Shelter Insurance - Katy Combs

Katy's office was so helpful when I was looking for a new insurance carrier. They spent so much time answering my questions. They were quick with the quote too. I appreciate fantastic customer service, as it's rare for many companies.

Katy has an extraordinarily amazing group of women whom work at Shelter Insurance, including herself! I could never fathom choosing another agency besides Shelter. Martin who?

Katy has been our go to girl for so long. We also love Rosalie who makes everything you have to do with insurance so simple! Katy ALWAYS makes sure to find the best deal & we have been recommending her to all of our friends and family! I promise you won’t find a better insurance agent in Muncie! Thank you Katy and staff for all you do for our family!

Kaylie at Combs Insurance is a great agent! We have four cars, a boat, and a motorcycle, and she’s always ready to help us with any question we have.

The service that we received from Katy and her assistants is a welcome change from other insurance providers. She made us feel like we are the most important client that she has. Our questions were answered promptly, and we were offered a good selection of options. Rosalie went above and beyond when she was able to get life insurance for our daughter (who has a lifetime disability). I can’t thank her enough for that. I recommend Katy Combs-Shelter Insurance to anyone looking for a great insurance provider!

Katy has been my insurance agent for about a year and a half. She's the best insurance agent that I have ever had.

She focuses on helping me to understand what coverage is what, and picking the best plan for me whilst saving money.

The office manager, Rosalie, is the one I normally speak to when calling in. She has treated me with nothing but respect and can hold a conversation very well.

If you're looking for a new insurance agent that can save you money, this is where you should be looking.

Katy and her team are always super fast to answer any questions. Recently I filed a claim and had my payout in four days start to finish without any headaches. She has saved me a ton of money and I will always recommend at least a chat with her to see what magic she can work!

Katy and Stephanie make a great team! We have had nothing but the BEST service from both of them! Very customer oriented and always responds to phone calls or emails. We appreciate the time that Katy takes to go over our policies to make sure everything is where it needs to be! Katy and Stephanie are awesome!

Great experience coming into the office anytime. These girls make insurance painless, cheap, and FUN!

I love Katy. Her and Stephanie are great. We have been with her a very long time and my in-laws have been with her even longer. If you ever need anything life or other insurance, they are the best!!!

I don't know why this is saying Clare.........our daughter and not Sue Terry her Mom. We have been so impressed with Katy and Stephanie. They are so helpful. You are treated like family with a "what more can we do for you" attitude. We have referred many people who purchase homes from us and I have not gotten one poor report. Helpful, helpful, helpful! I highly recommend.

I have personally been a client of katys for about 5 years. Katy and Stephanie are great to work with. They go over all the options with me and give detailed information about my policy when I have questions. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for insurance !

Katy has always been so great to deal with and very easy to contact on all my insurance needs. Either during hours or after she always goes above and beyond to help me and my family out.

They quoted all my policies so quickly. Super friendly and saved me some ca$h.

Very cool.
Worker, Rosalie, is always ready to help if needed and answers any questions. Very customer friendly. Great place to go through. 100% recommend looking into simply for the customer courtesy and satisfaction.

Katy is a joy to work with! She helped me get a great price on insurance for my small business. I highly recommend her. Fast, friendly and honest!

I've been with Katy Combs Shelter Insurance for years. We've had several claims and both Katy and Stephanie have gone above and beyond to help us. Both are very friendly and personable. I recommend them often.

Katy is phenomenal! She is very responsive and informed. She and her staff do a great job of exceeding my expectations.

Kaylie is the most courteous knowledgeable agent I have ever talked with.

Insurance stuff is never fun, but they make it seem easy! They are very helpful in finding what’s best for you. There are some AWESOME people that work here.