Four Brothers Pizza Inn

Delicious food!! We had the small pizza (before hiking for extra energy😅) and we ordered the small one and that served 2 adults! You can choose the toppings. The base is not thin! I recommend❤Super friendly staff! The place is simple, clean and inviting.

I don’t know what all the bad reviews are about. I had a great experience here. I had a great sausage grinder with homemade marinara sauce and German chocolate cake. My wife had the beef gyro with peanut butter pie. She loved and my mom had the Greek salad. Also loved. Our waitress Sam was amazing. She was a fill in from another restaurant and was serving us and another party of 16. She amazingly was doing a great job. I wish I could have seen how it worked out for her night. She is a great waitress and very friendly. I am from Albany and was only down there because my I brought my mom down because she grew up there and had me there. I will one day go there again and believe me. I’ll be going there for a meal again. I hope Sam is still our waitress. Lol. Thanks for such a great experience guys and Sam.

My family and I love this place. Their pizza is SO delicious and they have a crispy chicken wrap that is the only thing I want to eat while I’m currently pregnant. My husband tried their wrap with greek dressing tonight and the dressing was AMAZING. The people who work there are always so nice. I am shocked there are any negative reviews. Can’t wait to come back soon! 🥰🍕🥗

Love this restaurant, pretty decor on the wall and displays. Food is good taste, service is great! Definitely come back

Awesome place to eat and talk. Music is not to loud so that you can't speak to people you are with. Food is great too.

Everything was fantastic. The food, the server were excellent. It was s wonderful experience.

Good menu. Good prices. Good service. Will definitely go back again.

I love Four Brothers Pizza!!! They use very good quality product and it shows. I had a small cheese pizza and my husband had a Greek Salad.

It is close to Dover Stone Church where I want to go hiking so we will be back soon.

A staple of the local community, you'll be warmly greeted by the employees and the attention to detail is outstanding

Delicious food, attentive staff and easily accessible location ❗

The service is great, food is absolutely delicious and the atmosphere is quiet.

I’ve never been to a Four Brothers before. Was driving by and it looked cozy from the road so we decided to stop for a bite to eat. Food was delicious. The people were really nice. It felt like such a homey place to be. I live closer to the one in Mahopac but will definitely be back to this location specifically. I just wanted to say thanks for the great meal and a nice little dining experience! We left very happy.

Very nice restaurant. Plenty of selection on the menu. Pizza was good. Mostly Italian cuisine.

Clean. Staff was attentive. Kitchen was flexible and able to adjust a couple of meals for various dietary restriction.

Not much else to compare it to in the town of Dover. Glad it is there when we are not in the mood to travel far to go out to eat at a restaurant.

The food was absolutely outstanding. The waitstaff were super friendly and exceptionally accurate. The amount of food was amazing! The meatball casserole was exceptional. The ziti was perfectly al dente. I will definitely be going back to this place. Arrive there hungry. You will not leave there hungry!

What an amazing find! I've had 1000's of slices in my life, from all over NYC and this pizza stands with the best of them. The balance of all the ingredients is incredible. I was hoping to criticize their thick crust style, but I left amazed. Great job guys. I'm definitely coming back!

One of the best Pizzeria, I've been to, out of my city. They serve brick oven pizza pies, in 3 different sizes. There toppings are fantastic. I especially loved the cheese they used, you can definitely taste the difference.
They also serve all types of Italian pasta dishes.If you're ever in the area of Four Brothers Pizza, I suggest you make that pit stop 🍕

Can feel the history in the place. Great food, particularly the marinara sauce which is so tasty.

Amazing portions! The food is simply good old-fashioned delicious comfort food. The wait staff is very knowledgeable and polite. I will definitely be coming back to this place.

Consistently great pizza, love their gyros and chicken parm sandwiches. Fast and friendly!

Four brothers is on the list of best pizza I've ever had in my life if not the best. Consistently good and their Greek salad dressing is good for the crust or almost anything else you could think to put salad dressing on. Recommend highly.