Chesterton Toys

We absolutely love Chesterton Toys! They’re always so nice and welcoming, plus they have a great selection of interesting toys and puzzles! They make a point to remember you, which says a lot about how much they care about their customers. If you haven’t checked them out, I highly recommend it!

What a gem. Zach the owner was very kind and welcoming. We found some unique puzzles and classic candy. Prices were reasonable. Easy to park and walking distance downtown Chesterton. Will definitely be back!

I am a huge fan of toy stores and this one is top notch. The owner was personable and available. I bought way more than I budgeted, but the quality of it all, was totally worth it. Great store!

This place is fantastic! You gotta love trying new snacks, buying cool new toys and also chatting with the employees who love collecting more than yourself.

Only problem I had was my son and I breaking the pump on the water rocket before we got a good launch. It was still fun while it lasted.

Great selection of toys of all ages. Adorable books. A MUST stop for sure. Bought gifts for 2 year olds' birthday.

Our go-to place . The two of us enjoy the fact that you can check out the items before you buy and pretty much the same price as you know who . There are a lot of items to consider for young minds to keep active. Owners will answer any questions you may have extremely helpful.

Huge fan of Zack and the store. I had a chance to speak with Zack today and he took a lot of time out of his day to explain to me what the toy store is all about. Heck of a guy and a great artist! Thanks for the conversation.

Really cute, clean store with a great variety of toys and candy. Well organized and the owners are so nice and helpful.

This toy store is a must go! They have so many fun things and my favorite place to pick up funkos! They have really fun pens guaranteed to keep you distracted at work! Plus, they stock lots of developmental toy and books!

I cannot recommend this store enough! It is perfect for your toy or gift giving needs. The owner is so nice and welcoming everytime I go in! Great stock, reasonable pricing, friendly and helpful staff. Go support a great local business!

Loved browsing all their unique toys! Walked away with an adorable soft airplane teether and a plush puppy animal. Definitely shop small and support this local business!

My granddaughter and I visited today and had a fun-filled experience. The people were welcoming and friendly and interacted with her. She was so excited about her Playmobil Fire Station and I appreciated the variety of books, puzzles and games. She's been playing with it for hours. It wasn't difficult to set up, just as they let me know at the store. Thank you for a memorable, happy experience!!!

Amazing little shop. Very unique selection of toys, candy, books, and puzzles. The business owner and staff were all so kind and friendly. Would highly recommend stopping in! (Side note, I don’t have any children to buy toys for and ended up picking up a few great things for myself!)

I visited for the first time today. I was looking for a gift for my 8 year old cousin. The shop owner was very friendly and inviting and had wonderful recommendations. I ended up buying exactly what he recommended and I can't wait to deliver my gifts. Great stock and charming environment!

If I had kids, I'd buy their toys here. I've been here a few times on assignment and I've always been floored at how cool the place is. Tons of unique, fun toys and the owners are always extremely excited about new arrivals and toy lines that they've got.

One thing - "cheapness" seems to be low on the priority list here - almost everything I've seen in the store has been well-made and built-to-last - so don't expect to hop in, buy a $2 plastic trinket, and hop out. Not a bad thing, in my mind, but something to keep in mind.

I could spend an hour just browsing the cool stuff they've got here. Love it.

Wonderfully stocked with delightful toys, books, nostalgia and candy! It doesn't get better than this in a small town with a big heart! The owner loves what he does and it shows! This will be my first stop for any children's needs! Handicapped friendly!

Unlike any other toy store around. Many great toys with a focus on not only learning, but being environmentally conscious about how the items are packaged. That means a lot to me personally. Zack and Tracy are always so friendly and knowledgeable. They also have old fashioned candy!

A fantastic little surprise on our vacation. The kids loved it and so did we. Great selection of toys, gifts, candy, boars games, home decor for the modern nerd and more.

very nice store, prices are good for a small town local store. ♡ friendly service. we will be back.

Absolutely wonderful toy store. Adorable place, with a friendly shop owner that has the perfect recommendation for any kids birthday or holiday gift. I will definitely be coming back 👍