Gaines Street Pies

Pretty fantastic find while I was passing through Tallahassee. The place certainly has a vibe, I'll let the photos convey that better than my words. They stay open until pretty late, which is super cool.

The pizzas are amazing. 10/10. Some of the best thin crust I've ever had. You just gotta allow some time for them to be prepared, which is fair enough for the quality you get. I personally recommend the Bruno if you like Pepperoni. No complaints about the service either. Everyone is super chill and nice.

Can't find anything to complain about. You simply can't go wrong with this place.

The food was delicious and the service was great. The people that worked here were very polite and patient. Cesar salad had a little kick a bit too much pepper but none the less was a great. The pizza was piping hot and the dessert was very good. The cookie “pie” wasn’t overy sweet and the cheesecake calzone was delicious. If I’m ever back in town definelty will be back.

So delicious. I ordered from the app since I needed to pick up groceries from the Publix Greenwise up the block. Everything was ready on time and the employees were super sweet. The Cookies and Cream 🍪 dessert pie was so much better than I could have imagined. I am not sure how one created something so tasty. The dessert pie was so flavorful; littered with Oreo cookie magic…and some type of sauce that is surely the nectar of the gods. I also got a 10” half and half 🍕 pizza pie (pineapple and capicola//bell peppers and feta). I had a 30 minute drive home so the pictures don’t even do them justice. Honestly, it was just perfect. Thanks Gaines Street Pies, for the best meal I’ve had in months ❤.

From out of town, pulled in on a whim. Ordered the 18” Derek Sanders veggie pie. WOW, it was awesome.
Fresh, fresh, fresh. Crust was crisp and not doughy at all. Great job. This place is doing it right!

I mean who doesn't love Pizza? Lol. I like the different options they have here for toppings. I've only been here for lunch times but have a bar so I feel that they have a night life as well. Atmosphere here a casual. What you would expect for a pizza hangout spot to grab a quick bite to eat and sit and chat.

Food and service is 5 star , ambience is 4 1/2 and music is about a three maybe even a two . Oh.

Hands down favorite pizza in Tally. Great mid-sized crust with a solid mix of toppings. All time favorite is the Mo-Rockin. Parking is not impossible to find, but on busy weekendnds you may have to pay-park further away on Gaines st.

This is by far the best pizza in town, and honestly a contender for the best pizza I've ever had. Get you those candied jalapenos as a topping and you're set. The garlic knots are also slammin if you're looking for an appetizer.

Very clean place. Always fresh pizza and great service. Great price for such great quality.

It was good pizza. I ordered chicken gorgonzola pizza. A little chilly. So be careful. Pizza box was so cute. Staffs are so kind and friendly.

Love the quaint atmosphere, adjacent to two neighboring bars and a coffee shop, and the pizza slices are good

The staff was helpful and friendly. The food was amazing. Pizza had a nice crust , very flavorful. Wasn’t saturated with grease. We had a slice of pizza and both of their desserts which was awesome as well. Not too sweet just perfect. The family and I had a great memorable time here. Enjoyed the food. Highly recommend this place . If I ever come back to Tallahassee this would definitely be one of my go to places.

Wow. We got the jalepeno poppers, a pepperoni and sausage calzone, and the pesto chicken pizza and ALL three of them were SO GOOD!! I will most definitely be coming again.

Excellent, top-notch service and delicious drinks that aren’t overpriced.
And the pizza is outstanding! Unique menu of tasty specialties

Great little spot to grab some pizza! By the slice or whole! Yummy!

Great college town pizza! Close to the Convention Center too.

Everytime I go here the food is always perfect. The staff are always so kind, even in the late night rush.

I recommend the Bruno Sammartino, it's my favorite, with one of the Ceasar salads on the side.

First time today at Gaines and it was great. I had the lunch special which came with a slice of Pizza + Salad + drink for $7. I also got the garlic knots which was also good. Servers were very kind and i would recommend this place.

Love the vegan and non vegan options
Best happy hour!

Despite the simplicity of its menu and the fact that you first order and pay at the register, then the food comes to you, I found Gaines Street Pies to be a great experience.

From the surprisingly interesting quick conversation with the cashier (FSU Student) to the great tasting pizza, everything was 5 Stars!

While in Tallahassee, and craving for good pizza....Gaines Street will be my place to go.