Bagels and Cakes by Club 86

I absolutely love this place. I live about 15 minutes away, I've never stayed to dine in, I usually order cakes haha. Their strawberry layer cake is absolutely to die for. The prices are amazing for a cake in general. It's always fresh, looks beautiful and of course their icing is the absolute best. Highly recommend stopping here and getting a slice but you'll definitely want a whole cake 😅

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 - 476 Hamilton St., Geneva, NY

This is review is solely based on the service and Bagels. Both are excellent.

I went on two days; Day 1 was an Everything Bagel with olive and pimento cream cheese and Day 2 was an Onion Bagel with Chive and Garlic cream cheese. They were toasted just right (I like it very crisp), and they were delicious.

The place was busy for both visits, but the friendly staff were able to deliver orders quickly. Stop in for a bagel if you are in town!

We had a wonderful breakfast here one sunny February morning before getting started on our wine event. The breakfast sandwiches were delicious, the acai bowl was perfect, coffee was great...no complaints at all! This will probably be our go to place next time we're staying overnight in Geneva.

Such an amazing little cafe. Great bagels , cookies and sandwiches as well as, just plain good coffee. If you ship your coffee beans , I need them!

Staff were friendly and it had a great local crowd.
Worth a stop for breakfast if you're in the area

This is a phenomenal restaurant! It's worthy of not only breakfast that we came back for lunch! Both meals were outstanding. ....and Fish Fry Friday is very delicious!

Local hint: try the lemon sugar cookie!

My boyfriend and I went here for a late lunch. It was his first time. The food was spectacular. The service was wonderful. An amazing experience.

Had a Apple Orchard salad and substituted the chicken for steak. The food was excellent and atmosphere was nice. The person taking my order was super accommodating with my request

If you have never been here, you won't believe the menu. It'll take you ten or more minutes to decide what you want to eat. My favorite breakfast there is the salmon lox bagel. Delish

A Geneva institution and some of the best bagels you'll find in central NY. Their layered strawberry cake is a staple at any of our family functions!

We had greens and beans, rigatoni with meatballs, a chicken and bowtie pasta soup, and roast beef swiss pesto pannini

We have family breakfast here and what ever we ordered it was awesome noting can complain at all love it and 💯 will be back

We came out on Christmas Eve. Everything was amazing and we cannot wait to come back. Thank you!! So grateful to have such a terrific local spot.

Formerly from Geneva, we now reside in FL. There are a vast amount of Bagel shops in Sarasota/Bradenton, Fl area. We have visited many. BUT, I must say the Bagels at Bagels & Cakes in Geneva, NY are second to none. And, their veggie spread is outstanding. I now realize why the parking lot is full all day long. The employee serving me was very friendly and engaging, which is becoming rare. Keep up the good work!

Bob Marchenese

Food was great, workers were awesome! Was a little bit of a wait on a weekend brunch time but that's how you know it's good right? Maybe order online?

Stopped for breakfast while on a trip with the wife. Food was great and the people were friendly.

We Loved this place! Great breakfast after a hard workout. Açaí bowl with granola was just what the doctor ordered. We split that along with the avocado toast (with egg, of course!). So many great options here!

We got our wedding cake on our first anniversary and it’s JUST as good as it was last year. Get the strawberry layer, you won’t regret it.

Very good selection of food and everyone on my crew enjoyed what they ordered!

This place is always a banger! Fresh food, coffee is superb and the staff are SO nice! I just wish that I lived closer to go more often 🖤

BLT with avocado with fries was really good. Not too much or too little. The others had similarly good food. I think it was the huevos rancheros and a smoothie bowl. Good atmosphere and big menu.