Elm Street Brewing Company

I only am giving 5 stars due to our wonderful waiter Phoenix! Absolutely made my first experience very welcoming, even came and chatted with us regarding our flights of beer.
I will say that the beer choice is extensive, so I was very pleased with the options. Although the house brew is not to my particular taste buds but I am in no means a beer connoisseur and am very picky, not to any fault of this establishment.
Again I thank Phoenix for the wonderful experience and the reason we will return!
Oh Mac and Cheese add Brisket is absolutely delicious!

Second Visit Feedback: Exceptional Staff Hiring

During our second visit, it became evident that the establishment excels in staff recruitment. Our experience with Georgine, our waitress, reaffirmed this observation. Once again, we were treated to absolutely fantastic service. And once again the food did not disappoint!

By far my favorite local restaurant. Everything is always exceptional, the food and the service. I have never had a bad experience . Definitely order the mac & cheese (the bacon jam is phenomenal) It is the best I have ever had, but please don’t sleep on the pizza either. We love going on Friday and Saturday evenings when the have live music. It’s always a great time and the atmosphere is wonderful. If you are in Muncie, this is a must.

Very delicious. We went at 4pm so it was empty. We came in to visit our daughter at Ball State. She has been there once before and took us there. The building is cool. The portion size was great for Mac and cheese but was very small for the soup. All in all I would go again. The guacahummus was super. For 5 of us the total was $102. A bit pricey but it was definitely worth it. The server was very friendly and helpful. I think the French fries could have been better.

This is a hidden gem of Muncie. We had the tenderloin, Colorado Chili, Spinach dip. All were delicious. Be ready for some spicy dip and chili though.
The beer selection is really diverse with a selection or different tastes. They have their own brew, several guest breweries on tap and big selection of bottles.
Prices of everything are pretty reasonable and the service was good.

We got pizza to go and it was delicious!

We tried the cheese, pepperoni, and pit master.

The cheese had a lot of flavor, because of the multiple kinds of cheese.
Pepperoni was good and different with the yellow cheese.
The pit master was very very good! Smoked meats, the bbq sauce!! And cheeses.... It all went together so well!

Look forward to trying more from the menu. Also excited to have another pizza besides the blah chain pizza.

We had a great experience. The food, beer, and service were all top notch. The atmosphere is very unique and inviting. We will definitely e back again to try some some dishes and brews.

Very impressed by the wide variety of beers on draft. The chili was delicious and had a great spice level.

Great staff who were accommodating to our large group. TONS of unique beers (it was almost overwhelming!)
Definitely recommend the mac and cheese with bacon jelly. Sooo good.

Went there for drinks only, nice location and friendly staff.
Drinks didn't disappoint either 😊 also a nice place if you just want to grab a beer, huge selection!

You walk in and you are able to appreciate the building history. We kept wondering what the building was in the past, and it used to be an icehouse. We tried different beers. They are heavy in IPAs. My favorite was the milkshake IPA. It has well balanced flavor. Hops forward, but delicate at the same time. As far as food goes, the muscles were Amazing. The stock was not overpowering, but delicious at the same time. I also try the Chili. One the best chili I ever had. They are doing a great job at this microbrewery. I will definitely come back.

Nice place ! The decor was very nice. Our server was very helpful and quick! They had great dry rub wings and were on special! Tried a few of their beers, all were very good! (Also on special last night) Also had a live band last night!

Up from TN visiting fam for a few weeks. Had a phenomenal experience here from start to finish. Ashlyn, the host, was very kind, friendly and welcoming. We lucked out and had an OUTSTANDING server, Alexis! If you go, definitely request her. She will only add to your experience. She was extremely attentive, yet not over bearing. She was friendly, courteous and had one goal which was obvious: to have a wonderful experience. The setting in the former old ice house is so comfortable with some unique additions, such as all the different light fixtures. There were five of us, and each of us loved everything we ordered. As you can see from the pictures, a full rack of ribs is a FULL RACK OF RIBS. It was served on a baking tray! You can also see from the pics, I only finished half of mine. They were delicious! Fell off the bone. We were all amazed at the size! Two had sirloins that were fixed to the perfect temps. Another had the pork medallions, which she said were great. So...100% on the food. The beer selection was huge and diverse. I had one then chose a flight to try four others. Enjoyed them all. The entire night of our friends n fam little reunion was completely enjoyable, and we chose a good place to do it. Thanks, Elm Street, and a huge thanks to you, Alexis.

Great food, great beer, great atmosphere. This place is fantastic. The staff is friendly and fun. Lots of great food choices too for good prices. Huge list of drinks available including lots of in-house brewed choices.

Great dining and beer selection! Service was great and food was delicious! Pizza and salad were great!

Excellent beer and food selection. The atmosphere was great and plenty of seating; indoor and outdoor. Would definitely reccomend the place.

I have now been here for lunch, dinner, and brunch, and loved each visit. Menu has plenty of unique options that you can’t go wrong with, beer selection is great with wonderful locally brewed beers, and I just love the wood burning stove and exposed brick throughout. Also have witnessed live music.

Great restaurant, great service, and GREAT BEER!! 10/10 would recommend. Especially if you’re looking for an open place on Monday. Fresh, quick and fresh. Thanks Elm Street. We will be back

Great IPA! Quite possibly the best brisket Philly I have ever had!!

Very nice place and will preserved piece of Muncie history. The staff of very hospitable and knowledgeable about all of the menu items and drinks. A place for a professional business meeting or an intimate steering for a nice date. The food is priced very responsibly and tastes amazing.

Great Beer, amazing Mac and Cheese, don't forget to ask about dessert! Don't miss out on Tuesday open mic night!