New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream

One of the best homemade ice cream spots around. always worth the wait (be prepared there’s usually a line!) make sure you remember CASH ONLY! 10/10 would recommend!

This is the best place to get ice cream. So many good flavors and all made there, always so fresh. Most of the time there's some sort of line but it moves pretty fast . They only accept cash. One of my favorites is the pistachio nut flavor and coconut. They have great shakes. Peanut butter is my favorite. You'll love it

We drive 40 minutes for this ice cream and it never disappoints!

I loved their PB ice cream we had the first time I was there this summer. But last time we went they didn't have it!!!! Ughghh.
Still a great selection.

I’ve been taking my family for ice cream at New Baltimore forever, best ice cream ever! I have tried it all from Sundays to root beer floats, everything is good and plenty!

Awesome place and awesome service. Was extremely busy and a long line with lots of orders moved through very swiftly. We had an enjoyable time with excellent ice cream for a treat on a hot and muggy day. Thank you so much.

The ice cream was superb!!!! Totally recommend. Homemade and lists of flavors and options.

I had to get a child's portion because I couldn't finish a regular size! So happy with the choices and especially the homemade flavors. Mmmmmm

Ice cream very good!. Nice large dips. Unfortunately they are only open seasonal.

My family loves coming here for ice cream. Staff is always very friendly and the prices are great.

Even if you are not in the area of Marlboro, Ohio, you owe it to yourself to try the ice cream at New Baltimore Homemade Ice cream. It is the best.

Very good ice cream. I do wish they had more non fruit variety like coffee or mocha

I go all the time. The line can be long but it's worth any wait. Make sure you have cash - no credit cards (keeps costs down) All their stuff is awesome! Park around back and eat outside!

Cash only. But a great little place for ice cream. I'm lactose intolerant and figured getting ice cream would mess up my evening, but surprisingly it didn't. I don't know if I was having a good day, or if the pumpkin and rootbeer flavors I got were made dairy free. Either way it was delicious and my stomach didn't mind it at all!

Excellent traditional style ice cream oh, the Blue Moon is absolutely spectacular in the portion sizes are generous. I really can't recommend it enough.

Great little place for ice cream. Turtle sundae is the awesome!

The best ever ice cream. Homemade by genuine great giving people. Small community based.

Ice is the best around!! Well worth the wait!
Prices are great for the amount of ice cream!!
They only take cash

Ice cream wasn't bad. They ran out of the flavor we went there for but still we a good time

New Baltimore Ice Cream is an amazing place to get ice cream. So tasty. The people who work there are friendly and efficient.