly staff. Coffee was not the greatest but decent dark roast to pair with a sweet.

WOW! No wonder there was a line. This place is good. There were Italians here saying that this was a good a home. Not one thing we had was not great. Highly recommend making a stop here.

So glad we reversed down the wrong way to get some pastries. Very tasty canolis and tiramisus (?). Not too sweet and very flavorful. The Nutella canoli was my favorite! If we didn't live 4 hours away I'd be here on a regular basis. Delicious!

We checked out this bakery while we waited for our pizza. Ended up leaving with a handful of goodies. The kids loved all the delicious desserts.

Staff was very helpful. Place is clean and has plenty of seating.

Had a sweet tooth after dinner so decided to check this place out. The gelato was creamy and delicious. I tried the peanut butter flavor. They were out of the cappuccino flavor, but would love to try that next time. Also had a good list of Italian ice flavors. We got an assortment of cookies that were all delicious. My favorite were the yellow ones dipped in chocolate. Also took home pistachio cannolis for our moms.

Omgoodness, I had to keep myself from ordering one of every cannoli! Delicious cappuccinos, lattes and pastries. I was in heaven!

The Black Raspberry Gelato was life changing. One of the greatest flavors ever, perhaps. The Chocolate Gelato was incredibly "dry" and tough, though? I couldn't even finish the chocolate, just totally inedible. Perhaps it was freezer burned, but I wouldn't even bother trying it again. In comparison, the Black Raspberry was so creamy and smooth, and full of flavor. The Heath Bar Cannoli was unique and yummy.

The older lady serving us (maybe the owner?) Was so welcoming and friendly that we chatted for 15 minutes! Delicious sweets in a very cute setting, definitely visit here if in the area!

After moving away, I've missed all my favorite things about home. One of them being Libbys anginettes. On a whim, I looked at their website and saw that they have shipping. I ordered online and made a special request to have a 1lb box of anginettes only along with 1lb of coconut macaroons and 1lb of mixed cookies. They are just as good as if I went in and picked them up fresh. I am so very happy I can now have Libbys whenever I'm homesick. Thank you, thank you, thank you!

Libby's Italian Pastry Shop is so delicious. I had a gelato with half strawberry and half chocolate, and it tasted like a chocolate covered strawberry! I also had a Linzer tart, which I took home and enjoyed the next day that was also delicious. My friend had cheesecake and she said it was delicious. I can't wait to go back for some more of the gelato! I recommend if have never been there to try it, you won't be disappointed.

We love Libby’s! We’ve been coming here for years. The cannolis are so good and the staff is pretty friendly. We’ve had the gelato and it’s delicious too!

In all my years fancying myself an aficionado of Italian pastries, the puffy cannoli has always eluded me, always hiding, perhaps in plain sight behind the glass, amidst the usual suspects in the lineup. The owner offered it to me as a Cannolo Napolitano, with a filling that is not ricotta based. Instead it is an italian pastry cream: thicker, smoother & glossier than the lighter, fluffier pastry cream in cream puffs. I went with vanilla; chocolate is an option. Good for an espresso.

So thankful they are still open during the shutdown. You now walk up and order at a window but that was no problem. All the baked goods are showcased through the window. Love the biscotti's but everything is so good. Best Italian bakery no matter how far you have to drive.

Wonderful Italian bakery in the heart of New Haven’s Little Italy. Wide selection of Italian pastries, cookies and Italian Ice. My favorite and always reliable is the traditional cannoli. I have never had a bad one! Beware though, this is a cash only business. They do not take credit cards or debit cards.

Best pastry shop ever from their cannolis to shaved ices to coffee everything is delicious their cheesecake is also to die for btw!

Libby's is an excellent Wooster Square Italian pastry shop. The cookies, cannolis, and italian ices are amazing. Highly suggest getting the Lobster tail/mezzo mezzo Cannoli, and the ricotta tarts as well as an assortment of the delicious cookies sold by the quarter pound.

Donald was fantastic taking care of serving myself and my gaggle of friends. He was very friendly and knowledgeable and made our experience fantastic!

Cannoli, get all the cannoli. The quality is top shelf, the filling has the right consistency and density and just a hint of lemon. I don't know if they're the best I've ever had but I've never had better