Straight from New York Pizza

A slice of pie did not disappoint. First time at this location. I tend to like my pizza hot, delicious taste just a little on the cold side.
I can ask to warm it a little longer, no big deal.

It's definitely a place to grab a slice.
Love the atmosphere.

Most excellent pizza I've ever had. My favorite is geek veggie and chicken bacon ranch. Crispy crust, meals in your mouth. You have to try their super fluffy bread stick. Salads are large and hearty.

Had to drive 35 minutes to find real authentic New York style pizza! This place does not disappoint! Salem I am so jealous! You have a slice of heaven every day !

The most excellent pizza, only downside is the booth seating areas have many tears in them. Could easily be improved by replacing worn out seating.

The pizza absolutely unbelievable!! The pepperoni is perfect, but the veggie is the best vegetarian pizza I ever had. Absolutely delicious!!!!

The place looks clean , really really friendly staff. My pizza was good 😊👍

So delicious! I ordered for pick-up 30 min. before they closed and it was perfection! It was so tasty, that I was forcing myself to finish my 4th slice. I'm so glad I ordered the 18" pies because now I have leftovers. 😋🤤😎🍕

When moving to a new neighborhood, there are a few things you have to find. A good place to drink beer, a good place to buy produce, and a good place to deliver you pizza. After a half dozen local pizza joints, we found our delivery pizza of choice.

We haven't branched out from the classic pepperoni pizza, but I can honestly say I don't need to try other pies to know that this is the kind of pizza I like. First and foremost, the crust is the star of the show. Chewy in the best possible way through the cheese topped portion (and it certainly tastes like good quality cheese), and thick and fluffy in the crust-end. Dip the crust in some salad dressing or marinara, it's far too bread-like to eat dry (but that's totally by design!) The pepperoni is also well-chosen, letting out enough of its greasy deliciousness into the cheese and sauce to make it the kind of pizza that's actually worth the calories. The sauce itself is sweet and rich, but is also subtle enough not to demand too much of your attention, so you can focus on the rest of the pizza, which is unquestionably better. A bolder sauce would probably be overkill on a pizza like this.

Maybe even best of all, pizza is all about the leftovers, and SFNY's pie actually gets better over the course of a few days. Bake it in the oven and it'll even better than when it was fresh.

Honestly the five star rating is solely on the pizza sauce alone!! So good. I got a standard pepperoni with garlic added. It was a simple but well executed pizza. We also got a salad and I love the variety of toppings that comes on it. It’s a nice change up from boring salads. Nice work, straight from NY!

Love getting a slice here. Probably my kids' favorite pepperoni pizza. Always money well spent here.

Honestly this is the best pizza I have had in a very long time - flavorful, great sauce, crispy crusts, HUGE slices. Service was great and I would absolutely recommend this place to anyone finding themselves in Salem.

LOVE the pizza and this was my first time to this location, but I was not disappointed with any aspect of it. Absolutely a plwce yiu wouldn't want to miss if you're looking to grab a slice!!

Very standard straight from New York experience. All of them are about the same with the same menu with the same service and the same speed.

Always love the pizza and service we get here.

This place is delicious!! Driving through on the 5 and SO glad we stopped off to grab some slices. Super fast and friendly service and the food is SUPER fresh. Good selection of veggie and meat lover slices. Will definitely make the stop again when passing through, well worth it. Thanks for a delish dinner!!

I could eat here every day. Sometimes I do. Just like pizza in new York city.

I love there pizza!! Its cooked fresh to order and the pizza is huge. The bread sticks are great and so are the chicken wings. The people who work there are super friendly and the service is great! They have outdoor seating in the summer. You can have a cold beer while your waiting. Give them a try you will love them too!!!

I picked up a slice to-go. The slice crunched. Crispy crust, flavorful, delightful. Not a soggy flacid slice. 10/10 will come here again.

Good pizza, and the young men working at the counter. We’re very nice! I recommend if you’re looking for a tasty treat!

As a New Yorker - I probably have this false sense of authority on Pizza. However, this place is unbelievable. The pizza is awesome and takes me home every time I stop in with the wife and kids. This truly is the best pizza in Salem - hands down. Staff is always friendly and now that they deliver I am going to have to hit the gym more often.