New York New York Pizza

I was hungry and looking for a pizza spot while my husband was driving, spotted this lil gem and we went in, the first thing was the wonderful smell and we ordered and then the taste OMG absolutely NYC flavor and texture, we will be coming back, definitely 👍 😋 🍕❤

This place has been nothing but amazing for me and my family. Pizza got that old school smacking in the face. Pass it on to smack your mama kind of flavor going on. And the zeppely's oh my god the zeppely's get them with the honey hold on the hazelnut. You'll thank me later. Have a bottle of honey at home. FYI to juice it up a little bit. I could use more honey on them but you're getting five stars buddy because you run a great place and the food pleases me. You got competition though. West shore is comparable man. I would go grab a pepperoni and just scope it out and you'll see what I'm talking about. Be careful though cuz literally every single pizza from that place is different. I'm saying you don't know if it's Papa John's style or New York style from one day to the next. Anyways, good job guys, especially our boys behind the counter. Oh PS, thanks for the pup cup shadow! Loved it!

Ordered on DoorDash so can’t speak about anything other than the pizza. This was my FIRST time having NY pizza (Yes, I have been sleeping under a rock), and it was hands down one of the best pizzas I have had in the area. I can’t say it is the best overall, because you literally can’t compare across different styles, however this pizza had me doing a little seat dance with each bite!! We ordered a classic cheese and it hit the spot :) It had that characteristic foldable quality to it and was thin with just the right sauce to cheese ratio.

Someone needs to explain that this is Florida, not Little Italy. Italian food is not supposed to be this good in Wesley Chapel.
My wife's meatball hero came out first and it looked and smelled so good she had to fend me off with the car keys. Then when my Stromboli arrived I was like, Fugetaboudit, keep the hero.
I worked in all 5 boroughs, never had anything like this.
Wife said it was best meatball hero she had ever eaten.
Nice guys who work here too.

Excellent tasting pizza, best in town. We are from Riverview and prefer the long drive rather than any pizza in Riverview. For some reason the pizza did taste different today, it was good but different from the last couple of visits. Great New York style pizza. We will always keep coming back.

My first time coming to this place.
The pizza is sooo delicious that is worth coming, again and again.
Very cozy place.
The service was great, very attentive and making sure we were pleased with our order. Definitely will visit again !

Ordered from them tonight and the food is amazing, fresh authentic Italian food. The garlic knots were so good, fresh garlic and Parmesan cheese. The wings were Perfect and the pizza was delicious. If you’re looking for good, fresh food, amazing pizza. This is the place.

I used to be a regular customer at Fabellas at the Grove but hate the small piece of chicken cutlet Parmesan. I had yours for the first time and it was so delicious plus l had 2 large pieces of chicken cutlet, a salad and garlic bread. Fabellas lost a customer. I can’t wait to come back and try your lasagna, bake ziti and other food. Thank you NY NY Pizza for giving your customers more for their bucks. See you soon 😍

It's just delicious. They use Grande cheese in their pizza, which makes a huge difference in taste and quality. This is my place for pizza from now on. Great job guys!!!!

Hey Naila....this is not domino's to have an option on different crusts..just saying.... I'm a new yorker,and I've been an uber driver for over 8 years. Believe me I have tried many pizza places in tampa...hands down,NY NY pizza is the best....keep up the good work guys

I’m from Chicago and we have great pizza. This is one of the best pizzas I have ever had!!!! I was concerned that it was going to be rushed since I ordered the food shortly before they close on a Sunday. But it was perfect! It was absolutely delicious and looked beautiful. I will be a repeat customer and will spread the word. I ordered the #3 Grandma pie (pizza). Thank you.

First time trying here and we absolutely LOVED it!! I love that it is thin and crunchy, but also gooey with toppings! Perfect size and such a great price too!! This place is definitely a must try!!! 😋🍕

Editing to add: we haven’t even lived in the area for a month yet and we have been THREE times!

So I grew up in New York and anyone who's lived there knows that they have arguably the best pizza. So obviously with a place called NY NY pizza comes with some high expectations. Wow did they deliver on them...no pun intended! Stringy cheese, check! Greasy and yet filled with flavor, check! It was a taste that took me back to days of old for a moment. Not pictured here are the boneless wings. They were so good that I ate the 10 piece before I remembered to take a photo. Try the mango habanero...it is amazing! Yep, I'm coming back!

I had their pizza at work when New York, New York catered for the staff. Today I ordered a call in order and they delivered! I ordered the Mushroom and Swiss burger 😍🤤🍔🍽... This will be my go to burger from now until! Long story short their is DAMN GOOD and the burger MADE ME A FAN! Way to go, fellas!

Excellent service every time!!! Authentic NY pizza, their pasta dishes are fresh every time and serving sizes are large enough for 2 people! Fairly priced. We eat here often!

MY FAVORITE PIZZA PLACE IN WESLEY CHAPEL. Yes sometimes the bottom is burnt but that is not always the case. Like going to a steak house, it’s not always going to be medium rare. The red sauce on the grandma pizza + pepperoni is amazing. It’s garlicky, thick and flavorful. Pick it up, drive home 15 minute, throw it on a hot pan to crisp up the bottom and it’s amazing. Or just eat it right there. Space is limited but there is indoor and outdoor seating available. A little bit on the priced side but hey, you have other options like little Caesars if want cheap pizza.

Great pizza! I've been searching since I moved to Brooksville. Finally, I found it, amazing! 👏

Adi hands down the best!! Very attentive and makes you feel at home. It's become a Sunday routine to go eat here. Love the garlic knots 🖤

Love this spot! I've been ordering from here since 2018 and I won't stop. My order is typically the same.. hand tossed, pesto base with spinach, goat cheese and italian sausage. Owner is cool peeps.

I've tried a few pizza places, but this place right here 👌I enjoyed, the ingredients, the taste it was so good. 😋 ❤ 😍