Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe

Been living in Wesley Chapel for a year now. We've tried a handful of different pizza spots and have nothing bad to say about any of them.... BUT THIS ONE RIGHT HERE!!!!! Fratelli's has separated themselves from the rest. My families new go to place. The care and attention and quality ingredients. This was an authentic NY pie... and the Grandma Slice.... CHUUUURCH

Exactly what good Italian should be!
Mario was welcoming and friendly, the food was perfect (and I am a major foodie, married to a chef).
We ordered 2 pastas and a pizza and the portions were great.
So reasonably priced too!
Would come back anytime I have the chance.
Thanks again Mario.

The pizza was delicious. Crust was crispy but soft on the inside. The sauce was the perfect ratio to cheese. Best of all, it came out hot! The canolis were amazing, too. The owner was super nice and friendly. Definitely coming back!!

These guys have a great thing going! Service was A+ and the cheese pizza is the best that I’ve had in the south. Bravo to John and Mario for absolutely delicious pizza, cheesecake, and garlic knots. Let me add that the Broccoli Rabe sandwich was awesome — it’s a vegetarian’s dream. ⭐ We’ll definitely be back the next time we’re passing through the Wesley Chapel/Tampa area. Enjoy! 🍕

Great place to eat, the owner is a great guy. I’m from NY and it was my first time eating here been looking for the best pizza spots since I moved down here definitely up there on my list. I got a large Chicken Bacon Ranch delicious ate the whole thing while having a great conversation with the owner.

I recently enjoyed a medium plain New York-style pizza at this place, and I must say it was excellent! As a New Jersey native, I've been on the hunt for authentic, high-quality pizza, and I'm thrilled to say I've found it here. The owner, Mario, welcomed me warmly and assured me I was in the right place for a taste of New York. Mario's New York roots are evident in every bite, and his pizza truly embodies the authentic New York-style pizza experience. If you're a pizza enthusiast like me, don't miss out on this gem – it's the real deal!

The food was amazing! My wife and I had the chicken parm with spaghetti, baked ziti, mozzarella sticks, and garlic knots. Authentic Italian. I highly recommend this place. Can't wait to try the pizza next. Great atmosphere and the owner was a great guy.

Excellent pizza, pasta, salads and much more here. Food is delicious and the staff are warm and friendly. A very clean facility and I understand they do deliveries as well. Convenient location and large portions at a great price. Large selection of beverages including beer if you drink alcohol. Highly recommend

Best pizza in Tampa!! I have tried many and even in Italy recently. I’m a bit of a food critic. When I eat out I expect good food. I thought you just couldn’t find good pizza in Fl until I finally tried fratellis. I’ve been there twice already this week. They have slices ready when you’re in a rush but always get a fresh pizza pie when you can. Lovely quality, the perfect sauce cheese and bread.

Great pizza! Large thin crust as advertised.

Delicious food and huge portions! Great service as well, we asked for waters and the guy gave us bottles of water free! Loved our experience with these “brothers” pizza!

IMO hands down the best NY style pie in Pasco—and I have tried many. Definitely competition for Pinellas and Hillsborough, too. The owner had a 'sort of' local celebrity status in the Bronx.There are photos adorning the wall of him rubbing shoulders with Anthony Bourdain and Andrew Zimmerman. He is very proud of his Abruzzese heritage, as he should be.

The crust is light and airy with good crunch, a little char, and a hint of flavor reminiscent of fermentation. The sauce is bright and inviting. I've had the Pizza Margherita, several NY style pies, and the Grandma pizza. It's excellent work and very reasonably priced. I cannot speak to the rest of the menu as I have not tried it; however, if the same level of dedication and integrity is applied to it, I speculate it is also delightful.

For what it's worth: I was raised in a pizzeria, I have worked as a pizzaiolo many times over the decades, and even owned my own pizzeria. I have spent time in Italy more than once and I have a 900º wood fired oven on my patio. Therefore, I feel qualified to give an informed opinion on pizza.

If you are craving an authentic NY style pie—if you want to fold a slice in half and take a bite of a crispy yet airy crust that tastes like it was made with 'New York water' topped with a rememberable tomato sauce and hot, gooey, stringy mozzarella—then this is your place.

Also, not for nothing as they say in NY, the owner is a legitimately nice person who you can tell likes people and loves what he does. I would rather frequent that type of establishment 100% of the time.

Absolutely loved the Grandma’s pizza!!!! So happy I found this place. Owner is super friendly. Great service and amazing food. Definitely will be coming back!

Fantastic Eggplant Rollatini (a must try). Co-workers truly enjoyed the pizza and salad. Complementary garlic knots were awesome.

Best NY pizza I've ever had! We had a half pepperoni and half sausage. Really good! Love their homemade sauce. And the garlic knots.... Delish!

This is hands-down best pizza place in Wesley chapel. These guys are still famous in NY! Their food is amazing!!!

I have had their pizza since the day they opened it's fantastic. Just recently got spaghetti, stuffed shells and carbonara and it was the best. The owners are awesome and go above and beyond to make sure you are happy.

Stopped in for a slice and some garlic knots after passing this establishment a few times and seeing the good rating. I’m hard to please for pizza coming from Chicago but was willing to try. I am happy we did. The employee a male from Brooklyn was friendly and full of knowledge the grandma slice we tried was amazing and crust cooked to perfection. I love it the knots were great as well. Worth your money to come here.

Unbelievably nice people, great pizza too! Best chicken wings ever. Try them, you will be impressed.

Pizza is HUGE and delicious. I only ate two slices of the Sicilian pizza. This pizza is good for a family/friends get together. Staff was really friendly and great customer service.