Supreme Pizza

I’ve been going here since I was a kid with my dad. I’ve continued to go here for the last 20 or so years. The owners and people who work here are professional, friendly, and have created a warm and welcoming atmosphere. I’m always happy to go here to enjoy their food. To this day, I can’t find a better tuna grinder than theirs.

I've been going here since I was a kid and the food has always been absolutely amazing. They make my favorite grinders of all time, especially the chicken cutlet, and obviously the pizza is delicious. That being said, what really makes Supreme one of the best spots to get food, is their customer service and attention to detail. By far, one of my favorite food spots!

They are not skimping on toppings. They are feeding the people. The taste isn't going to be your high end pizza, but you aren't leaving hungry.

Excellent food! Nice little hole in the wall with great grinder and pizza options. My mother-in-law got a grilled chicken salad which was huge and tasty. I got a spicy Italian grinder (only half of it pictured because I was so hungry) and my wife got a pepperoni grinder. Both were delicious and big for a size small. The staff was really friendly too. I would highly recommend!

Perhaps the best Capicola grinder around! The quality of the bread used for the grinders is unreal. Will definitely go out of the way to stop at this place in the future.

Best place to get a grinder around this area and exceptional customer service! They stuff the grinder so much, that you can literally make another one if you took some out. Tuna is my favorite!

Decided to drive over and try their single slice. I chose mushrooms and meatball. It was really good with generous topping and a great crust! Of course I expected nothing less since they have a great reputation and provide a personal touch. Price to value was very reasonable, too.

The best local pizza place in Waterford/New London. Good food always ready to be picked up within 20-30 minutes.

Called in to place an order for pickup. Large cheese pizza. The lady that answered the phone was sweet. When i came in to pick up the pizza i noticed the variety of chips they have. Amazing. The staff that works here are super nice and helpful. When i got the pizza it was a lot bigger than i thought a large was going to be. Its not a 16 inch they are 18 inch. Which is good. The pizza tastes amazing. Will definitely add this to my pizza favorites!

A fantastic, delicious mom and pop or family owned pizza place. They sell by the slice or by the pie, the slices are very big if you buy by the slice. For reference 2 slices filled me up. Aside from pepperoni and sausage pizza being a favorite, the Italian grinder is a huge favorite of mine.

Great cheese steaks and awesome staff. You can really taste the fresh bread and produce.

Always excellent food. You get your money's worth. Good portions. Highly recommend 👌.

Some of the best deli grinders around! They load you down with meat and toppings as well!

My husband and I love coming here for our grinders! I get a meatless and they load it up enough for two grinders. The team is usually smiling or messing around in a professional manner. The prices are appropriate and I would recommend this place anytime!

Been going to Supreme for the last 30yrs. There pizza is great! There grinders are AWESOME!! My favorite is the Tuna grinder toasted!! If you want good food, at a great price....Supreme is the place!!

Supreme Pizza really is Supreme! Forget about the chain pizza factories. These folks have been serving Waterford and New London County from before the chains arrived. The chains advertise low prices but have gimmicks that wind up costing you.
Supreme Pizza has great pizzas, sheet pizzas for parties, pastas, salads and the best loaded grinders.
Support your local businesses.
Try Supreme Pizza, you will become a loyal member of their family.
The owners are always on the premises making sure you are satisfied!

Best pizza ever! “Supreme” service and atmosphere!

I've visiting from Florida and was pumping gas in waterford and asked the attendant where I could get a pizza to take over to my friend's I'm normally over in East Lyme or niantic hands down 1 of the best pizzas I've ever had and it seemed like a nice family restaurant 🤙

Great food. The tuna grinder is the best I’ve ever had. The people are awesome and nice. Always laughing. Great place great food. I’m actually about to order right now..

New London-style pizza (and yes, that's a thing) with an unmatched level of counter service banter. There are a few tables if you want to stay and eat, but that's not the point. Pizza is darn good too, my wife keeps wondering why the pie always gets home with a slice missing, I tell her it's the delivery fee.