The Toys Time Forgot

I can’t even explain how incredible this shop is - I am from Southern California and I kid you not, this is the BEST vintage toy shop I’ve ever seen. And, I have been to every vintage toy shop you can imagine and as a serious, very knowledgeable vintage toy collector - THIS IS THE BEST. The service is unmatched, the owners and those working are not only some of the nicest people I’ve met, but true fans of the toys from every time period. I teared up, literally, seeing so much from my childhood, and knowing I’d have to take several items home to California. We are going back tomorrow, because it was just a true privilege to see such care taken with these treasures from childhood and beyond. The shop is stunning, organized, well laid out, and I spent hours in there just staring and feeling JOY. I feel honored to have been there and I can’t wait to come back every time I visit my mom in Ohio. THIS PLACE IS THE BEST STORE I HAVE EVER SEEN. Everything you can imagine, if you loved it, they have it — in perfect condition, complete, clean and you get to talk toys with the incredible staff. I am serious when I say I feel it was a gift to just be there. Thank you guys for an unforgettable experience and the highest quality service there is. I am a huge fan of vintage toys, but now a huge fan of this store and all of you!

What an awesome store!! Just looking at all the amazing toys was incredible, but finding some treasures to take home was even better!! Super friendly staff!! If work doesn’t bring me back to the area I’m going to have to road trip!!

Excellent destination for all your vintage (and new) toy needs - PLUS TONS more. Wonderful staff with friendly and knowledgeable service highlighted my recent visit. They REALLY know their stuff. Outstanding shop with a wide selection of items from the 50s to the present. It's a very eclectic shop as well carrying everything from board games, to action figures, play sets, Sideshow Collectibles, trading cards, comics and everything in between. I was astounded by the breadth of the inventory and had not seen some of the toys since I was a kid in the 1970s. And lest you think I am simply talking about Star Wars (which they have a ton of) - it's just a lot of really obscure, rare, and highly collectible items. This is a MUST visit on the Ohio Toy Trail and a wonderful vintage toy store. Special thanks to Josh and Jacob on my recent visit.

My wife, kid, and I like to stop here all the time for our Funko collections and to honor the tradition of every time I start a new D&D campaign my 3yo picks out the dice (they'll be hers collection when she's older if I can successfully introduce her to D&D). Everyone's very friendly and seems to really enjoy themselves, and are always happy to geek out over awesome stuff (which it's all awesome).

Aside from our own Funko Pop and D&D centric outings, it's also a great place for anyone looking for classic toys from across a multitude of eras.

Very cool shop. They were busy and we had to wait to go in. But, the person working was super nice. I'm not a regular here, but they treated me like I was 💚 They have so many cool games and statues. Perfect place for gamers, horrors fans, marvel fans, table top gamers, comic book collectors, and any one who's a fan of old games 😍😍

Vast collection of toys, games, collectibles, and comic books. People come from Japan and Europe to buy and trade in collectible toys. Items from 50's to today. If you are a toy collector this place is just Awesome. A true Ohio treasure.

Very cool shop! My grandson and I stopped in and were blown away by the amount of stuff. This little shop is PACKED! There are toys from before I was even born and I'm no spring chicken. Something to delight everyone - toys, board games, figurines, comic books, etc. The staff was super friendly. Will definitely come back again when I have more time to fully look at everything. A must see.

This place was amazing and the staff was very attentive. I myself was not shopping, but my friend was looking for a particular comic, which they searched for and found. A lot of amazing memorabilia.

Such a well organized store that is like a time capsule for middle aged farts like me. A great selection of comics and toys with a very engaged staff working to meet your needs and a very good knowledge of their inventory. Definitely a place worth revisiting when you’re in the area.

Great place crammed with new and vintage toys and comics. There's so much to see and some great nostalgia. Really friendly and helpful staff too.

Awesome place with a huge variety of Funko Pops plus all your favorite toys, action figures, and games from your childhood.

What a pleasant surprise to find this place. Saw things that I have not seen and have not seen in a long time. There's so much to look at. They use every nook and cranny to put stuff. You are missing out if you don't check this place out!

Very cool place. Packed with vintage toys, games and comics.

ThIs place is AMAZING!! You need at least a few trips to take it all in! Prices are fair and the owners are wonderful. I never wanted to leave. Make sure you give yourself plenty if time to enjoy all your time here.

Knowledgeable friendly service. Great selection of hard to find vintage goodies!

Great place for nostalgia. Wonderful place, if they don't have what your looking for the can find it and get it for you. I collect Vintage GI Joe's and love shopping there. Been a loyal customer for the last decade or more. Nice selection of toys of all types from all periods.

Found exactly what I was looking for today and more!! My wife and I found some Funko Pop figures we wanted and I found a Vampirella figure I've been looking for a good price on for five years since I became a fan of hers. We first visited during Covid and a few years later we're happy to see they're still doing well. They also had an awesome dollar comic booth at Olde Canal Days today with some awesome deals on comic sets and single issues too. Found a great Aliens set and Punisher books as well. Toys Time Forgot ISN'T an experience you'll forget soon. 😁😁 Definitely worth the 55 min drive from Cleveland.

Very crowded and hard to navigate, but they have a lot of cool and interesting toys that are worth the trip!

Wonderful toy store. Antiques and vintage items, all in outstanding condition, and plenty of new toys, too. Quite a little gem of a store.

Really cool store with toys from every decade. Very helpful staff.