The Plum Tomato, Colchester, CT

Super fun spot, great quality food, fun atmosphere and fantastic beer list. The pizzas were soooo tasty and the kids food was yummy too. All in all a great spot for a bite and a bit of relaxation after a day at the beach or the seaport. Highly recommend!

Delicious tender eggplant with just a little crisp edge. Tasty sauce, fresh fabulous bread. Great beer and wine selection, everything priced to enjoy. Best part of the meal…Jaden. Best service in a very long time!!!
Looking forward to coming back soon!

The food here can be great but it is really hit or miss. Lately it's mostly miss. I picked up a pizza last night that was more of a cracker than a pie. It was a $27 dollar pizza and most of it remains in my fridge this morning destined to be dog snacks.

No review would be complete without mentioning the massive delays in service. 55 minutes for takeout is not uncommon.

This is my last trip to Plum for myself.

12/8/23 Update -the service here has really turned around for the worse. I ordered a turkey club with no sauce (there's comes with Russian dressing), not hot. What I received was nothing like that. I was so disappointed, I left a message on the store webpage requesting a callback and it's been about a week and no one has reached out. This sandwich was what my dog ate that night, I just couldn't get past two bites.

Staff was great and friendly! Sandwiches are HUGE! Bonus points for homemade bread. Prices are quite affordable. Decent place to check out if you want a relaxed environment.

Excellent pizza! The crust had a nice crisp but also had some chew to it which I liked. I got a large and had left overs for 3 days! Well worth it and still good reheated

The wings were awesome. Nice and crispy outside, juicy on the inside and tossed to near perfection in teriyaki. Waitress was on her game, and I never had to ask for a refill. Great little restaurant.

If everything in a pizza place can be judged by the cheese pizza, The Plum Tomato is One of the best wood fired pizza places in CT. I really like the rustic atmosphere and the friendly people here. Try the Sammy the Bull sandwich! Incredible flavors!

I would have posted pics of the food but my stomach couldn’t wait! Absolutely amazing food whether you get pizza, a sandwich, salad, soup or whatever else they have on the menu! The Sammy the Bull sandwich is AMAZING!!!

Service is always great and staff are super friendly and interactive, but not too much! Quirky little spot that has great eats!

This is by far the best resturant in colchester. Great food .good pricing.liked everything I've eaten here.we love the thin pizza that is served here.

The Plum Tomato recently catered our special event Friday night in Colchester. Worked with Erin Walls and her service was exceptional and thoroughly detailed. Many compliments on the food! I highly recommend for catering!

Gluten Free Goodness! This was my third visit and I still am amazed. This first visit was coming across this place accidentally because my 2 year old grandson was "starving" on our way to Rhode Island. It was a pleasant and unexpected surprise. My daughter noticed the "gluten free" sign, so we walked in. I ordered the "Mad Cow" and I was not mad in the least bit for ordering it. A mouth watering gluten free relation to any Philly Cheesesteak sandwich I had in Philly. Happily this version is on their very own gluten free homemade flat type bread. The bread, yes GF bread is delightfully warm, seasoned as well as having a delicious buttery flavor. The first bite is always my favorite. The horseradish sauce, fried roasted peppers & onions through the thinly sliced roast beef, has me sighing from the comfort of really good food. Creamy, crunchy, and cheesy gooeyness run down my chin, and this makes me incredibly happy. (My daughter was equally happy with her Sammy the Bull chicken roasted sandwich which she shared with her son during our first visit)
Their Slogan reads: Food So Good, It's Addictive, Please Eat Responsibly. So true. I wish they were closer than the hour ride on route 85 in Salem, CT. Open everyday at 11am. The staff is friendly and it is obvious they have repeat customers from local workers, families and people on their way to the New London Beaches. There are a few tables in this quaint store front. Please go! it's worth it. find me on instagram @gltuenista_foodie

Just a short time in Colchester, but after eating at the "Plum" we are impressed. Friendly service, good and plenty food ( enough pasta to have a second dinner and the tuna wrap served a lunch too) We will be back!

their pizza is delicious, the sauce is very flavorful and so homemade tasting, complimenting the cheese and the crust. always love getting their black bean quesadilla as well. great selection of lunch, dinner, and dessert and service is always friendly.

Great pizza, wings and sandwiches. Awesome local beers on tap. Inviting for a whole family or a casual date! Dave and Erin are the best.

I have eaten here for lunch and recently used them to cater a party at home. The staff is friendly and helpful. Erin provided excellent customer service to ensure I had everything I needed to feed my hungry friends and family! The food has consistently been fantastic, with large serving sizes, and full of flavor.

We used Plum Tomato Colchester Catering for our party. Everyone loved the food. Our experience in making the food order and having it delivered was the best. The people were very helpful and pleasant . Will use them again for future events.

Food was great waitress was attentive and helped out alot.
BBQ chicken pizza and Fiesta fries with a bottle of Moscato

Have been a customer for years, but recently used the catering service for the for the first time - it was awesome! Food was great - portions generous - and staff was a pleasure to work with. Highly recommend!

The Plum Tomatoe is very popular in Colchester Ct. and rightfully so, the pizza,pasta,italian breads and sandwiches are always done to perfection. The waitresses are very attentive and personable, especially Kayliegh. Across the board its a great place for lunch or dinner.

Stopped in for a quick bite after a lacrosse game nearby. Great wings, amazing wraps and some of the best pizza I've had in years. Worth going out of your way for if you're not in the area, and if you're in the area it's a no brainer.