Fox Island Creamery

Absolutely amazing!!! They have reconfigured their space and it is so wonderful. I am absolutely coming back again and again. The food is awesome and the staff are as friendly as you can be!! Pretty diverse menu choices and VERY KID FRIENDLY!!! A couple cute games for the kids and real great decor. Very nice views of the lake, gentle background music. Spacious seating. Another great aspect is keeping it local.

I love this place! They have great ice cream selections and the employees are always friendly and helpful. Their fresh bowls are to die for - really filling and fresh. Coconut is the best flavor. It’s conveniently placed in Cosmo’s grocery store which is an added bonus!

Holly was amazing, my girlfriend and I bought two smoothies, we will be back!

What a wonderful place. You can't help feeling but feel young. Ultra clean. Plenty of parking. Plenty of Ice cream.

I had no idea this place moved into Cosmos- we thought it just shut down! Was so happy to go there today and see not only the standard ice cream flavors, but also smoothies, acai bowls, and self-serve. We love Fox Island, and we are thrilled it's still around in a new, improved space!

Best ice cream in the area. Beautiful view of Greenwood Lake indoor and outdoor seating. This is a great place to hit on a summer night. Beautiful friendly atmosphere an amazing ice cream flavors. If you are on the health-conscious side they have frozen yogurt and several gluten-free desserts. I would rather go to this place than the other small ice cream shops in the area that have long lines in the summer. The lines at Fox Island generally move pretty quickly even on their busiest day.

Better than Bellvale Creamery!!! Awesome quality ice cream with extremely creative flavors! Love being able to dock the boat and grab ice cream as well. I probably come here twice a week and am never disappointed! They were even able to cater 30 cups of ice cream for a party I held this weekend. The ice cream stayed the perfect consistency despite being transported!! Prices are very reasonable as well!

We love their ice cream! The chocolate raspberry and seasonal flavors are great. I just wish they would post the weekly flavors online as my fiance only likes chocolate based ice cream and sometimes the options are primarily vanilla based.

We are so happy to finally have a great ice cream frozen yogurt place nearby. This place is always clean the people are so friendly and the ice cream and frozen yogurt are just awesome. There are so many toppings to put on your frozen yogurt and it has a beautiful view of the lake. We love it and have been there many times already

Always very clean, staff always smiling & friendly. Great back porch seating overlooking the lake. Never been disappointed. AND ladies room is GREAT. Clean, roomy, a place to put your purse/ backpack off of the floor. 5 stars every time.

The staff is always friendly and extremely accommodating. The food is great and very reasonably priced, and they have a nice selection of meatless options including the Beyond Burger. Definitely one of my favorite local spots.

Excellent ice cream, baked goods and frozen yogurt but a little pricey. Kids love that they can self serve frozen yogurt and pick from a multitude and toppings. Very clean and nice outdoor deck seating available as well as seating indoors.

Huge variety plus dairy free options!
They have Froyo self serve machines which you dispense into little cups & can top with tons of toppings. They also have sorbet and almond milk sorbet-type stuff. They also have tons of hard-serve ice cream, and baked goods like cupcakes. Also a lovely patio with lake view, and ample parking.

Some of the best and most creative homemade ice creams I've ever had! Super creamy with big flavors! The store is really fun, this place will quickly become a destination location for sure!

Great ice cream with a great view. Their ice cream is super delicious, and nothing is better than eating it on the porch, overlooking the lake. I have not used the bathrooms there, but I imagine they are clean.

Very good homemade ice cream with a lovely deck overlooking Greenwood Lake. Good pricing. Now has a cafe offering seafood that is also very well made. The lobster bisque is to die for.

This site is my number one site. Of all restaurants I know I like it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to that place. Whenever I I need a fair lunchon, this is the place that comes straight to my head. exeptionalgorgeous and diverse food and a large menu.great crew, and great spirit. Also important, the bill is fair. I suggest this spot with great pleasure.

Awesome new addition to the West Milford / Hewitt area! Had some froyo and espresso and both were great! This cafe features ice cream, froyo, cupcakes and espresso. Very clean dining area and friendly staff! One more reason that I am excited for summer now!!!!

Great flavors, chocolate marshmellow milk shakes was delicious. The place has great views, a outside deck, and a walk down alot of stairs to the water. The service was friendly and helpful. I will definitly return.

Did a detour after Appalachian trail for a treat. This place has a beautiful view of a lake, and ice cream was great! I had the brownie and um was it soft and good!